Adaptive production of fighter males: queens of the antCardiocondylaadjust the sex ratio under local mate competition

Sylvia Cremer, Jürgen HeınzeProceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences 2002 · DOI

TL;DR

Ant queens in the species Cardiocondyla obscurior adaptively adjust the sex ratio of their offspring, producing more "fighter" males when local mate competition is high (i.e., when multiple queens are present). This finding supports the Local Mate Competition (LMC) theory even in social insects, demonstrating that queens, not workers, are the primary drivers of this sex allocation strategy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, the prevailing theory explaining female-biased sex ratios in insects has been Hamilton's concept of Local Mate Competition (LMC). LMC posits that when males don't disperse far from their birthplace and compete for mates locally, it's evolutionarily advantageous for females to produce more daughters than sons. However, applying this theory to social insects like ants has been challenging. In social Hymenoptera, a non-reproducing worker caste exists, and their relatedness to offspring can lead to different optimal sex ratios compared to the queen (due to haplodiploidy). This "worker control" hypothesis, driven by relatedness asymmetry, often overshadows LMC. Furthermore, the typical mating systems in social insects, where mating often occurs during large nuptial flights, seem to reduce the conditions for LMC. This paper investigates Cardiocondyla obscurior, an ant species with a unique life history: dimorphic males (one disperser, one fighter) and the ability to have single or multiple queens in a colony. This system provides a rare opportunity to test the relative importance of LMC versus worker control in a social insect context.

Methods

The researchers conducted two main experiments using Cardiocondyla obscurior ants collected from Brazil.

  1. Colony-level sex allocation: They established experimental colonies with varying numbers of queens: single queens (monogyny), multiple related queens (polygyny with related queens), and multiple unrelated queens (polygyny with unrelated queens). They then monitored the production of female sexuals, ergatoid (fighter) males, and winged (disperser) males.
  2. Identifying the controlling party and cues: In a second experiment, they manipulated monogynous colonies by adding eggs from either monogynous or polygynous "donor" colonies. This created a situation with a single queen but brood heterogeneity. This allowed them to test whether queens or workers were adjusting the sex ratio and what cues (queen number vs. brood heterogeneity) they might be using.

Statistical analyses, including one-way ANOVAs and Bonferroni-corrected post-hoc tests, were used to compare sex allocation patterns across different experimental groups.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental manipulation of ant colonies rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LMC reigns supreme in this social ant: Despite the presence of workers and the potential for worker control, the study strongly supports LMC as the primary driver of sex ratio adjustment in C. obscurior.
  • Queens are the architects of sex ratio: The experiments clearly indicate that queens, not workers, are the ones making the decisions about sex allocation in response to colony structure.
  • Fighter males are the key: The adaptive shift in sex ratio under high LMC conditions primarily manifests as an increase in the production of ergatoid (fighter) males, while the number of disperser males remains relatively constant.
  • Queen number is the cue: Queens appear to directly "count" or estimate the number of other queens in the colony as the cue for adjusting their offspring sex ratio. Brood heterogeneity alone wasn't sufficient to trigger the same adaptive response.
  • A unified theory is needed: The findings highlight that LMC and worker control aren't mutually exclusive and that a comprehensive understanding of sex allocation requires considering multiple evolutionary forces.

Key Results

  • Polygyny leads to more fighter males: When colonies had multiple queens (polygynous), the production of ergatoid males significantly increased compared to single-queen colonies (monogynous). This increase was about 92% in terms of numerical sex allocation.
  • Disperser males are unaffected: The production of winged, disperser males did not differ significantly across monogynous and polygynous colony structures.
  • Female sexuals decrease with polygyny: As ergatoid male production increased under polygyny, the proportion of female sexuals consequently decreased.
  • Manipulation experiment confirms queen control: Colonies where eggs from polygynous donors were added (treatment B, simulating higher LMC) showed a significant increase in ergatoid male production, mirroring the results of the first experiment. Colonies receiving eggs from monogynous donors (treatment A) did not show this increase, suggesting that the brood's origin (and thus the implied colony structure of the donor) was the critical factor, and that queens were responding to this.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Morph determination mechanism: The paper acknowledges that the exact mechanism by which queens determine male morph (egg stage vs. later larval development) is still unknown. Future research could investigate this, exploring blastogenic vs. other forms of caste determination.
  • Proximate cues for queens: While the study identified queen number as the likely cue, understanding the precise "proximate mechanisms" by which queens detect colony composition and relatedness would be valuable for broader kin selection studies.
  • Worker influence in donor colonies: The authors note that while workers in the focal colonies didn't seem to manipulate sex ratios in the second experiment, it's possible workers in the donor colonies had already influenced the sex ratio of the eggs before they were transferred. This is a subtle point but worth further investigation.
  • Broader applicability of LMC: The paper suggests that LMC's role in social insects might be underestimated, even in species with seemingly less conducive mating systems. Future work could explore this in other social insect species.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hamilton's concept of local mate competition (LMC) is the standard model to explain female-biased sex ratios in solitary Hymenoptera. In social Hymenoptera, however, LMC has remained controversial, mainly because manipulation of sex allocation by workers in response to relatedness asymmetries is an additional powerful mechanism of female bias. Furthermore, the predominant mating systems in the social insects are thought to make LMC unlikely. Nevertheless, several species exist in which dispersal of males is limited and mating occurs in the nest. Some of these species, such as the ant Cardiocondyla obscurior, have evolved dimorphic males, with one morph being specialized for dispersal and the other for fighting with nest-mate males over access to females. Such life history, combining sociality and alternative reproductive tactics in males, provides a unique opportunity to test the power of LMC as a selective force leading to female-biased sex ratios in social Hymenoptera. We show that, in concordance with LMC predictions, an experimental increase in queen number leads to a shift in sex allocation in favour of non-dispersing males, but does not influence the proportion of disperser males. Furthermore, we can assign this change in sex allocation at the colony level to the queens and rule out worker manipulation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cremer2002adaptive,
  author = {Sylvia Cremer and Jürgen Heınze},
  title = {{Adaptive production of fighter males: queens of the ant<i>Cardiocondyla</i>adjust the sex ratio under local mate competition}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.1098/rspb.2001.1892},
}
Figure