Active to Sterile Neutrino Mixing Limits from Neutral-Current Interactions in MINOS

P. Adamson, D. J. Auty, D. S. Ayres, C. Backhouse, G. Barr, M. Bishai, A. Blake, G. J. Bock, D. J. Boehnlein, D. Bogert, S. Cavanaugh, D. Cherdack, S. Childress, J. A. B. Coelho, S. J. Coleman, L. A. Corwin, D. Cronin-Hennessy, I. Z. Danko, J. K. de Jong, N. E. Devenish, M. Diwan, M. Dorman, C. O. Escobar, J. J. Evans, E. Falk, G. J. Feldman, M. V. Frohne, H. Gallagher, R. A. Gomes, T Hara, P. Gouffon, N. Graf, R. Gran, N. Grant, K. Grzelak, A. Habig, Deborah A. Harris, J. Hartnell, R. Hatcher, A. Himmel, A. Holin, X. T. Huang, J. Hylen, J. Ilić, G. M. Irwin, Z. Isvan, D. E. Jaffe, C. James, D. Jensen, T. Kafka, S. M. S. Kasahara, G. Koizumi, S. Köpp, M. Kordosky, A. Kreymer, K. Lang, G. Lefeuvre, J. Ling, P. J. Litchfield, L. Loiacono, P. Lucas, W. A. Mann, M. L. Marshak, N. Mayer, A. M. McGowan, R. Mehdiyev, J. R. Meier, M. D. Messier, William H. Miller, S. Mishra, J. W. Mitchell, C. D. Moore, J. G. Morfín, L. Mualem, S. Mufson, J. Musser, D. Naples, J. K. Nelson, H. B. Newman, R. J. Nichol, T.c. Nicholls, J. Nowak, W. P. Oliver, M. Orchanian, J. Paley, R. B. Patterson, G. Pawloski, G.f. Pearce, D. Petyt, S. Phan-Budd, R. Pittam, R. Plunkett, Xin Qiu, J. Ratchford, T. M. Raufer, B. Rebel, P. A. Rodrigues, C. Rosenfeld, H. A. Rubin, M. C. SánchezPhysical 2011 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Results are reported from a search for active to sterile neutrino oscillations in the MINOS long-baseline experiment, based on the observation of neutral-current neutrino interactions, from an exposure to the NuMI neutrino beam of $7.07 \times 10^{20}$ protons on target. A total of 802 neutral-current event candidates is observed in the Far Detector, compared to an expected number of $754 \pm 28(\text{stat}) \pm 37(\text{syst})$ for oscillations among three active flavors. The fraction $f_s$ of disappearing $\nu_\mu$ that may transition to $\nu_s$ is found to be less than 22% at the 90% C.L.

Introduction

In the Standard Model of particle physics, neutrinos exist in three "active" flavors: $\nu_e$, $\nu_\mu$, and $\nu_\tau$. However, persistent anomalies from experiments like LSND and MiniBooNE have suggested the potential existence of a fourth, "sterile" neutrino ($\nu_s$). Unlike active neutrinos, sterile neutrinos would not interact via the weak force, making them detectable only through their gravitational influence or their impact on the oscillation patterns of active neutrinos.

The MINOS experiment addresses this by analyzing neutral-current (NC) interactions. Because NC interactions are flavor-blind—meaning they occur with equal probability for all active neutrino flavors—the total rate of NC events should remain constant even as neutrinos oscillate between active states (e.g., $\nu_\mu \to \nu_\tau$). A significant deficit in the observed NC rate at a distant detector would therefore serve as a "smoking gun" for oscillations into sterile states.

Experimental Methodology

MINOS utilizes the NuMI beam at Fermilab, which generates a high-intensity beam of muon neutrinos. The experiment employs a two-detector design to minimize systematic uncertainties:

  1. Near Detector (ND): Located 1.04 km from the source, it measures the initial neutrino flux and spectrum before significant oscillations occur.
  2. Far Detector (FD): Located 735 km away in the Soudan Underground Laboratory, it searches for deviations from the three-flavor oscillation model.
The reconstructed energy spectrum of neutral-current event candidates in the Near Detector establishes the baseline flux for the experiment.

The analysis distinguishes between Charged-Current (CC) interactions, characterized by long muon tracks, and NC interactions, which produce diffuse hadronic showers. This study benefits from a data sample twice as large as previous MINOS publications ($7.07 \times 10^{20}$ protons on target) and improved reconstruction algorithms that reduce detector noise and crosstalk.

