Abstract
Cold seep ecosystems are developed from methane-rich fluids in organic rich continental slopes, which are the source of various dense microbial and faunal populations. Extensive studies have been conducted on microbial populations in this unique environment; most of them were based on DNA, which could not resolve the activity of extant organisms. In this study, RNA and DNA analyses were performed to evaluate the active archaeal and bacterial communities and their network correlations, particularly those participating in the methane cycle at three sites of newly developed cold seeps in the northern South China Sea (nSCS). The results showed that both archaeal and bacterial communities were significantly different at the RNA and DNA levels, revealing a higher abundance of methane-metabolizing archaea and sulfate-reducing bacteria in RNA sequencing libraries. Site ROV07-01, which exhibited extensive accumulation of deceased Calyptogena clam shells, was highly developed, and showed diverse and active anaerobic archaeal methanotrophs (ANME)-2a/b and sulfate-reducing bacteria from RNA libraries. Site ROV07-02, located near carbonate crusts with few clam shell debris, appeared to be poorly developed, less anaerobic and less active. Site ROV05-02, colonized by living Calyptogena clams, could likely be intermediary between ROV07-01 and ROV07-02, showing abundant ANME-2dI and sulfate-reducing bacteria in RNA libraries. The high-proportions of ANME-2dI, with respect to ANME-2dII in the site ROV07-01 was the first report from nSCS, which could be associated with recently developed cold seeps. Both ANME-2dI and ANME-2a/b showed close networked relationships with sulfate-reducing bacteria; however, they were not associated with the same microbial operational taxonomic units (OTUs). Based on the geochemical gradients and the megafaunal settlements as well as the niche specificities and syntrophic relationships, ANMEs appeared to change in community structure with the evolution of cold seeps, which may be associated with the heterogeneity of their geochemical processes. This study enriched our understanding of more active sulfate-dependent anaerobic oxidation of methane (AOM) in poorly developed and active cold seep sediments by contrasting DNA- and RNA-derived community structure and activity indicators.
Introduction
Methane is a potent greenhouse gas, and the ocean floor contains massive reservoirs of it. "Cold seeps" are areas where methane-rich fluids leak from the seafloor. Fortunately, much of this methane never reaches the atmosphere because specialized microbial consortia consume it through a process called Anaerobic Oxidation of Methane (AOM). Historically, scientists have used DNA sequencing to identify these microbes. However, DNA is stable and can persist in dead or dormant cells, meaning a DNA "census" doesn't necessarily tell you who is actually "at work."
This research addresses the need to distinguish active methane-consumers from the background population in recently emerged cold seeps. By focusing on RNA (which indicates active protein synthesis) alongside DNA, the authors aimed to understand how these microbial communities establish themselves and change as a seep matures.
Study Sites and Methodology
The research team utilized a Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV) to collect sediment cores from three distinct sites in the northern South China Sea. These sites represent different stages of seep development: ROV07-02 (poorly developed), ROV05-02 (intermediate), and ROV07-01 (highly developed).
Key techniques included:
- Geochemical Profiling: Measuring sulfate, dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC), and methane concentrations to determine the activity level of the environment.
- Comparative Sequencing: High-throughput sequencing of 16S rRNA (RNA-based) and 16S rDNA (DNA-based) to differentiate between the total and metabolically active communities.
- Quantitative PCR (qPCR): Counting copies of specific functional genes, such as mcrA (methane metabolism) and apsA (sulfate reduction).
- Network Analysis: Visualizing syntrophic (mutually beneficial) relationships between methane-oxidizing archaea and sulfate-reducing bacteria.
Geochemical and Microbial Results
The geochemical data provided clear evidence of varying activity levels across the sites. Site ROV07-01, characterized by extensive dead Calyptogena clam shells, showed the most intense AOM activity, with sulfate concentrations dropping significantly within the top 55 cm of sediment.
Key findings from the microbial analysis include:
- The "Active" Difference: The microbial community looked vastly different at the RNA level compared to the DNA level. RNA libraries showed a much higher abundance of methane-metabolizing archaea and sulfate-reducing bacteria, proving that these groups are the primary "engines" of the ecosystem despite what DNA-only counts might suggest.
- The Rise of ANME-2dI: This is the first report of high proportions of ANME-2dI in the northern South China Sea. In the active layers of site ROV05-02, ANME-2dI accounted for up to 73.5% of the total archaeal RNA sequences. Its presence in the "intermediate" site suggests it may be an early colonizer.
- Specific Partnerships: Network analysis showed that different ANME groups maintain specific "social circles" of sulfate-reducing bacteria, suggesting highly specialized metabolic handshakes.
Discussion and Conclusion
The study proposes that cold seeps go through successional stages. ROV07-02 represents a poorly developed stage with low activity. ROV05-02, colonized by living clams, shows high ANME-2dI activity. Finally, ROV07-01 represents a highly developed stage dominated by ANME-2a/b and extensive sulfide-rich sediments.
While the study identifies who is active, most of these organisms remain uncultivated in the lab. Further metagenomic and proteomic studies are needed to fully decode the metabolic pathways these microbes use to survive in such extreme environments. This research enriches our understanding of active sulfate-dependent AOM in emerging cold seep sediments by contrasting DNA- and RNA-derived community structures.
Summary updated