Acute effect of breathing exercises on muscle tension and executive function under psychological stress

Wen-Ming Liang, Jing Xiao, Fei-Fei Ren, Zi-Shuai Chen, Chun-Ri Li, Zhenmin Bai, Osvaldas RukšenasFrontiers in Psychology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Brief breathing exercises did not substantially affect muscle tension under psychological stress. SLOW demonstrated greater potential for sustaining executive function in men, possibly via its superior respiration efficiency on SpO<sub>2</sub> and inhibition of RR.

Introduction

In modern high-pressure work environments, chronic stress frequently manifests as both physical muscle tension (e.g., "tech neck") and cognitive fatigue. While micro-breaks are often recommended to mitigate these effects, there is limited consensus on which specific activities provide the most effective acute relief. This study investigates whether five-minute sessions of specialized breathing techniques can immediately improve physiological and cognitive outcomes during a subsequent psychological stressor.

Methods and Experimental Design

The study utilized a within-subjects design involving 48 participants (21 men and 22 women in the final analysis). To control for order effects, researchers employed a Latin Square Williams design to randomize the sequence of four 5-minute interventions: Mindful Breathing (MINDFUL), Slow Breathing (6 breaths/min; SLOW), Fast Breathing (30% above baseline; FAST), and Music Listening (MUSIC).

The experimental procedure followed a randomized sequence of interventions followed by the Stroop test.

Following each intervention, participants performed the Stroop Color and Word Test to induce psychological stress. Researchers monitored several physiological and cognitive metrics:

  • Muscle Tension: Surface electromyography (sEMG) on the upper trapezius.
  • Executive Function: Accuracy and reaction time measured via E-prime 3.0.
  • Physiology: Respiration rate (RR), oxygen saturation ($SpO_2$), and end-tidal $CO_2$ ($EtCO_2$).
The experimental setup included a nasal cannula, wireless EMG sensors, and a respiration belt to monitor physiological responses.

Results

Executive Function and Gender Differences

The most significant findings occurred in cognitive performance among male participants. During the final minute of the stress task, men exhibited significantly higher accuracy after the SLOW breathing intervention compared to both MUSIC ($p=0.011$) and FAST breathing ($p<0.001$). Reaction times were also shortest following SLOW breathing. Interestingly, preference for these techniques was split by gender: 52% of men preferred SLOW breathing, while 48% of women preferred MUSIC.

Physiological Impact

SLOW breathing demonstrated superior "respiratory efficiency," significantly increasing $SpO_2$ levels compared to mindful breathing or music. This physiological shift likely provided a metabolic buffer that helped sustain cognitive performance. Conversely, FAST breathing was the least effective method, leading to lower accuracy and higher subjective dissatisfaction, likely because it mimics the physiological state of anxiety.

Muscle Tension

Contrary to expectations, none of the 5-minute interventions significantly reduced trapezius muscle activity during the subsequent stressor. This suggests that physical tension induced by mental tasks may be resistant to very brief relaxation exercises.

Discussion and Limitations

The study highlights that while brief breathing exercises—particularly slow, rhythmic breathing—can sustain executive function, they may not be sufficient to reset neuromuscular pathways responsible for muscle tension. Limitations include the high sensitivity of sEMG to micro-movements and the relatively short duration of the interventions. Future research should explore why women tended to prefer music and whether longer intervention durations might impact physical tension.

Conclusion

For individuals seeking to maintain cognitive sharpness during high-stress intervals, a five-minute session of slow breathing (6 breaths per minute) appears more effective than music or "energizing" fast breathing, particularly for men. While it may not solve "tech neck" immediately, it provides a critical physiological edge for mental performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Brief breathing exercises did not substantially affect muscle tension under psychological stress. SLOW demonstrated greater potential for sustaining executive function in men, possibly via its superior respiration efficiency on SpO<sub>2</sub> and inhibition of RR.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liang2023acute,
  author = {Wen-Ming Liang and Jing Xiao and Fei-Fei Ren and Zi-Shuai Chen and Chun-Ri Li and Zhenmin Bai and Osvaldas Rukšenas},
  title = {{Acute effect of breathing exercises on muscle tension and executive function under psychological stress}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1155134},
}
Figure