Adaptive Discretization for Evaluation of Probabilistic Cost Functions

Christoph Zimmer, Danny Driess, Mona Meister, Duy Nguyen-TuongAISTATS 2020

Abstract

Evaluating the safety of continuous robot paths typically involves a trade-off between discretization resolution and computational speed. Coarse discretization may overlook thin obstacles, while fine discretization incurs high computational costs. This paper introduces an adaptive discretization scheme that leverages Gaussian Processes (GPs) to intelligently select evaluation points. By iteratively refining the path at locations with the highest probability of being unsafe, the method provides theoretical safety guarantees ($\epsilon$-safe) with significantly reduced computational overhead.

Introduction

In autonomous robotics, ensuring that a candidate path is collision-free is paramount. Because paths are continuous and computation is discrete, safety is usually checked at specific points. The standard equidistant discretization approach is often inefficient or unreliable, particularly when dealing with thin obstacles or complex safety cost functions. This research addresses the efficiency-accuracy gap by automatically determining the necessary discretization points to guarantee a specific safety level.

Methods

The proposed framework integrates probabilistic learning with iterative optimization. Gaussian Processes are employed to learn safety cost functions from environmental observations, providing both predictions and uncertainty estimates. The adaptive discretization algorithm begins with minimal points (start and end) and iteratively inserts new points where the risk of being unsafe is maximal. This process continues until the remaining risk falls below a user-defined threshold $\epsilon$.

Iterative path refinement using adaptive discretization.

Experimental Evaluation

The approach was tested in several simulated environments designed to challenge standard planners:

  • Thin Obstacle Scenario: An environment with an obstacle only 0.01 units thick, which standard equidistant planners often miss.
  • Adaptation to Data: Scenarios where the planner must adjust its path as it learns more about the environment through varying observations.
  • 2D Robot Exploration: Real-time roadmap construction in a workspace with sharp-cornered obstacles.

Results and Discussion

The adaptive method demonstrated significant performance gains. In the thin obstacle task, it was approximately 17 times faster than a fine equidistant grid while maintaining equivalent safety levels. Remarkably, the adaptive algorithm often required only 3 points to identify an unsafe path, whereas the equidistant version failed to do so even with 200 points in many cases.

Path planning result with a safety probability threshold of p=0.80.

The use of GP variance allows the algorithm to focus on uncertain regions, effectively performing a local search for potential collisions. Furthermore, the authors provide a proof of convergence, ensuring that the safety estimate becomes increasingly accurate as points are added, never overestimating safety during refinement.

Conclusion

While effective, the method's reliance on Gaussian Processes introduces $O(n^3)$ complexity, which may limit scalability in high-dimensional spaces or extremely large environments. Future work will explore Sparse GPs and more efficient sampling techniques like Expectation Propagation to further enhance real-time performance in complex robotic systems.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zimmer2020adaptive,
  author = {Christoph Zimmer and Danny Driess and Mona Meister and Duy Nguyen-Tuong},
  title = {{Adaptive Discretization for Evaluation of Probabilistic Cost Functions}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Statistics},
  year = {2020},
}
Figure