Adaptive dual closed-loop trajectory tracking control for a wheeled mobile robot on uneven ground

Li Li, Jiaping Qiang, Yuanqing Xia, Weiqun CaoResearch Square 2023 · DOI

This paper presents a robust control framework for Wheeled Mobile Robots (WMRs) navigating the unpredictable "real world"—specifically, uneven terrain where bumps, dips, and unmodeled motor dynamics usually degrade performance.

TL;DR

The authors develop a dual closed-loop control strategy that combines an adaptive kinematic controller with an improved fixed-time disturbance observer. This approach allows a mobile robot to track trajectories on uneven ground with high precision, ensuring that errors converge to zero within a guaranteed timeframe regardless of the initial state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Most theoretical models for wheeled robots assume a perfectly flat, "frictionless vacuum" style environment. In reality, robots face "lumped disturbances": a mix of uneven ground, friction, air resistance, and the internal complexities of DC motors.

Standard controllers often struggle with two things:

  1. Parameter Tuning: Classical kinematic controllers require manual tuning of gains that are difficult to optimize for varying conditions.
  2. Convergence Speed: Many existing observers (which estimate the robot's state) are "finite-time," meaning the time they take to stabilize depends on how far off the robot is initially. If the initial error is large, the recovery is slow.

Methods

The researchers propose a Dual Closed-Loop Control (DCLC) strategy backed by a more sophisticated dynamic model that includes DC motor characteristics.

  • Outer Loop: Adaptive Kinematic Controller (AKC). Instead of fixed gains, the AKC uses an adaptive law to estimate the necessary parameters on the fly. This improves position accuracy and removes the "tuning headache" for the engineer.
  • Inner Loop: Adaptive Non-singular Terminal Sliding Mode Control (ANTSMC). This handles the velocity tracking. It is "non-singular," meaning it avoids the mathematical "divide-by-zero" pitfalls common in standard sliding mode control, and it ensures velocity errors hit zero in finite time.
  • The "Secret Sauce": Improved FXESO. They designed an improved Fixed-Time Extended State Observer (FXESO). Unlike standard observers, its convergence time is bounded by a constant—it will stabilize within a set window of time no matter how large the initial disturbance is. Crucially, they simplified the FXESO to have fewer tuning parameters, making it more practical for real-world engineering.

Datasets

As is standard in robotics control research, the authors did not use a static dataset but rather evaluated their system using Reference Trajectories in both simulation and physical experiments:

  • Circular Trajectory: Used for initial performance testing.
  • Lemniscate (Figure-Eight) Curve: Used for complex path-tracking validation.
  • Hardware Setup: The physical tests were performed on a custom WMR equipped with an Ultra-Wide Bandwidth (UWB) module for positioning, an IMU for orientation, and brushless DC motors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fixed-Time is the Goal: The transition from "finite-time" to "fixed-time" observers is a major leap for reliability. It allows engineers to guarantee a recovery window (e.g., "the robot will always correct its path within 0.5 seconds"), which is vital for safety-critical applications.
  • Motor Dynamics Matter: By integrating the DC motor model into the control loop rather than treating the robot as a simple velocity vector, the controller accounts for the physical lag and torque limits of the actual hardware.
  • Simplification for Implementation: A recurring theme in the paper is reducing the number of parameters. By making the FXESO easier to tune, the authors bridge the gap between complex control theory and practical deployment.

Key Results

The proposed DCLC was tested against Classical Kinematic Controllers (CKC) and various other observers (LESO and FTESO).

  • Faster Recovery: In simulations, when a step disturbance (simulating a bump) was introduced, the improved FXESO converged significantly faster than linear or finite-time alternatives.
  • Steady-State Accuracy: In physical experiments tracking a lemniscate path, the proposed method showed superior steady-state accuracy in $x$ and $y$ coordinates compared to existing methods in the literature (specifically citing improvements over the method in reference [12]).
  • Finite-Time Velocity Convergence: The ANTSMC successfully drove velocity errors to zero rapidly, maintaining stability even on rough pavement.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors identify one primary trade-off: Initial Delay. Because the system relies on an adaptive method to "learn" the parameters, there is a slight time delay during the initial dynamic response stage (roughly the first 10 seconds of operation).

Future Work: The team aims to develop a method to accelerate this parameter adjustment phase, reducing the initial response time without sacrificing the robustness of the fixed-time observer.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> In this paper, trajectory tracking problem is investigated for a wheeled mobile robot (WMR) on uneven ground. Firstly, a more accurate dynamic model is developed by introducing a direct current motor model. Secondly, an improved fixed-time extended state observer (FXESO) is proposed to estimate the system states and the lumped disturbance containing unmodeled dynamics of the system and uneven ground. Thirdly, a dual closed-loop control (DCLC) strategy is proposed. For the outer loop control, adaptive kinematic controller (AKC) is presented, which reduces the difficulty of parameter tuning and improves the steady-state accuracy of position errors compared to the classical kinematic controller. For the inner loop control, a dynamic controller based on adaptive non-singular terminal sliding mode control (ANTSMC) and improved FXESO is designed, in which the velocity errors converge to zero in finite time. Finally, numerical simulations and experiment results are carried out to illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed control strategy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023adaptive,
  author = {Li Li and Jiaping Qiang and Yuanqing Xia and Weiqun Cao},
  title = {{Adaptive dual closed-loop trajectory tracking control for a wheeled mobile robot on uneven ground}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3002413/v1},
}
Figure