Activity system, schizotypal personality, and mentalization: A study between halted activity and COVID-19 conducted in Henan, China

Mohamad El Maouch, Yile Wang, Zheng Jin, Timothy Tamunang Tamutana, Kaibin Zhao, Yü LiuFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

This study, published in Frontiers in Public Health, explores how the disruption of daily life during COVID-19 lockdowns in China impacted the "activity systems" of college students and how these disruptions correlate with PTSD, mentalization (the ability to reflect on mental states), and schizotypal personality traits.

TL;DR

The research demonstrates that the "halting" of daily activities during the pandemic significantly disturbed the "life narratives" of students, leading to increased schizotypal traits and PTSD. Crucially, the study finds that having structured, medium-term goals and a high capacity for "mentalization" acts as a vital psychological buffer against these disturbances.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While many studies have documented the rise of anxiety and depression during COVID-19, this paper digs deeper into the structural relationship between what we do and how we think. Drawing on Cultural-Historical Activity Theory (CHAT), the authors argue that the human mind and "self" are not static but are constantly formed through a flow of goal-directed activities.

When the pandemic "vacuumed" individuals out of their social and professional contexts, it didn't just cause stress—it broke the "life narrative." The authors investigate whether this break in the activity system leads to an increase in schizotypal traits (sub-clinical markers of thought and perceptual disturbances) and how "mentalization" (reflective function) helps individuals maintain mind coherence during such a crisis.

Methods

The researchers employed a mixed-methods approach, surveying 852 college students in Zhengzhou, Henan, China, between November 2021 and March 2022.

  • Quantitative Measures: Standardized scales were used to measure Schizotypy (MSS-B), Mentalization/Reflective Function (RFQY), and PTSD (IES-R).
  • Qualitative/Coded Measures: Participants answered open-ended questions about their personal goals and how the pandemic affected their activities. These were then coded into categories:
  • Goal Term: Short, medium, or long-term.
  • Goal Type: Tangible (e.g., "buying a car") vs. Abstract (e.g., "improving life quality").
  • Activity Flow: Nine categories of pandemic-related disruption (e.g., "total halt of activity," "mood affected").
  • Analysis: The team used Pearson correlations, One-way ANOVA, and Multiple Linear Regression to identify predictors of schizotypal traits.

Datasets

The study utilized a primary dataset of 852 survey responses collected from students at Zhengzhou Normal University (ZZNU). This population was particularly relevant as they faced both the pandemic and a severe flood in the region shortly before the study began.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Protective Power of Goals: Simply having goals was associated with lower levels of "Disorganized" schizotypy. Interestingly, medium-term goals (like graduating or finding a job) were more protective than short-term ones, likely because they provide a stable "space-time structure" for the mind.
  • Mentalization as a Shield: "Reflective function" (the ability to understand the mental states underlying behavior) was the strongest predictor of lower schizotypal traits. Those who could consciously evaluate the disturbance of their life narrative experienced less "mind incoherence."
  • Activity as Compensation: The authors suggest that when external activity is halted, the mind may "inflate" internal schizotypal traits (like magical thinking or social withdrawal) as a dysfunctional form of mental compensation for the loss of social engagement.
  • Gender and Minority Status: In this specific sample (91% female), males reported significantly higher levels of PTSD and schizotypal traits. The authors hypothesize this might be due to the stress of being a "minority" within the university social structure.

Key Results

  • High Stress Levels: Approximately 46% of participants reported stress levels above the clinical cut-off for PTSD concern.
  • Predictive Modeling: Multiple regression models explained 21.6% of the variance in "Positive" schizotypy and 23.4% in "Disorganized" schizotypy.
  • Significant Predictors: Gender, only-child status, PTSD levels, and reflective function were all significant predictors of schizotypal traits ($p \leq 0.001$).
  • Goal Impact: Students with abstract goals reported higher reflective function and lower levels of negative and disorganized schizotypy compared to those with only tangible, concrete goals.

Limitations and Future Work

The study's primary limitation is its gender imbalance (91% female), which is typical for "Normal" (teacher-training) universities in China but limits generalizability. Additionally, as a cross-sectional study, it can identify associations but cannot definitively prove that the pandemic caused the increase in schizotypal traits.

The authors suggest that future mental health interventions should move beyond simple counseling and focus on helping individuals rebuild their "activity systems." This includes providing tools for "dynamic planning" and developing self-reflective skills to help people regain control over their life narratives during periods of social upheaval.

Summary updated

Abstract

The pandemic-related lifestyle has potentially imposed crucial disturbances on daily and long-term activities, which, in turn, were associated with thought disturbance. This study investigates how the characteristics of the activity system during pandemic-related restrictions are associated with other psychomental aspects. By focusing on PTSD, mentalization, and schizotypal personality, and by inquiring about the main components of the activity system of 852 college students (Zhengzhou, Henan, China)- including the goals orienting their activity, goals' terms and types, the motivation levels and sources, the activity type and engagement time, the flow of the activity, and how due to pandemic lifestyle-results revealed that the activity system's components have significant associations with PTSD, reflective function, and schizotypal traits. Additionally, some of the activity system's elements have a significant predictive role regarding schizotypal traits. The study considered that the life narrative during the pandemic has been disturbed; hence, this may have a crucial effect on mind coherence. Additionally, the outcomes from the pandemic context will support mental health interventions in other similar contexts where the life narrative is severely affected.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{maouch2022activity,
  author = {Mohamad El Maouch and Yile Wang and Zheng Jin and Timothy Tamunang Tamutana and Kaibin Zhao and Yü Liu},
  title = {{Activity system, schizotypal personality, and mentalization: A study between halted activity and COVID-19 conducted in Henan, China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.930842},
}
Figure