Active L\\'evy Matter: Anomalous Diffusion, Hydrodynamics and Linear\n Stability

Andrea Cairoli, Chiu Fan LeearXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces "active Lévy matter" (ALM), a new model for collective behavior in systems where individual particles exhibit anomalous diffusion (superdiffusion akin to Lévy flights) and interact via polar alignment. They demonstrate that this combination leads to a critical (second-order) phase transition between disordered and ordered states, unlike typical active matter which shows a first-order transition. This finding opens new avenues for understanding biological systems and designing active materials.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many biological systems, from bird flocks to bacterial swarms, exhibit two key phenomena: anomalous diffusion (particles moving in a way that doesn't follow standard Brownian motion, often characterized by power-law displacements) and collective behavior (spontaneous emergence of coordinated motion). Existing theories of active matter primarily focus on particles with normal diffusion. This paper addresses the crucial question: how does anomalous diffusion at the single-particle level influence the collective behavior and phase transitions in interacting active matter systems? Specifically, they investigate how superdiffusive particles, performing Lévy flights, interact and self-organize.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-pronged approach:

  1. Microscopic Model: They define a microscopic model of active particles that perform superdiffusion (Lévy flights) and interact through polar alignment of their orientations.
  2. Hydrodynamic Equations: They derive the continuum hydrodynamic equations of motion for this ALM system using a coarse-graining procedure based on the Bogoliubov-Born-Green-Kirkwood-Yvon (BBGKY) hierarchy and Fourier expansions. This is a key technical contribution, as standard methods need adaptation for the non-local nature of Lévy flights.
  3. Linear Stability Analysis: They analyze the stability of disordered and ordered phases predicted by the hydrodynamic equations. This involves perturbing the mean-field solutions and examining the growth or decay of these perturbations.
  4. Finite Size Scaling Analysis: To confirm the theoretical predictions and characterize the transition, they perform extensive numerical simulations of the microscopic model. This involves analyzing how various quantities (like the Binder cumulant and correlation functions) scale with system size to extract critical exponents.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on numerical simulations of a defined microscopic model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Critical Transition: The most significant finding is that ALM exhibits a critical (second-order) phase transition between disordered and ordered states. This is a departure from ordinary active matter, which typically undergoes a first-order transition.
  • Suppression of Banding Instability: The anomalous diffusion inherent in Lévy flights appears to suppress the "banding instability" that typically drives first-order transitions in conventional active fluids. This stabilization allows for a continuous transition.
  • Universality Class Connection: The estimated critical exponents suggest a potential link between ALM and equilibrium systems with long-range interactions, particularly in the "classical regime" (low α values). This hints at deeper connections between different physical phenomena.
  • Novel Hydrodynamic Terms: The derivation of hydrodynamic equations for ALM reveals new terms that account for both the anomalous diffusion and the interactions, highlighting the unique physics of these systems.

Key Results

  • Hydrodynamic Equations: The paper successfully derives a set of hydrodynamic equations for active Lévy matter, capturing the interplay between superdiffusion and polar alignment.
  • Linear Stability: Linear stability analysis shows that the disordered phase is stable, and crucially, the ordered phase is also stable against perturbations at the onset of collective motion, predicting a critical transition.
  • Critical Exponents: Finite size scaling analysis provides numerical estimates for static and dynamic critical exponents. For α=1/2, they found exponents consistent with theoretical predictions for certain long-range interacting systems (γ=1, β=1/2, ν=1). For α=3/4, the results suggest a deviation from these simple scaling laws.
  • Critical Noise Strength: Numerical simulations allowed for the estimation of the critical noise strength (σc) at which the transition occurs, with values like σc ≈ 0.2398 for α=1/2.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Analytical Exponents: While numerical estimates for critical exponents are provided, a full analytical derivation for general α remains an open problem.
  • Intermediate Wavelengths: The linear stability analysis was primarily performed in the hydrodynamic (long-wavelength) limit. The behavior at intermediate wavelengths, where other instabilities might emerge, requires further investigation.
  • Universality Class Confirmation: While numerical results hint at connections to specific universality classes, further analytical work is needed to definitively establish these relationships, especially for non-classical regimes (higher α).
  • Biological Relevance: The authors suggest applying their framework to other collective phenomena like active turbulence and motility-induced phase separation to better understand biological systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Anomalous diffusion, manifest as a nonlinear temporal evolution of the\nposition mean square displacement, and/or non-Gaussian features of the position\nstatistics, is prevalent in biological transport processes. Likewise,\ncollective behavior is often observed to emerge spontaneously from the mutual\ninteractions between constituent motile units in biological systems. Examples\nwhere these phenomena can be observed simultaneously have been identified in\nrecent experiments on bird flocks, fish schools and bacterial swarms. These\nresults pose an intriguing question, which cannot be resolved by existing\ntheories of active matter: How is the collective motion of these systems\naffected by the anomalous diffusion of the constituent units? Here, we answer\nthis question for a microscopic model of active L\\'evy matter -- a collection\nof active particles that perform superdiffusion akin to a L\\'evy flight and\ninteract by promoting polar alignment of their orientations. We present in\ndetails the derivation of the hydrodynamic equations of motion of the model,\nobtain from these equations the criteria for a disordered or ordered state, and\napply linear stability analysis on these states at the onset of collective\nmotion. Our analysis reveals that the disorder-order phase transition in active\nL\\'evy matter is critical, in contrast to ordinary active fluids where the\nphase transition is, instead, first-order. Correspondingly, we estimate the\ncritical exponents of the transition by finite size scaling analysis and use\nthese numerical estimates to relate our findings to known universality classes.\nThese results highlight the novel physics exhibited by active matter\nintegrating both anomalous diffusive single-particle motility and\ninter-particle interactions.\n
BibTeX
@misc{cairoli2019active,
  author = {Andrea Cairoli and Chiu Fan Lee},
  title = {{Active L\textbackslash\{\}\textbackslash\{\}'evy Matter: Anomalous Diffusion, Hydrodynamics and Linear\textbackslash\{\}n Stability}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1904.08326},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.08326},
}
Figure