Active microrheology to determine viscoelastic parameters of\n Stokes-Oldroyd B fluids using optical tweezers

S. Paul, Avijit Kundu, Ayan BanerjeearXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a high-precision active microrheology technique using optical tweezers to disentangle the individual contributions of polymers and solvents in viscoelastic fluids. By measuring the phase response of an oscillating trapped particle, they can accurately extract fundamental parameters like the polymer relaxation time and specific viscosities, offering a more detailed look at complex fluid composition than standard bulk measurements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how complex fluids—like ketchup, cytoplasm, or polymer solutions—flow and deform is the domain of rheology. Traditionally, "bulk" rheology requires milliliters of a sample and applies strain to the entire volume, which masks local variations and is impractical for rare biological samples.

"Microrheology" solves this by using micron-sized probe particles. However, standard passive techniques (watching a particle's random Brownian motion) often require complex mathematical transformations that are prone to noise, especially in very dilute solutions. Furthermore, most models only provide the "complex modulus" ($G^*$), a combined metric that doesn't easily distinguish between the behavior of the polymer chains and the solvent they live in. This paper aims to bridge that gap by providing a method to measure these constituents individually and with higher sensitivity.

Methods

The authors employ active microrheology using an optical tweezers setup.

  1. Optical Trapping: A 1.5 $\mu$m polystyrene bead is held in a harmonic potential created by a focused 1064 nm laser.
  2. Active Perturbation: Instead of just observing the bead, they wiggle the trap center sinusoidally using a piezo-mirror at frequencies between 20 and 100 Hz.
  3. Phase-Sensitive Detection: Using a second laser (780 nm) and a lock-in amplifier, they measure the phase lag between the trap's oscillation and the bead's response.
  4. Theoretical Modeling: They utilize a linearized Stokes-Oldroyd B model. Unlike simpler models, this one explicitly includes terms for the polymer time constant ($\lambda$), polymer viscosity ($\mu_p$), and solvent viscosity ($\mu_s$). By fitting their phase data to a derived theoretical equation (Eq. 4 in the paper), they can extract these three parameters directly.

Datasets

The study validated the method using:

  • Pure Water: Used as a control to ensure the system correctly identifies a purely viscous fluid (where polymer contributions should be zero).
  • Polyacrylamide (PAM) Solutions: PAM was mixed with water at various concentrations ranging from very dilute (0.002% w/w) to relatively high (1% w/w).
  • Literature Comparison: The extracted polymer time constants ($\lambda$) were compared against established benchmarks from recent fluid mechanics literature (e.g., Chandra et al., 2018).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Phase is King: The authors highlight that measuring the phase of the response is significantly more accurate than measuring amplitude. Phase is less affected by electronic noise and, crucially, does not require the difficult calibration of converting detector voltages into nanometers of displacement.
  • Constituent Isolation: By using the Stokes-Oldroyd B model, the researchers successfully separated the "background" solvent viscosity from the "added" viscosity of the polymer network. They found the solvent viscosity ($\mu_s$) remained constant across different concentrations, proving the model's physical validity.
  • The Linearity Limit: The method works exceptionally well for dilute solutions. However, the authors discovered a "breakdown" point at higher concentrations (above ~0.1% PAM). Here, the fluid's behavior likely becomes non-linear or involves multiple relaxation time constants, which their current single-constant linear model cannot account for.

Key Results

  • Water Validation: For pure water, the system correctly measured a solvent viscosity of $0.0009 \pm 0.0001$ Pa.s (matching the known value at 300K) and found the polymer components to be effectively zero.
  • PAM Trends: For PAM solutions, the polymer time constant ($\lambda$) and polymer viscosity ($\mu_p$) increased with concentration as expected. For example, at 0.008% PAM, $\lambda$ was measured at approximately 1.3 ms.
  • High Signal-to-Noise: The active phase-measurement approach allowed for reliable data even at extremely low polymer concentrations where passive methods typically struggle.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the assumption of linearity and a single relaxation time. As polymer concentration increases, the chains interact more complexly, leading to non-linear viscoelasticity and a "superposition" of multiple time constants. The current model fails to provide reliable $\mu_p$ values in these dense regimes.

Future Work: The authors suggest extending this technique to more complex biological systems like blood or plasma. Since these fluids are weakly viscoelastic, this high-sensitivity method could potentially serve as a diagnostic tool to detect changes in fluid properties caused by infection or disease.

Summary updated

Abstract

We use active microrheology to determine the frequency dependent moduli of a\nlinear viscoelastic fluid in terms of the polymer time constant ($\\lambda$),\nand the polymer ($\\mu_p$) and solvent viscosity ($\\mu_s$), respectively. We\nmeasure these parameters from the response function of an optically trapped\nBrownian probe in the fluid under an external perturbation, and at different\ndilutions of the viscoelastic component in the fluid. This is an improvement\nover bulk microrheology measurements in viscoelastic Stokes-Oldroyd B fluids\nwhich determine the complex elastic modulus $G(\\omega)$ of the fluid, but do\nnot, however, reveal the characteristics of the polymer chains and the\nNewtonian solvent of the complex fluid individually. In a recent work [Paul\n\\textit{et al}., 2018 J. Phys. Condens. Matter \\textbf{30} 345101], we\nlinearized the Stokes-Oldroyd B fluid model and thereby explicitly formulated\nthe frequency dependent moduli in terms of ($\\mu_p$) and ($\\mu_s$), which we\nnow extend to account for an external sinusoidal force applied to the probe\nparticle. We measure $\\lambda$, $\\mu_p$, and $\\mu_s$ experimentally, and\ncompare with existing the $\\lambda$ values in the literature for the same fluid\nat some of the dilution levels, and obtain good agreement. Further, we use\nthese parameters to calculate the complex elastic modulus of the fluid again at\ncertain dilutions and verify successfully with existing data. This establishes\nour method as an alternate approach in the active microrheology of complex\nfluids which should reveal information about the composition of such fluids in\nsignificantly greater detail and high signal to noise.\n
BibTeX
@misc{paul2018active,
  author = {S. Paul and Avijit Kundu and Ayan Banerjee},
  title = {{Active microrheology to determine viscoelastic parameters of\textbackslash\{\}n Stokes-Oldroyd B fluids using optical tweezers}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1811.01262},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1811.01262},
}

Loading related content...

Figure