Results and Analysis

The primary metric for this search is the $R$-statistic, the ratio of observed to predicted NC events. If $R \approx 1$, the data is consistent with the standard three-flavor model.

In the Far Detector, researchers observed 802 NC candidates, while the prediction for standard oscillations was $754 \pm 28(\text{stat}) \pm 37(\text{syst})$. This results in an $R$ value of $1.09 \pm 0.06(\text{stat}) \pm 0.05(\text{syst})$, indicating a slight statistical excess rather than a depletion.

The reconstructed energy spectrum in the Far Detector shows the observed data points compared to predictions for standard oscillations and models including sterile mixing.

Based on these observations, the collaboration placed stringent limits on sterile neutrino mixing:

  • The fraction $f_s$ of disappearing $\nu_\mu$ transitioning to $\nu_s$ is limited to $f_s < 22\%$ at the 90% Confidence Level (C.L.).
  • Pure $\nu_\mu \to \nu_s$ oscillations are excluded at the 99.8% C.L.
  • The sterile mixing angle is constrained to $\theta_{34} < 26^\circ$, assuming no $\nu_e$ appearance.

Conclusion

The MINOS data shows no evidence for active-to-sterile neutrino oscillations, significantly narrowing the allowed parameter space for sterile neutrino models. The results are sensitive to the rate of $\nu_e$ appearance; if $\nu_e$ appearance is maximized within current experimental limits, the constraint on $f_s$ relaxes to 40%. Future refinements in the measurement of $\theta_{13}$ will be critical to further sharpening these limits and potentially resolving the sterile neutrino hypothesis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Results are reported from a search for active to sterile neutrino oscillations in the MINOS long-baseline experiment, based on the observation of neutral-current neutrino interactions, from an exposure to the NuMI neutrino beam of 7.07×10(20) protons on target. A total of 802 neutral-current event candidates is observed in the Far Detector, compared to an expected number of 754 ± 28(stat) ± 37(syst) for oscillations among three active flavors. The fraction f(s) of disappearing ν(μ) that may transition to ν(s) is found to be less than 22% at the 90% C.L.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{adamson2011active,
  author = {P. Adamson and D. J. Auty and D. S. Ayres and C. Backhouse and G. Barr and M. Bishai and A. Blake and G. J. Bock and D. J. Boehnlein and D. Bogert and S. Cavanaugh and D. Cherdack and S. Childress and J. A. B. Coelho and S. J. Coleman and L. A. Corwin and D. Cronin-Hennessy and I. Z. Danko and J. K. de Jong and N. E. Devenish and M. Diwan and M. Dorman and C. O. Escobar and J. J. Evans and E. Falk and G. J. Feldman and M. V. Frohne and H. Gallagher and R. A. Gomes and T Hara and P. Gouffon and N. Graf and R. Gran and N. Grant and K. Grzelak and A. Habig and Deborah A. Harris and J. Hartnell and R. Hatcher and A. Himmel and A. Holin and X. T. Huang and J. Hylen and J. Ilić and G. M. Irwin and Z. Isvan and D. E. Jaffe and C. James and D. Jensen and T. Kafka and S. M. S. Kasahara and G. Koizumi and S. Köpp and M. Kordosky and A. Kreymer and K. Lang and G. Lefeuvre and J. Ling and P. J. Litchfield and L. Loiacono and P. Lucas and W. A. Mann and M. L. Marshak and N. Mayer and A. M. McGowan and R. Mehdiyev and J. R. Meier and M. D. Messier and William H. Miller and S. Mishra and J. W. Mitchell and C. D. Moore and J. G. Morfín and L. Mualem and S. Mufson and J. Musser and D. Naples and J. K. Nelson and H. B. Newman and R. J. Nichol and T.C. Nicholls and J. Nowak and W. P. Oliver and M. Orchanian and J. Paley and R. B. Patterson and G. Pawloski and G.F. Pearce and D. Petyt and S. Phan-Budd and R. Pittam and R. Plunkett and Xin Qiu and J. Ratchford and T. M. Raufer and B. Rebel and P. A. Rodrigues and C. Rosenfeld and H. A. Rubin and M. C. Sánchez},
  title = {{Active to Sterile Neutrino Mixing Limits from Neutral-Current Interactions in MINOS}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2011},
  doi = {10.1103/physrevlett.107.011802},
}
Figure