Active Noise Control in Jets from Conical and Contoured Supersonic Nozzles with Plasma Actuators

Jin-Hwa Kim, Martin Kearney-Fischer, Mo Samimy2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates active noise control in Mach 1.65 supersonic jets using plasma actuators, comparing contoured (shock-free) and conical (shock-containing) nozzles. They found that plasma actuators can reduce noise by up to 2.6 dB, particularly at lower angles and with higher azimuthal forcing modes, and that the conical nozzle's inherent screech tones can be significantly suppressed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Supersonic jets are a significant source of noise, particularly in military aircraft applications. This noise originates from various mechanisms, including mixing noise from large-scale turbulent structures and, in the case of imperfectly expanded jets (like those with conical nozzles), screech tones generated by shock-cell feedback loops. While active noise control methods have shown promise, their effectiveness can vary depending on the jet's characteristics, such as nozzle geometry and the presence of shock structures. This paper aims to explore the efficacy of plasma actuators for noise reduction in two distinct supersonic jet types: a shock-free contoured nozzle and a shock-containing conical nozzle, both operating at Mach 1.65. Understanding how these actuators interact with the different flow physics, especially the shock structures in the conical nozzle, is crucial for developing more effective noise mitigation strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed plasma actuators, specifically eight tungsten pin electrodes flush-mounted around the nozzle exit, to actively control the jet flow. These actuators were used to force the jet with various azimuthal modes (m = 0-3, ±1, ±2, ±4) and forcing Strouhal numbers (StDF) ranging from 0.18 to 4.0.

Two types of Mach 1.65 axisymmetric nozzles were used:

  • Contoured nozzle: Designed using the method of characteristics for a shock-free jet.
  • Conical nozzle: Features converging and diverging conical sections with a sharp throat, leading to shock wave generation within the jet plume.

Far-field acoustic data was collected using a linear microphone array positioned at polar angles from 25° to 80° relative to the jet axis. Jet flow fields were visualized using Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV), providing ensemble-averaged velocity contours and Galilean streamlines. The primary metric for evaluating noise control effectiveness was the change in Overall Sound Pressure Level (ΔOASPL).

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study utilizes experimental data generated from controlled wind tunnel experiments. The "datasets" consist of:

  • Far-field acoustic measurements (SPL spectra) at various angles and forcing conditions.
  • PIV measurements of jet flow fields (velocity contours, streamlines) under baseline and forced conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Conical vs. Contoured Nozzle Behavior: The conical nozzle exhibits strong screech tones and more pronounced shock structures compared to the shock-free contoured nozzle. This fundamental difference in flow physics significantly impacts how each jet responds to active control.
  • Competition for Energy in Conical Jets: In the conical jet, there's a dynamic interplay between naturally occurring shock-induced structures and those generated by the plasma actuators. At moderate forcing, the forced structures can dominate, suppressing the natural ones.
  • Screech Tone Suppression: The suppression of naturally occurring structures in the conical jet by moderate forcing is directly linked to the reduction or complete suppression of screech tones. This is a key finding for noise mitigation in such jets.
  • Azimuthal Mode Dependence: For both nozzle types, higher azimuthal modes (m=3 and ±4) generally lead to greater noise reduction at lower polar angles (30°). This suggests that more complex forcing patterns are more effective at directing noise control.
  • Angle-Dependent Effectiveness: Noise reduction is most pronounced at lower polar angles (closer to the jet axis, around 30°) and becomes negligible at higher angles (near sideline, 80°). This aligns with the preferential directionality of jet noise.
  • Forcing Strouhal Number Optimization: The most effective noise reduction occurs at specific forcing Strouhal numbers (StDF = 0.2-0.6), which likely correspond to the natural large-scale structure frequencies.
  • Actuator Noise: At certain forcing conditions (especially m=0), the plasma actuators themselves generate noise, which can sometimes offset the noise reduction achieved in the jet.

Key Results

  • Maximum Noise Reduction:
    • Contoured jet: 1.5 dB at 30° polar angle.
  • Conical jet: 2.6 dB at 30° polar angle.
  • Screech Tone Reduction: In the conical jet, screech tones can be reduced by up to 9 dB at moderate forcing Strouhal numbers.
  • Angle of Maximum Reduction: Noise reduction is most significant at a 30° polar angle and negligible at an 80° polar angle.
  • Effective Azimuthal Modes: Modes m=3 and ±4 showed the greatest noise reduction in both jets at 30°.
  • Effective Forcing Strouhal Numbers: Optimal noise reduction was observed for StDF in the range of 0.2-0.6.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited High Strouhal Number Effectiveness: At high forcing Strouhal numbers (StDF > 1.0 or 1.8), the effects of forcing on both flow and acoustic fields become negligible for both nozzle types, suggesting the jet becomes less responsive to the actuators.
  • Actuator Noise Impact: In some cases, particularly with m=0 forcing, the noise generated by the actuators themselves can be significant and needs to be accounted for when assessing overall noise reduction.
  • Shock Cell Strength Determination: While the paper infers changes in shock cell structures from flow field and acoustic data, direct measurement or detailed analysis of shock cell strength under forced conditions would be beneficial.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the strength of shock cells and their interaction with forcing. A more detailed understanding of the competition between naturally occurring and forced structures in the conical jet could lead to more optimized control strategies. Exploring a wider range of actuator configurations and forcing parameters might also yield further improvements.

Summary updated

Abstract

An active noise control work in jets from contoured and conical supersonic axisymmetric nozzles (henceforth contoured and conical jets, respectively) with plasma actuators is conducted. The Mach 1.65 contoured nozzle is designed by using the method of characteristics for shock-free jet. The Mach 1.65 conical nozzle has converging and diverging conical sections with a sharp throat. Eight actuators, distributed uniformly around the nozzle exit, are used and the jet is forced with azimuthal modes of 0-3, and ±4 and at forcing Strouhal numbers ranging from 0.18 to 4.0. Far-field acoustic is measured by a linear microphone array covering polar angles from 25 to 80q relative to the jet axis. At a far-field polar angle of 30q, more noise reduction is observed at a higher azimuthal mode of 3 or ±4 in both jets. The maximum reduction in overall sound pressure level is 1.5 and 2.6 dB for the contoured and conical jets, respectively. At a polar angle of 80q (near sideline), the reduction in noise level is negligible. In the conical jet, there is a competition for energy between the naturally-occurring structures and those generated by forcing, similar to the process taking place in forcing an imperfectly-expanded supersonic jet. At moderate forcing Strouhal numbers, the structures generated by forcing prevail and thus the naturally-occurring structures are suppressed or weakened. This seems to be responsible for the reduced or suppressed screech tones in the conical jet.
BibTeX
@misc{kim2009active,
  author = {Jin-Hwa Kim and Martin Kearney-Fischer and Mo Samimy},
  title = {{Active Noise Control in Jets from Conical and Contoured Supersonic Nozzles with Plasma Actuators}},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.2514/6.2009-3187},
}
Figure