Adaptive coding in the human brain: Distinct object features are encoded by overlapping voxels in frontoparietal cortex

Jade Jackson, Alexandra WoolgarCortex 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how the human brain flexibly adapts to changing task demands by examining "voxel reuse" in the multiple demand (MD) system. The findings suggest that individual voxels within the MD network are more likely to contribute to multiple neural codes for different object features than expected by chance, indicating a flexible and adaptive coding mechanism.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Our ability to navigate a complex world relies on our capacity to focus on relevant information and ignore distractions, especially when task goals change. While studies in non-human primates (NHPs) have shown that individual neurons in the prefrontal cortex can flexibly reconfigure their responses to code different task-relevant information (a concept known as "adaptive coding"), it's been less clear if this applies to the human brain at a similar level of detail. The human "multiple demand" (MD) system is thought to be involved in this cognitive control, but it was unknown whether the same or different neural populations within this system are recruited for different tasks. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining how individual voxels (small regions of brain tissue) contribute to coding information across different tasks in humans, providing an intermediate level of resolution between whole-brain region analysis and single-neuron studies.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of fMRI data acquisition and advanced analysis techniques.

  • Multi-Voxel Pattern Analysis (MVPA): This is a standard fMRI analysis technique used to decode information from patterns of activity across multiple voxels. They used MVPA to identify which voxels could distinguish between relevant features of objects in two separate tasks.
  • "Voxel Reuse" Measure: This is the novel methodological contribution of the paper. They developed a method to quantify the extent to which the same voxels contribute maximally to the multivoxel codes for two distinct task features. Essentially, they looked at the overlap in voxels that were most important for decoding information in Task A versus Task B.
  • Permutation Testing: To determine if the observed voxel reuse was greater than what would be expected by chance, they used permutation tests. This involved shuffling the data to create a null distribution against which their actual findings could be compared.
  • Searchlight Analysis: This exploratory technique was used to identify any other brain regions beyond the pre-defined MD regions that showed similar coding patterns.

Datasets

The study used fMRI data collected from 26 healthy human participants. No new benchmarks were introduced; the focus was on analyzing existing fMRI data with a novel analytical approach.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Voxel Reuse as a Proxy for Neural Flexibility: The core idea is that if individual voxels consistently contribute to decoding different types of information across tasks, it suggests that the underlying neural populations within those voxels are also flexible and adaptable, rather than being specialized for a single task.
  • Bridging the NHP-Human Gap: By examining voxel reuse, the study provides a more direct comparison to NHP studies that have looked at single-neuron flexibility, offering a more nuanced understanding of adaptive coding in the human brain.
  • MD System's Adaptability: The findings strongly support the idea that the MD system is not a collection of rigidly specialized regions but rather a dynamic network where individual units (voxels) can be repurposed to meet changing cognitive demands.

Key Results

  • MD Regions Show Significant Voxel Reuse: The multiple demand (MD) network, including regions like the anterior cingulate cortex/pre-supplementary motor area (ACC/pre-SMA), intraparietal sulcus (IPS), and inferior frontal sulcus (IFS), showed a significantly higher proportion of voxel reuse for task-relevant information than predicted by chance (23.9% overall for MD regions).
  • Visual Cortex Lacks Voxel Reuse: In contrast, early visual cortex (BA 17) did not show significant voxel reuse for task-relevant information. These voxels tended to code for both relevant and irrelevant features, suggesting a more stimulus-driven, less behaviorally modulated processing.
  • Task-Relevant Coding is Prioritized: Consistent with previous findings, the MD regions showed stronger coding of task-relevant features compared to task-irrelevant features.
  • Precuneus Shows Task-Relevant Coding but No Reuse: The precuneus, a region often associated with the default mode network, also showed preferential coding of task-relevant information but lacked evidence of flexible voxel reuse.
  • Cerebellum Shows Some Voxel Reuse: Interestingly, one cluster in the cerebellum also demonstrated above-chance voxel reuse, suggesting that this region might also play a role in flexible cognitive control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Voxel-Level vs. Neuron-Level: The authors acknowledge that voxel reuse is an indirect measure of neural reuse. It's possible, though considered unlikely, that a voxel could sample two independent populations of neurons, each responding to a different task. Ideally, direct neural recordings would provide definitive evidence.
  • Stimulus Similarity and Task Demands: The study suggests that future work could explore how the degree of voxel reuse varies with the similarity of stimuli and the complexity of task demands, drawing parallels to NHP literature.
  • Investigating Other Regions: The exploratory searchlight analysis identified the precuneus and cerebellum as regions of interest for future investigation into their roles in adaptive coding.
  • Abstract Representation: The study also explored whether category number decisions were cross-classified between tasks, finding no evidence for this, suggesting that the observed voxel reuse is not driven by abstract representations of category number.

Summary updated

Abstract

Our ability to flexibly switch between different tasks is a key component of cognitive control. Non-human primate (NHP) studies (e.g., Freedman, Riesenhuber, Poggio, & Miller, 2001) have shown that prefrontal neurons are re-used across tasks, re-configuring their responses to code currently relevant information. In a similar vein, in the human brain, the "multiple demand" (MD) system is suggested to exert control by adjusting its responses, selectively processing information in line with our current goals (Duncan, 2010). However, whether the same or different resources (underlying neural populations) in the human brain are recruited to solve different tasks remains elusive. In the present study, we aimed to bridge the gap between the NHP and human literature by examining human functional imaging data at an intermediate level of resolution: quantifying the extent to which single voxels contributed to multiple neural codes. Participants alternated between two tasks requiring the selection of feature information from two distinct sets of objects. We examined whether neural codes for the relevant stimulus features in the two different tasks depended on the same or different voxels. In line with the electrophysiological literature, MD voxels were more likely to contribute to multiple neural codes than we predicted based on permutation tests. Comparatively, in the visual system the neural codes depended on distinct sets of voxels. Our data emphasise the flexibility of the MD regions to re-configure their responses and adaptively code relevant information across different tasks.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jackson2018adaptive,
  author = {Jade Jackson and Alexandra Woolgar},
  title = {{Adaptive coding in the human brain: Distinct object features are encoded by overlapping voxels in frontoparietal cortex}},
  booktitle = {Cortex},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1016/j.cortex.2018.07.006},
}
Figure