Adjustments in Motor Unit Properties during Fatiguing Contractions after Training

Carolina Vila‐Chã, Deborah Falla, Miguel Velhote Correia, Dario FarinaMedicine 2011 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated how short-term strength and endurance training affect muscle fiber properties and motor unit behavior during fatiguing contractions. The key finding is that both training types improve the maintenance of muscle fiber conduction velocity during fatigue, with endurance training showing a more pronounced effect. This suggests that training can enhance the resilience of muscle fibers to fatigue by improving their electrophysiological properties.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the neuromuscular system adapts to fatigue is crucial for optimizing training and rehabilitation strategies. While it's known that fatigue impairs muscle function, the specific adaptations in motor unit properties (like how quickly electrical signals travel along muscle fibers) during sustained submaximal contractions after different training regimens remain less clear. Previous research has shown differences in fatigue profiles between trained athletes, but longitudinal studies examining how short-term training in previously sedentary individuals impacts these specific electrophysiological adjustments during fatigue are limited. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating how 6 weeks of either strength or endurance training affects motor unit conduction velocity and other related parameters during fatiguing knee extension contractions.

Methods

The study employed a controlled experimental design with three groups of healthy sedentary men: strength training, endurance training, and a control group. Both training groups underwent 18 supervised sessions over 6 weeks.

Key techniques included:

  • Surface and Intramuscular EMG: Used to record electrical activity from the vastus lateralis, vastus medialis obliquus (agonist muscles), and biceps femoris (antagonist muscle). Intramuscular EMG was crucial for isolating individual motor unit signals.
  • Motor Unit Conduction Velocity (MUCV) Estimation: A sophisticated spike-triggered averaging technique using intramuscular EMG as a trigger and surface EMG for signal detection was employed to measure how fast action potentials propagate along muscle fibers. This is a standard but technically demanding method.
  • Fatigue Protocol: Subjects performed sustained isometric knee extensions at 10% and 30% of their maximum voluntary contraction (MVC). The 30% MVC task was continued until task failure (defined as a drop in force >5% for >5s).
  • Force Measurement: An isokinetic dynamometer was used to measure MVC and the force output during fatiguing contractions.
  • Subcutaneous Fat Thickness Measurement: Ultrasound was used to assess fat layer thickness, as this can influence EMG signal detection and MUCV estimation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved direct measurements from human participants.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Training Enhances Fatigue Resilience: Both endurance and strength training improved the ability of muscle fibers to maintain their conduction velocity during sustained contractions. This is a significant finding, as it shows that even short-term training can lead to beneficial electrophysiological adaptations.
  • Endurance Training's Superiority in MUCV Maintenance: While both training types improved MUCV decline during fatigue, endurance training showed a significantly greater reduction in the rate of decline compared to strength training. This suggests endurance training might induce more robust adaptations in the sarcolemmal excitability mechanisms that are challenged during prolonged contractions.
  • Antagonist Muscle Co-activation Changes: Endurance training led to a reduction in the coactivation of the biceps femoris (antagonist) with the vasti muscles (agonists). This suggests improved motor control and coordination, potentially contributing to increased endurance. Strength training did not show this effect.
  • MVC vs. Endurance Trade-off: Endurance training improved time to task failure without significantly changing MVC, while strength training increased MVC but did not significantly affect time to task failure. This highlights the specificity of training adaptations.
  • MUCV Decline Mechanisms: The observed decline in MUCV during fatigue is attributed to alterations in sarcolemmal excitability, likely due to ion flux (K+ efflux, Na+/Cl- influx) and the subsequent depolarization of muscle fiber membranes. The Na+/K+ pump's role in restoring ion gradients is implicated in the training-induced improvements.

Key Results

  • Motor Unit Conduction Velocity (MUCV):
    • The rate of MUCV decline during sustained contractions was reduced after 6 weeks of both endurance and strength training compared to baseline.
  • Endurance training resulted in a significantly lower rate of MUCV decline than strength training at 30% MVC (P < 0.01).
  • Initial MUCV values at 30% MVC increased slightly after both training programs compared to the control group.
  • Motor Performance:
    • Endurance training increased time to task failure by ~29% (P < 0.05) but did not change MVC.
  • Strength training increased MVC by ~17% (P < 0.05) but did not influence time to task failure.
  • EMG Amplitude:
    • The average rectified value of the vasti muscles increased progressively during the 30% MVC fatiguing task for both training groups, reflecting increased motor unit recruitment.
  • The biceps femoris (antagonist) EMG amplitude showed different patterns: it decreased after endurance training but increased after strength training.
  • Coactivation Ratio:
    • Endurance training reduced the biceps femoris-vasti coactivation ratio by ~37% (P < 0.05).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subcutaneous Fat Thickness: While measured, the paper notes that changes in subcutaneous fat thickness were not significant enough to explain the observed MUCV changes.
  • Motor Unit Discharge Rate: The study found that motor unit discharge rates declined during sustained contractions similarly across all groups and was not altered by training. This suggests that the improvements in fatigue resistance are not primarily driven by changes in the firing rate of already recruited motor units, but rather by other mechanisms.
  • Generalizability: The study involved young, sedentary males. Future research could explore these adaptations in different populations (e.g., older adults, athletes, individuals with neuromuscular conditions).
  • Training Duration: The study focused on 6 weeks of training. Longer-term training effects and the persistence of these adaptations could be investigated.
  • Mechanistic Detail: While the Na+/K+ pump is implicated, further research could directly measure its activity or expression to confirm its role. Investigating the specific cellular and molecular changes underlying these adaptations would also be valuable.
  • Central vs. Peripheral Contributions: While the study focused on peripheral adaptations, future work could further disentangle the roles of central (e.g., descending drive) and peripheral factors in training-induced fatigue resistance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Short-term strength and endurance training induces alterations of the electrophysiological membrane properties of the muscle fiber. In particular, endurance training lowers the rate of decline of motor unit conduction velocity during sustained contractions more than strength training.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{vilacha2011adjustments,
  author = {Carolina Vila‐Chã and Deborah Falla and Miguel Velhote Correia and Dario Farina},
  title = {{Adjustments in Motor Unit Properties during Fatiguing Contractions after Training}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1249/mss.0b013e318235d81d},
}
Figure