Adaptive Importance Sampling for Bayesian Inference in Gaussian Process models

Dejan Petelin, Matej Gašperin, Václav ŠmídlIFAC 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Bayesian inference algorithm for Gaussian Process (GP) models called AIS-GP. It tackles the challenge of accurately estimating hyperparameters by using an adaptive importance sampling technique, which allows for more robust inference, especially when the hyperparameter posterior is multi-modal. This approach leads to improved predictive performance and better uncertainty quantification compared to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gaussian Processes (GPs) are powerful tools for modeling complex systems, widely used in areas like time-series prediction and control. A core aspect of GP modeling is inferring "hyperparameters" that define the covariance function, which in turn shapes the model's behavior. Ideally, this inference should be fully Bayesian, considering all uncertainty in the hyperparameters. However, the integration required for this Bayesian inference is often computationally intractable, especially when the posterior distribution of hyperparameters is broad or has multiple peaks (multi-modal).

Traditional approaches often resort to approximations, such as using a single point estimate (like the Maximum Likelihood estimate) for the hyperparameters. While computationally simpler, this "type II maximum likelihood" approach sacrifices the full Bayesian treatment, potentially leading to over-fitting and an underestimation of uncertainty. Other methods like Monte Carlo approximations exist, but their efficiency heavily relies on choosing a good "proposal" distribution, which is difficult to do in practice. This paper addresses the need for a more robust and computationally feasible method for Bayesian hyperparameter inference in GPs, particularly in scenarios where the posterior is complex.

Methods

The paper proposes an Adaptive Importance Sampling (AIS) for Gaussian Processes (AIS-GP) algorithm. The core idea is to use importance sampling (IS) to approximate the intractable integral over hyperparameters. However, instead of using a fixed proposal distribution, AIS adaptively updates the parameters of the proposal distribution based on previously drawn samples. This allows the proposal to "learn" the shape of the target posterior distribution, even if it's multi-modal.

Key aspects of the method include:

  • Adaptive Proposal: The algorithm iteratively draws samples from a parametric proposal distribution (here, a Gaussian) and uses these samples to update the proposal's mean and covariance. This is done recursively, allowing for efficient updates.
  • Forgetting Mechanism: A "forgetting factor" is introduced to give more weight to recent samples, making the algorithm more responsive to changes and less sensitive to initial poor choices of proposal parameters.
  • Laplace Approximation Initialization: To provide a reasonable starting point for the adaptive process, the algorithm optionally uses a Laplace approximation to find an initial estimate for the hyperparameters and their covariance. This helps to guide the AIS towards promising regions of the parameter space.
  • Moment Matching: After sampling, the resulting mixture of predictions is projected back into a single Gaussian using moment matching. This ensures the output format is consistent with standard GP predictions and allows for recursive use in applications like dynamic systems modeling.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the proposed AIS-GP algorithm on a synthetic regression problem. The dataset consists of:

  • 20 data points for training.
  • 80 data points for validation.

The data is generated from a GP model with a specific covariance function and is contaminated with white noise. Notably, the noise level is varied: 90% of the data points have a standard deviation of 0.1, while the remaining 10% have a standard deviation of 1. This setup is designed to create a scenario with a multi-modal hyperparameter posterior, making it challenging for standard methods.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: AIS-GP effectively bridges the gap between computationally expensive but theoretically sound Bayesian inference and the practical approximations often used in GP modeling.
  • Handling Multi-modality: The adaptive nature of AIS is crucial for handling multi-modal hyperparameter posteriors. Traditional methods can get stuck in local optima, leading to poor model choices, whereas AIS can explore and cover multiple peaks.
  • Improved Uncertainty: By better capturing the hyperparameter posterior, AIS-GP leads to more accurate uncertainty estimates in predictions, which is vital for decision-making in control and other applications.
  • Efficiency vs. Accuracy: The paper demonstrates that AIS-GP achieves better predictive accuracy than other methods (ML, IS, point-mass) while using the same computational budget (number of samples).

Key Results

The paper compares AIS-GP against Type II Maximum Likelihood (ML), standard Importance Sampling (IS) with proposals from individual optima, and a uniform point-mass approximation. All methods were run using 10,000 samples.

  • Error Measures: The AIS-GP algorithm achieved the lowest error measures, specifically the lowest Standardized Mean Squared Error (SMSE) and Mean Standardized Log Loss (MSLL).
  • AIS: SMSE = 0.321127, MSLL = -0.556568
    • For comparison, the best IS result (IS2, using a proposal from the second optimum) was SMSE = 0.506627, MSLL = -0.419936.
  • Outperforming IS: AIS systematically outperformed standard IS, even when IS used proposals derived from the true optima. This highlights the benefit of adaptively adjusting the proposal.
  • Qualitative Improvement: Figures in the paper visually demonstrate how the AIS proposal distribution effectively adapts to cover both peaks of the multi-modal target density, unlike fixed proposals that only cover one peak well. This leads to better coverage of the true hyperparameter uncertainty.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Initialization Sensitivity: While the algorithm is designed to be adaptive, the paper acknowledges that the choice of initial statistics for the proposal can still impact inference, especially in challenging cases.
  • Computational Cost: Although more efficient than full Bayesian inference, AIS-GP is still more computationally intensive than single-point approximations like ML-II.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest extending the AIS-GP approach to GP models for dynamical systems (state-space models). This is a promising direction, as these models often suffer from insufficient training data and overfitting, where robust hyperparameter inference is critical. The paper also notes that the benefits of AIS are expected to be even greater in higher-dimensional problems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{petelin2014adaptive,
  author = {Dejan Petelin and Matej Gašperin and Václav Šmídl},
  title = {{Adaptive Importance Sampling for Bayesian Inference in Gaussian Process models}},
  booktitle = {IFAC},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3182/20140824-6-za-1003.02352},
}
Figure