Adaptive inference on general graphical models

Umut A. Acar, Alexander T. Ihler, Ramgopal R. Mettu, Özgür SümerUAI 2008

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "adaptive inference" technique for general graphical models, enabling faster updates and marginal computations by leveraging existing model structure. This approach significantly speeds up repeated inference tasks, particularly in domains like protein structure prediction where models are frequently modified.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world applications involve repeatedly performing inference on graphical models that are only slightly modified. For instance, in machine learning, we might update a model based on new data, or in bioinformatics, we might simulate mutations in a protein structure. The traditional approach is to re-run inference from scratch, which can be computationally prohibitive when thousands of such modifications are needed. Existing "adaptive inference" methods are often limited to tree-structured models or only support changes to observed evidence. This paper tackles the challenge of efficiently updating and querying inference on general graphical models, which can contain cycles ("loopy" graphs).

Methods

The core of the proposed method is a hierarchical clustering of the factor graph, built upon a user-provided spanning tree. This clustering partitions the graph into nested subgraphs (clusters), with each cluster having a defined boundary and a "cluster function" representing a partial marginalization of its factors. The key innovation lies in how this hierarchical structure is maintained and utilized:

  • Hierarchical Clustering: The graph is decomposed into a spanning tree and "non-tree" edges. The clustering is built bottom-up, creating a tree of clusters with an expected logarithmic depth.
  • Cluster Functions: For each cluster, a function is computed that summarizes the interactions within that cluster, considering only variables on its boundary.
  • Adaptive Updates: Changes to the model (replacing factors, adding/deleting edges) are handled by updating only the relevant parts of the hierarchical clustering and recomputing affected cluster functions. This avoids recomputing everything from scratch.
  • Efficient Queries: Marginal distributions for variables are computed by traversing the cluster tree from the root down to the relevant cluster, leveraging the pre-computed cluster functions.

The authors adapt techniques from RC-Trees (previously for tree-structured models) to handle general graphs by distinguishing between "tree" edges (from the spanning tree) and "non-tree" edges.

Datasets

The paper evaluates its approach on two types of data:

  • Synthetic Data: Randomly generated factor graphs with varying sizes (up to 1000 variables) were used to create loopy structures by adding cycles to a base Markov chain.
  • Protein Structure Data: Factor graphs were constructed from five moderately-sized protein backbone structures, representing interactions between amino acids. These were drawn from the SCWRL benchmark.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Leveraging Structure for Speed: The fundamental insight is that by carefully organizing computations around a hierarchical decomposition of the graph, we can avoid redundant work when the model changes slightly.
  • Spanning Tree Choice Matters: The choice of the initial spanning tree significantly impacts the efficiency of the adaptive inference process, analogous to how triangulation affects junction tree algorithms. A "good" spanning tree can keep the "measure" (related to graph cuts) low, leading to faster computations.
  • Generalizing Tree-Based Methods: The paper successfully extends adaptive inference techniques, previously limited to trees, to handle general graphs with cycles by intelligently managing non-tree edges within the hierarchical clustering framework.
  • Logarithmic Complexity for Updates: The ability to perform updates and queries in expected logarithmic time with respect to the graph size is a major achievement, offering substantial speedups over naive recomputation.

Key Results

The proposed adaptive inference algorithm demonstrates significant performance improvements:

  • Synthetic Data: Average update times were found to be one to three orders of magnitude faster than performing inference from scratch. Build times were comparable to standard junction tree methods.
  • Protein Structure Data: For moderately-sized proteins, queries and updates achieved speedups of 3-18 times compared to inference from scratch. This highlights the practical utility of the approach in complex biological modeling.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Measure Dependency: The theoretical bounds on computation time depend exponentially on the "measure" of the graph with respect to the chosen spanning tree. While the paper shows how to keep this measure small through careful spanning tree selection, it remains a factor.
  • Larger Proteins: For very large protein structures, the simple choice of the protein backbone as the spanning tree resulted in graphs with too high a treewidth for efficient processing by either their algorithm or standard sum-product.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring alternative methods for choosing the spanning tree, particularly for large proteins, potentially based on rigid secondary structure elements. They also mention that while the presentation focuses on single changes, simultaneous multiple changes can be handled.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{acar2008adaptive,
  author = {Umut A. Acar and Alexander T. Ihler and Ramgopal R. Mettu and Özgür Sümer},
  title = {{Adaptive inference on general graphical models}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2008},
}
Figure