TL;DR
This study investigates the acoustic environments of two urban university campuses in Suzhou, China, using real-time noise measurements and surveys. The findings reveal that traffic noise is a significant contributor to campus noise pollution, with only one zone achieving an "excellent" acoustic rating. The research highlights the need for targeted noise mitigation strategies to improve the learning and living experience on campuses.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The quality of the acoustic environment within educational institutions, particularly classrooms, has been a subject of increasing research. Studies have explored how noise impacts learning, speech intelligibility, and teacher well-being. However, a significant gap exists in understanding the broader acoustic environment of campus areas outside of classrooms. This paper addresses this gap by investigating the noise levels and perceived sound sources within two modern urban university campuses, aiming to identify problem areas and inform potential solutions for improving the overall campus acoustic experience, which can indirectly affect the emotions, health, and concentration of students and staff.
Methods
The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:
- Real-time Noise Level Measurements: They used a calibrated Samsung A9 smartphone with a custom-developed "Noise Explorer" app to measure sound pressure levels (LAeq). The smartphone's microphone was calibrated against a Class 1 microphone to ensure accuracy in both sound pressure level and frequency spectrum. Measurements were taken at 30 points per zone, hourly from 6:40 to 19:40, over weekdays and weekends.
- Questionnaire Surveys: A survey was distributed to students, staff, and visitors to identify the perceived major sound sources within specific campus zones. The survey also collected information on the interviewee's location, zone, gender, frequency of visits, and their ranking of the two most prominent sound sources.
On-site observations were conducted to classify sound sources into four categories: human-made, machinery, living creatures, and natural physical sounds.
Datasets
The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it collected primary data through:
- Real-time noise measurements: Data collected from 30 points in each of the 3 zones at Xi'an Jiatong-Liverpool University (XJTLU) and 7 zones at Soochow University (Dushuhu Campus) over weekdays and weekends.
- Questionnaire responses: 273 valid questionnaires were collected from interviewees across both campuses.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Traffic is the primary campus noise culprit: The study consistently identifies road vehicles as a major sound source, particularly in zones near main traffic roads. This underscores the pervasive impact of urban traffic on even seemingly contained environments like university campuses.
- Campus zones vary significantly in acoustic quality: The research categorizes campus zones based on noise levels, revealing a spectrum from "excellent" to "fair" acoustic environments. This granular analysis is crucial for understanding localized noise issues.
- Perception matters: Combining objective noise measurements with subjective survey data provides a more holistic understanding of the acoustic environment. What is measured as noise might be perceived differently, and vice-versa, influencing the overall experience.
- Weekend vs. Weekday dynamics: Noise levels and dominant sound sources can shift between weekdays and weekends due to changes in human activity patterns (e.g., fewer lectures, more recreational activities).
Key Results
- XJTLU: Only Zone 3 (near a park) achieved an "Excellent" acoustic rating (A zone, < 55 dBA). Zone 1 (near the main traffic road) was classified as "Fair" (D zone, 65.1-70 dBA), while Zone 2 was rated "Good" (B zone, 55.1-60 dBA).
- Soochow University (Dushuhu Campus): Zones 2, 3, and 6 were rated "Good" (B zone, 55.1-60 dBA). Zones 1, 4, 5, and 7 were classified as "Average" (C zone, 60.1-65 dBA).
- Major Sound Sources Identified:
- Near main traffic roads: Road vehicles, human talking.
- High crowd areas: Human talking, footsteps.
- Park-adjacent areas: Birds, insects.
- School of Art: Music.
- Traffic Mitigation Recommendations: The study suggests implementing traffic rules such as speed limit reductions, controlling vehicle numbers during peak hours, and restricting heavy vehicles during certain periods to mitigate noise pollution.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limitations:
- The study focused on daytime noise levels, using the daytime thresholds of the Environmental Quality Standard for Noise (GB 3096-2008). Nighttime noise was not assessed.
- The use of a smartphone for measurements, while calibrated, might have limitations compared to professional-grade sound level meters in certain complex acoustic scenarios.
- Future Work:
- The authors propose constructing a noise map using CadnaA software to evaluate the effectiveness of proposed traffic noise mitigation measures.
- Further research could explore the impact of these acoustic environments on student and staff well-being and academic performance more directly.
- Investigating nighttime noise levels would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the campus acoustic environment.
Summary updated