ActiveNotes

Lauren Wilcox, Jie Lü, Jennifer C. Lai, Steven Feiner, Desmond Jordan2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces activeNotes, a prototype system designed to streamline the creation of critical care notes for physicians. By integrating automated, context-aware patient data retrieval and user-controlled updates/alerts, activeNotes aims to reduce the time and cognitive load associated with documenting patient progress. A key finding is that physicians, who previously rejected rigid templates, expressed interest in using activeNotes to create personalized, reusable note templates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Creating comprehensive "Critical Care Notes" in hospital intensive care units (ICUs) is a time-consuming and complex task for physicians. These notes document a patient's progress and prognosis and are crucial for legal and billing purposes, as well as for informing other caregivers. Current Electronic Medical Record (EMR) systems, while offering some assistance, often present overly complex user interfaces with deeply structured menus, making it difficult and inefficient for physicians to gather, review, and synthesize the necessary patient data (lab results, medical rounds information, medications) into a coherent note. Physicians spend significant time navigating through data and struggle with updating notes as patient conditions change, often relying on memory or jotted reminders. This inefficiency can lead to delays in documentation and potentially less up-to-date records.

Methods

The core of activeNotes is its innovative approach to integrating patient data retrieval and note creation. The system presents physicians with two side-by-side views: an editable note view and a patient information view. As a physician types, activeNotes dynamically interprets the content to identify potential information requests. Using a hot-key, the system can automatically formulate queries to retrieve relevant data from multiple sources.

A key novel component is the introduction of activeTags. These are not static tags but dynamic data entries that serve as identifiers and placeholders for data. activeTags are associated with a set of rules that control how dynamic source content is reflected in the note. Physicians can tag terms or phrases within the note, and then configure activeTags to automatically update the data at specified times or trigger alerts based on user-defined criteria (e.g., value changes). This allows for context-sensitive updates and alerts, directly linked to the note content.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study involved a qualitative review session with physicians using the activeNotes prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physician Resistance to Templates is Nuanced: Contrary to expectations, physicians who had previously rejected rigid, template-based documentation systems showed a strong desire to use activeNotes to create their own personalized, physician-specific note templates. This suggests that flexibility and user control are key to template adoption.
  • activeTags as Dynamic Placeholders: The concept of activeTags as dynamic data entries that can trigger automated updates and alerts based on context is a significant departure from traditional tagging mechanisms. This allows for a more fluid and responsive note-creation process.
  • Integrated Data Retrieval and Note Editing is Crucial: The side-by-side view of the note editor and patient information, combined with the ability to seamlessly pull in retrieved data, significantly improves the efficiency of note creation.
  • "Fresh" Notes are Highly Valued: Physicians expressed that the ease of incorporating up-to-date information would lead to higher quality, "fresh" notes, reducing the worry of copying outdated information.

Key Results

  • Qualitative Feedback: A user study with 15 physicians at New York Presbyterian Hospital yielded positive qualitative feedback. Physicians found activeNotes valuable and indicated they would use it for both formal and informal notes.
  • Desire for Personalized Templates: A surprising finding was that half of the attending physicians expressed a desire to use the system to create their own note templates for specific problems, which could then be applied to patients and automatically updated.
  • Tagging for Updates/Alerts is Key: 13 out of 15 participants considered the ability to use tags for setting up updates and/or alerts to be an important feature.
  • Ease of Use: Physicians felt the system made it easier to include up-to-date information without extensive retyping.
  • Potential Learning Curve: A noted drawback was the potential difficulty for physicians to learn which keywords the system could recognize, as they sometimes used terms that made sense to them but were not in the system's dictionary.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Study Scope: The study was qualitative and involved a relatively small sample of physicians in specific ICU environments.
  • Need for Longer Study: The authors acknowledge that a longer study is needed to compare responses across different ICU environments and to address various usage scenarios, system requirements, and deployment architectures.
  • Future Work Directions:
    • Integrating system support for connecting with and retrieving from multiple systems and data sources used in the CTICU.
  • Designing a comparative study to address quantitative human factors.
  • Evaluating the quality of notes produced by activeNotes by both attending physicians and billing professionals.
  • Exploring a variety of interactive visualizations of patient information.
  • Further developing the system's ability to understand physician-defined keywords and terminology.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present activeNotes, a prototype application that supports the creation of Critical Care Notes by physicians in a hospital intensive care unit. activeNotes integrates automated, context-sensitive patient data retrieval and user control of automated data updates and alerts into the note-creation process. In a user study at New York Presbyterian Hospital, we gathered qualitative feedback on the prototype from 15 physicians. The physicians found activeNotes to be valuable and said they would use it to create both formal notes for medical records and informal notes. One surprising finding is that while physicians have rejected template-based clinical documentation systems in the past, they expressed a desire to use activeNotes to create personalized, physician-specific note templates to be reused with a given patient, or for a given condition.
BibTeX
@misc{wilcox2009activenotes,
  author = {Lauren Wilcox and Jie Lü and Jennifer C. Lai and Steven Feiner and Desmond Jordan},
  title = {{ActiveNotes}},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1145/1520340.1520480},
}
Figure