Adam-Gibbs Relation for Glass-Forming Liquids in Two, Three, and Four Dimensions

S. Sengupta, Smarajit Karmakar, Chandan Dasgupta, Srikanth SastryPhysical 2012 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

The Adam-Gibbs relation between relaxation times and the configurational entropy has been tested extensively for glass formers using experimental data and computer simulation results. Although the form of the relation contains no dependence on the spatial dimensionality in the original formulation, subsequent derivations of the Adam-Gibbs relation allow for such a possibility. We test the Adam-Gibbs relation in two, three, and four spatial dimensions using computer simulations of model glass formers. We find that the relation is valid in three and four dimensions. But in two dimensions, the relation does not hold, and interestingly, no single alternate relation describes the results for the different model systems we study.

Introduction

As a liquid cools toward its glass transition, its relaxation time ($\tau$)—the time it takes for particles to rearrange—increases dramatically, often far exceeding the simple exponential behavior predicted by the Arrhenius law. The Adam-Gibbs (AG) relation is a cornerstone of glass physics that explains this "super-Arrhenius" slowing by linking it to configurational entropy ($S_c$), a measure of the number of distinct structural arrangements available to the liquid.

The AG relation states that $\tau \propto \exp(C/TS_c)$. While this formula doesn't explicitly include spatial dimensionality ($D$), more modern frameworks like Random First Order Transition (RFOT) theory suggest that dimensionality should play a role. This study investigates whether the AG relation is a universal law across different dimensions, from 2D to 4D.

Methodology and Models

The researchers employed large-scale Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations to study model glass-formers. Dynamics were measured using the relaxation time ($\tau_\alpha$) from a two-point overlap function. Thermodynamics were assessed by calculating the configurational entropy ($S_c$)—the total entropy minus the vibrational component calculated via inherent structures.

The study utilized several well-characterized computer models:

  • Kob-Andersen (KA) Model: An 80:20 binary mixture of Lennard-Jones particles (used in 2D, 3D, and 4D).
  • Modified KA (MKA) Model: A 65:35 mixture used in 2D to avoid orientational ordering.
  • R10 Model: A 50:50 binary mixture of repulsive soft spheres (used in 2D) to test the impact of interaction potential.

Key Results and Discussion

The AG relation proved remarkably robust in higher dimensions. In both 3D and 4D, the plot of $\log(\tau)$ versus $1/TS_c$ is linear, confirming the classic AG formulation. However, in 2D, the relation fails as data points curve away from the predicted linear relationship at low temperatures.

Adam-Gibbs plots for KA models in 4D (a), 3D (b), and 2D (c). The relation holds in 4D and 3D but deviates in 2D.

A significant finding is the loss of universality in 2D. Using a generalized form $\tau = \tau_0 \exp[(C/TS_c)^\alpha]$, the authors found that the deviation depends on the interaction potential. In the attractive MKA model, $\alpha < 1$, while in the purely repulsive R10 model, $\alpha > 1$. This suggests that in low dimensions, the specific nature of inter-particle forces fundamentally changes how thermodynamics dictates dynamics.

Breakdown of universality in 2D glass-formers. (a) 2D MKA model shows alpha < 1, while (b) 2D R10 model shows alpha > 1.

Conclusion

While the AG relation is a powerful tool for understanding 3D and 4D glass-formers, it breaks down in 2D. The lack of universality in 2D is unexpected, as both AG and RFOT theories treat the glass transition as a thermodynamic phase transition that should be universal. These results suggest that activated relaxation mechanisms might be fundamentally different in 2D, potentially linked to the breakdown of the Stokes-Einstein relation in low dimensions. Future work will focus on these mechanisms to reconcile the dimensional dependence of glass dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Adam-Gibbs relation between relaxation times and the configurational entropy has been tested extensively for glass formers using experimental data and computer simulation results. Although the form of the relation contains no dependence on the spatial dimensionality in the original formulation, subsequent derivations of the Adam-Gibbs relation allow for such a possibility. We test the Adam-Gibbs relation in two, three, and four spatial dimensions using computer simulations of model glass formers. We find that the relation is valid in three and four dimensions. But in two dimensions, the relation does not hold, and interestingly, no single alternate relation describes the results for the different model systems we study.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sengupta2012adam,
  author = {S. Sengupta and Smarajit Karmakar and Chandan Dasgupta and Srikanth Sastry},
  title = {{Adam-Gibbs Relation for Glass-Forming Liquids in Two, Three, and Four Dimensions}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.109.095705},
}
Figure