ADAPT: A Game-Theoretic and Neuro-Symbolic Framework for Automated Distributed Adaptive Penetration Testing

Haozhe Lei, Yunfei Ge, Quanyan ZhuMilcom 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces ADAPT, a novel framework that combines game theory and neuro-symbolic AI to automate distributed penetration testing for AI-enabled healthcare systems. ADAPT addresses the growing complexity and evolving threat landscape of these critical infrastructures by providing an adaptive and efficient approach to identify vulnerabilities and devise countermeasures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern critical infrastructure, particularly in healthcare, is increasingly reliant on AI and machine learning (ML) technologies. While these advancements offer significant benefits in areas like patient care and diagnostics, they also introduce new vulnerabilities, such as expanded attack surfaces and the emergence of adversarial AI. Traditional penetration testing methods are struggling to keep pace with this complexity due to scalability issues, the dynamic nature of threats, and the sophisticated evasion tactics employed by AI-powered attackers. This paper tackles the challenge of developing an automated, distributed, and adaptive penetration testing framework that can effectively assess risks and develop remediation strategies in these complex, AI-integrated environments.

Methods

ADAPT employs a two-pronged approach: a game-theoretic framework and a neuro-symbolic framework.

  • Game-Theoretic Framework: This framework models the interaction between an attacker and a defender as a meta-security game. This game is composed of two levels:
  • Micro Tactic Games (MTGs): These represent detailed, sequential interactions between the attacker and defender at individual network nodes, often visualized as extensive-form game trees. They capture local attack and defense actions.
  • Macro Strategic Process (MSP): This models the attacker's decision-making across the entire network, treating nodes as states and connections as actions. It's framed as a Markov Decision Process (MDP) where the attacker aims to explore and exploit vulnerabilities to achieve their objectives. The MTGs and MSP are coupled, meaning local penetration plans influence the global attack strategy, and policy evaluation from the macro process informs the utilities in the micro games.

  • Neuro-Symbolic Framework: This component handles the adaptation and learning aspects.

  • Symbolic Adaptation: This involves using First-Order Logic (FOL) to represent node properties and a knowledge library to store MTGs. When new vulnerabilities or properties are discovered (e.g., through automated fuzzing), the symbolic representation is updated.
  • Neural Penetration Playbook Computation: This part uses algorithms (like Algorithm 1, which iteratively computes Nash equilibria and updates strategies) to determine the optimal penetration playbook, which includes both local penetration plans and the global attack strategy. Algorithm 2 outlines the overall neural-symbolic workflow.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a conceptual framework and uses a simulated hospital network case study for illustration and experimental evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Gap: ADAPT effectively bridges the gap between traditional, static penetration testing and the dynamic, AI-driven threat landscape by integrating game theory for strategic decision-making and neuro-symbolic AI for adaptive learning.
  • Meta-Security Game: The concept of a meta-security game, encompassing both network-level strategy and node-level tactics, provides a powerful abstraction for modeling complex cybersecurity scenarios.
  • Adaptive Defense: The framework's adaptive nature, driven by continuous knowledge acquisition and learning, is crucial for staying ahead of evolving adversarial AI techniques.
  • Healthcare Focus: The specific application to AI-enabled healthcare infrastructure highlights the critical need for robust security in this sector, where vulnerabilities can have life-threatening consequences.
  • Purple Teaming Advantage: The experimental results suggest that more sophisticated defense strategies, like "purple teaming" (combining red and blue teaming), offer significant advantages over fixed strategies against skilled attackers.

Key Results

The paper presents experimental results using a simulated hospital network case study.

  • Risk Reduction: The framework demonstrated an improvement of around 98% in reducing the risk score of the system when using a purple teaming defender compared to a fixed strategy defender.
  • Attacker Skill Impact: As the attacker's skill level increases, the network risk score rises, and the ML model's accuracy decreases. At a high attacker skill level (Ca=1), the attacker can obtain nearly 100% of the value from the critical asset and cause complete damage to the ML model.
  • Defender Advantage: The experiments showed that a purple teaming defender consistently maintained an advantage, keeping the attacker's values below zero, regardless of the attacker's skill level.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Imperfect Knowledge Library: The authors acknowledge that the knowledge library might be imperfect and unable to fully describe all node properties. They suggest that constantly updating the knowledge library is a direction for future work.
  • Computational Complexity: While not explicitly stated as a limitation, the complexity of solving extensive-form games and computing Nash equilibria can be significant, especially for large networks. The paper mentions using neural network-based approaches for computationally complicated MTGs.
  • Real-world Deployment: The current work is based on a simulated case study. Future work could involve validating ADAPT in real-world healthcare environments.
  • Defender Strategies: The paper explores fixed and purple teaming defender strategies. Further research could investigate other advanced defense mechanisms and their integration into the framework.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{lei2024adapt,
  author = {Haozhe Lei and Yunfei Ge and Quanyan Zhu},
  title = {{ADAPT: A Game-Theoretic and Neuro-Symbolic Framework for Automated Distributed Adaptive Penetration Testing}},
  booktitle = {Milcom},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1109/milcom61039.2024.10774038},
}
Figure