Adhesive force measurement of steady-state water nano-meniscus: Effective surface tension at nanoscale

Soyoung Kwon, Bongsu Kim, Sangmin An, Wanhee Lee, Ho‐Young Kwak, Wonho JheScientific 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel experimental method to measure the effective surface tension of nanoscale water menisci. They found that surface tension significantly decreases at small radii of curvature (below 25 nm), offering a potential explanation for long-standing discrepancies in nanoscale water behavior and paving the way for better understanding of biological processes and material design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Surface tension (ST) is a fundamental property of liquids, but its behavior at the nanoscale has been a persistent puzzle. While classical theories predict that ST should decrease for curved interfaces (like bubbles, droplets, and menisci) compared to a flat surface, experimental verification has been challenging. This discrepancy is particularly problematic because nanoscale water phenomena, such as nucleation and phase transitions, are crucial in many scientific and engineering fields, including atmospheric science, biology, and materials science. Existing experimental results and theoretical predictions for these phenomena often don't align, suggesting a missing piece in our understanding of nanoscale ST. This paper aims to experimentally quantify the effective surface tension of a nanoscale water meniscus under controlled conditions to shed light on this issue.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated hybrid force-measurement system combining a tapping-mode, amplitude-modulation atomic force microscope (AFM) with a microelectromechanical system (MEMS) sensor. This setup allows for the simultaneous measurement of both static and dynamic forces associated with a capillary-condensed water nano-meniscus formed between an AFM tip and a MEMS surface.

The core of their method involves:

  1. Nano-meniscus formation: A water nano-meniscus is formed by capillary condensation as the AFM tip approaches the MEMS surface.
  2. Force measurement: The AFM measures dynamic forces (elasticity and damping), which help determine the precise tip-surface contact point. The MEMS sensor then measures the full-range capillary force exerted by the meniscus.
  3. Young-Laplace equation application: The experimental force data is analyzed using the Young-Laplace equation, which relates capillary pressure to surface tension and curvature. Crucially, the authors assume a constant radius of curvature (ROC) for the meniscus during slow retraction, a condition they experimentally validate.
  4. Effective ST determination: By fitting the experimental force curves to the theoretical model derived from the Young-Laplace equation, they can uniquely determine the effective surface tension ($\gamma_m$) for a given meniscus ROC ($r_m$).

A key innovation is the slow retraction speed (<1 nm/s) of the MEMS plate, which ensures the meniscus remains in a steady-state, thermodynamically equilibrated condition with a constant ROC, allowing for accurate force measurements and ST determination.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using a custom-built AFM-MEMS system and controlled environmental conditions (ambient pressure, room temperature, ~60% relative humidity).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Surface tension is not constant at the nanoscale: The most significant finding is that the effective surface tension of water is not a constant bulk value when confined to nanoscale curvatures. It demonstrably decreases as the radius of curvature shrinks.
  • A unified explanation for nanoscale water discrepancies: The observed curvature-dependent ST provides a potential resolution for the long-standing disagreements between experimental observations and theoretical predictions for various nanoscale water phenomena (nano-bubbles, nano-droplets, and nano-menisci).
  • The importance of experimental control: The paper highlights the critical role of experimental conditions, particularly the slow retraction speed, in achieving a steady-state, constant ROC meniscus, which is essential for accurate ST measurements.
  • "Effective" ST vs. "Genuine" ST: The authors acknowledge that the measured ST is an "effective" value, potentially influenced by factors beyond pure surface tension (like van der Waals forces, hydration layers, or double-layer forces). However, they argue that this effective ST is what governs the observed nanoscale phenomena.

Key Results

  • The effective surface tension ($\gamma_m$) of a water nano-meniscus decreases significantly with decreasing radius of curvature ($r_m$).
  • At $r_m$ below 25 nm, $\gamma_m$ drops to less than 20% of the bulk water surface tension (approximately 71.97 mN/m).
  • Above an ROC of approximately 130 nm, the effective ST approaches the bulk value, consistent with thermodynamic predictions for curved interfaces.
  • For a specific example, at $r_m \approx 21.6$ nm, the effective ST was found to be approximately 1/8th of the bulk value.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Effective" Surface Tension: The authors acknowledge that the measured ST is an "effective" value. Separating out other contributing forces (e.g., van der Waals, electrostatic) to isolate the "genuine" surface tension remains a challenge for future work.
  • Theoretical Development: The findings are expected to stimulate further theoretical development to better understand the microscopic origins of ST at the nanoscale.
  • Broader Applications: The research opens avenues for understanding ST-related phenomena in biological systems (e.g., protein folding, cluster growth) and for designing nano-biomaterials that leverage the unique properties of nano-menisci.
  • Investigating other liquids: While this study focuses on water, future work could explore the curvature dependence of ST for other liquids.

Summary updated

Abstract

When the surface of water is curved at nanoscale as a bubble, droplet and meniscus, its surface tension is expected to be smaller than that of planar interface, which still awaits experimental studies. Here, we report static and dynamic force spectroscopy that measures the capillary force of a single nanoscale water meniscus at constant curvature condition. Based on the Young-Laplace equation, the results are used to obtain the effective surface tension (ST) of the meniscus, which decreases to less than 20% of the bulk value at the radius-of-curvature (ROC) below 25 nm, while indicating the bulk behaviour above ~130 nm ROC. Interestingly, such a possibility provides a qualitative resolution of the unsettled discrepancies between experiments and theories in the thermodynamic activation processes for the mentioned three types of nano-curvatured water. Our results may not only lead to development of microscopic theories of ST as well as further experimental investigations, but also help better understanding of the ST-induced nanoscale dynamics such as cluster growth or protein folding, and the ST-controlled design of nano-biomaterials using the nano-meniscus.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kwon2018adhesive,
  author = {Soyoung Kwon and Bongsu Kim and Sangmin An and Wanhee Lee and Ho‐Young Kwak and Wonho Jhe},
  title = {{Adhesive force measurement of steady-state water nano-meniscus: Effective surface tension at nanoscale}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-018-26893-5},
}
Figure