TL;DR
This paper introduces a novel distributed economic control strategy for microgrid clusters (MGCs) that minimizes operating costs by equalizing marginal costs across all distributed energy resources (DERs), even considering line losses. It also incorporates adaptive control for power and storage capacity limits, and uses consensus-based secondary controllers to maintain system frequency and voltage stability without a central controller.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Interconnecting multiple microgrids (MGs) into a microgrid cluster (MGC) offers enhanced reliability and potential cost savings. However, traditional control methods, like droop control, often lead to higher operating costs because they distribute power based on capacity ratios rather than actual generation costs. This is particularly problematic when DERs have varying cost characteristics. Furthermore, existing methods often neglect line losses between MGs, which can be significant in collective operation, and may not adequately handle the power limits of DERs or the crucial capacity constraints of energy storage systems. The challenge is to achieve optimal economic dispatch across an MGC while ensuring system stability and robustness, all without relying on a centralized control system, which can be a single point of failure.
Methods
The core of this paper is an adaptive marginal costs-based economic droop control. Instead of traditional droop control that uses capacity ratios, this method aims to equalize the marginal costs of all DERs within the MGC. This is achieved through a consensus-based adaptive controller that dynamically adjusts cost coefficients to account for DER power limits and, importantly, storage capacity constraints.
Key methodological components include:
- Marginal Cost Calculation: The paper defines and calculates marginal costs for conventional generators, renewable generators, and storage devices, explicitly considering line losses in the collective mode of MGC operation.
- Adaptive Control for Power Limits: For DERs reaching their maximum or minimum power output, virtual cost coefficients are adjusted to maintain the desired marginal cost equalization.
- Storage Capacity Constraint Handling: A novel aspect is the inclusion of storage capacity limits. If a storage unit reaches 80% charge or 20% discharge capacity, its control is adapted to gradually reduce its power injection/withdrawal to zero, preventing overcharging or deep discharge.
- Consensus-Based Secondary Control: To rapidly restore system frequency and voltage magnitudes after disturbances, distributed secondary controllers (DSFC and DSVC) are employed. These controllers use a sparse communication network, interacting only with neighboring DERs.
- Distributed Architecture: The entire control scheme is decentralized, eliminating the need for a central controller and enhancing reliability through local interactions and consensus algorithms.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulations using Matlab/Simulink with parameters defined in Table 1 and network configurations shown in Figure 3.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Marginal Cost Equality is Key to Economic Dispatch: The fundamental insight is that achieving optimal economic operation in an MGC hinges on ensuring all DERs operate at the same marginal cost, a principle extended here to include line losses.
- Line Loss Matters in Collective Mode: Explicitly accounting for line losses between sub-microgrids is crucial for accurate economic dispatch when MGs are interconnected, leading to more realistic cost optimization.
- Storage Capacity is a Critical Constraint: The paper highlights that simply treating storage as a power source/sink is insufficient. Incorporating state-of-charge limits is vital for safe and efficient operation, and the proposed adaptive control effectively manages this.
- Decentralization Enhances Robustness: By relying on local communication and consensus, the proposed strategy avoids the vulnerabilities of a central controller, making the MGC more resilient to communication failures.
- Adaptive Control for Power Limits is Essential: The adaptive adjustment of cost coefficients to handle DER power limits is critical for achieving the target marginal cost equality when DERs are operating at their boundaries.
Key Results
- Cost Reduction: The proposed adaptive marginal cost-based control achieved significant cost reductions compared to traditional droop control, with savings up to 34.99% in simulations. This is attributed to better utilization of cheaper DERs and maximizing renewable energy output.
- Frequency and Voltage Stability: The distributed secondary controllers effectively restored system frequency to the nominal value (50 Hz) and regulated voltage magnitudes to around the rated value (311 V), with small errors (within 3 V) despite network impedances.
- Effective Handling of DER Limits: Simulations demonstrated that the adaptive control successfully managed DER power limits and storage capacity constraints, ensuring optimal operation and preventing undesirable states.
- Robustness to Communication Delays: While communication delays can affect transient performance (e.g., overshoot), the proposed strategy remains effective even with delays up to 10 ms, indicating good robustness.
Limitations and Future Work
- Communication Delay Impact: The paper acknowledges that communication delays can affect transient performance (overshoot) and suggests that future work should focus on determining how to mitigate these effects.
- Reactive Power Sharing: While voltage regulation is addressed, the paper notes that reactive power is not shared by capacity ratio, and further discussion on this aspect could be beneficial.
- Model Simplifications: The paper mentions simplifying assumptions for AC microgrids (e.g., resistive line impedance, neglecting earth branches) which might limit applicability in certain scenarios.
The authors suggest that future research should investigate methods to minimize the impact of communication delays on the overall system performance.
Summary updated