Activation of the DLPFC Reveals an Asymmetric Effect in Risky Decision Making: Evidence from a tDCS Study

Daqiang Huang, Shu Chen, Siqi Wang, Jinchuan Shi, Hang Ye, Jun Luo, Haoli ZhengFrontiers in Psychology 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The phenomenon of loss aversion—the tendency for losses to have a greater impact than comparable gains—is a cornerstone of behavioral economics. While neuroimaging has linked this behavior to the prefrontal cortex, the causal mechanisms remain debated. This study investigates whether unilateral stimulation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) can modulate risky decision-making in gain and loss frames. Using transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) and a Multiple Price List (MPL) task, we found that participants became more risk-averse in gain frames following left anodal stimulation and more risk-seeking in loss frames following right cathodal stimulation. These results reveal a hemispheric asymmetry in the DLPFC's role in processing risk, providing neural evidence for the multi-system nature of loss aversion.

Introduction

In behavioral economics, "loss aversion" describes the psychological reality where the pain of losing $100 is significantly more intense than the joy of gaining $100. While models like Prospect Theory have mapped this behavior for decades, the underlying neural architecture has remained unclear. Previous fMRI studies identified the prefrontal cortex as a key region, but correlational data often yielded contradictory results. This study seeks to establish causality by determining if the DLPFC acts as a single unit or if its hemispheres have specialized roles in evaluating risk across "gain" and "loss" frames.

Methods

The researchers employed Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) to establish causality by temporarily modulating neuronal excitability in 150 healthy university students. Participants were divided into five groups: Left Anodal (excitation), Left Cathodal (inhibition), Right Anodal, Right Cathodal, and a Sham (placebo) control.

Electrode placement for tDCS targeting the DLPFC (F3 and F4) and the reference electrode (Pz).

Risk appetite was measured using a Multiple Price List (MPL) task. Participants chose between a "Safe" option (a guaranteed small outcome) and a "Risky" option (a gamble for a larger outcome or nothing) across 10 rows. The "Crossover Point" (CP)—the row where a participant switches from safe to risky choices—served as the primary metric for risk preference.

Key Results and Insights

The study revealed a distinct hemispheric specialization for risk processing. The left hemisphere appears more sensitive to rewards (gains), while the right hemisphere is more sensitive to threats (losses).

  • The "Cautious" Left: Exciting the left DLPFC (anodal stimulation) made participants significantly more risk-averse in the gain frame. They were more likely to choose the "sure thing" over the gamble.
  • The "Reckless" Right: Inhibiting the right DLPFC (cathodal stimulation) made participants more risk-seeking in the loss frame. When faced with a certain loss, they became more willing to take a "double-or-nothing" gamble to avoid it.
Crossover points in the gain frame (A) and loss frame (B) across different stimulation conditions, showing significant deviations from the sham group.

Statistical analysis confirmed these interaction effects. In the gain frame, the left anodal group had a significantly higher CP (6.60) than the sham group (5.53). In the loss frame, the right cathodal group showed a higher CP (5.23) compared to sham (4.50), indicating a stronger preference for risky options to avoid loss. Notably, stimulation did not affect reaction times, suggesting the effect is specific to the decision-making process rather than general cognitive speed.

Discussion and Conclusion

These findings challenge the notion of a single "risk center" in the brain, supporting a model where decision-making emerges from the interaction of asymmetric neural systems. The study provides a feasible paradigm for understanding how the DLPFC modulates human irrationality in economic contexts.

Future research should address the limitations of the current between-subject design by exploring within-subject variations. Additionally, mapping the connectivity between the DLPFC and subcortical structures like the amygdala (fear) and striatum (reward) will be essential to fully characterizing the "loss aversion" circuit. This work expands our understanding of human behavioral preferences and aligns empirical observations in economics with neurobiological evidence.

Summary updated

Abstract

The phenomenon of loss aversion (the tendency for losses to have a greater impact than comparable gains) has long been observed in daily life. Neurocognitive studies and brain imaging studies have shed light on the correlation between the phenomenon of loss aversion and the brain region of the prefrontal cortex. Recent brain stimulation studies using bilateral transcranial magnetic stimulation or transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) have obtained various results showing the causal relationship between brain regions and decision making. With the goal of studying whether unilateral stimulation can change participants' risky decision making in the frames of gains and losses, we applied different polarities of tDCS over the regions of the right or left prefrontal cortex. We also designed a risk measurement table (Multiple Price List) to reflect the participants' attitudes toward risky decision making via the crossover point including the frames of gains and losses. The results of our experiment indicated that the participants tended to be more risk averse in the gain frame after receiving left anodal tDCS and more risk seeking in the loss frame after receiving right cathodal tDCS, which was consistent with the hypothesis that the process of risky decision making was correlated with the interaction of multiple systems in the brain. Our conclusion revealed an asymmetric effect of right/left DLPFC when the participants faced gains and losses, which partially provided the neural evidence and a feasible paradigm to help better understand risky decision making and loss aversion. The current study can not only expand the traditional understanding of the behavioral preferences of humans in economics but also accommodate empirical observations of behavioral economists on the preferences of humans.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2017activation,
  author = {Daqiang Huang and Shu Chen and Siqi Wang and Jinchuan Shi and Hang Ye and Jun Luo and Haoli Zheng},
  title = {{Activation of the DLPFC Reveals an Asymmetric Effect in Risky Decision Making: Evidence from a tDCS Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00038},
}
Figure