TL;DR
This paper investigates the acoustical and musical properties of a reconstructed Deskford carnyx, a Celtic brass instrument. By combining acoustic measurements with the extensive performance experience of a renowned carnyx player, the study sheds light on the instrument's unique sound and playing characteristics, offering insights into historical instrument design and performance.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The carnyx, an ancient Celtic lip-excited wind instrument, is known primarily from archaeological fragments and artistic depictions. While reconstructions have been attempted, a deep understanding of their acoustical behavior and musical potential has been limited. Specifically, the Deskford carnyx reconstruction, based on a fragment found in Scotland, involved significant design choices regarding its length and bore profile due to the incomplete nature of the original artifact. This paper aims to bridge the gap between historical reconstruction and scientific understanding by thoroughly analyzing the acoustical properties of this specific reconstruction and relating them to its musical performance, especially in light of new archaeological findings from Tintignac, France.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach:
- Acoustic Measurements:
- Input Impedance Measurement: Using the BIAS apparatus, they measured the input impedance of the instrument to identify its resonance frequencies and their harmonic relationships.
- Acoustic Pulse Reflectometry (APR): This technique was used to reconstruct the internal bore profile of the carnyx, complementing physical measurements.
- Transfer Function Measurement: This involved measuring the ratio of acoustic pressure at the mouthpiece entrance to the radiated sound field at a distance, providing insights into the instrument's radiation efficiency.
- Spectral Centroid Analysis: To assess the "brassiness" of the sound, they measured how the spectral centroid of the radiated sound changed with increasing input pressure, indicating nonlinear distortion.
- Musical Performance Analysis:
- Playing Frequency Recording: Recordings of a skilled carnyx player, John Kenny, were analyzed to identify the natural playing frequencies and pitches.
- Spectrum Analysis: The frequency spectra of played notes were calculated and compared with the instrument's input impedance to understand how the player excites resonances.
- Equivalent Fundamental Pitch (EFP): This metric was used to visualize the relationship between the instrument's resonances and the harmonics of played notes, highlighting deviations from a perfect harmonic series.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on measurements taken from a physical reconstruction of the Deskford carnyx.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Non-Harmonic Resonances: The input impedance of the Deskford carnyx shows that its resonance frequencies are not perfectly harmonically related. This is a significant departure from many modern brass instruments and contributes to its unique sound.
- Mouthpiece Design Impact: The chosen mouthpiece design, with a minimal bore constriction, significantly influences the instrument's acoustical behavior, particularly the boosting of impedance peaks.
- "Trombone Mute" Effect: The transfer function of the carnyx exhibits a deep minimum around 1500 Hz and strong peaks at higher frequencies, suggesting that the mouth shape and tongue might function acoustically like a trombone mute, shaping the sound in a distinctive way.
- Large Dynamic Range: The instrument's wide bore and efficient sound radiation contribute to a remarkably large dynamic range, allowing for both very soft (pianissimo) and very loud (fortissimo) playing.
- Brassiness Potential: The carnyx possesses a significant "brassiness potential," indicating its capacity for nonlinear distortion that generates rich, complex timbres, similar to trombones.
- Tintignac Comparison: The discovery of carnyx parts at Tintignac, France, provides a valuable point of comparison, particularly regarding mouthpiece design, and suggests that the Deskford reconstruction's mouthpiece is consistent with historical examples.
Key Results
- The Deskford carnyx reconstruction has a length of approximately 1.6 meters.
- Its cutoff frequency is estimated to be around 2500 Hz, about three times that of a tenor trombone.
- The playing frequencies of some notes, like E3 and C4, were found to be slightly offset from the instrument's resonance peaks, indicating the player's ability to fine-tune pitch.
- The brassiness potential parameter (B) was calculated to be 0.69, a value typical for trombone-family instruments.
Limitations and Future Work
- Speculative Reconstruction: The authors acknowledge that any reconstruction of an ancient instrument inevitably involves speculation, particularly regarding aspects not preserved in the original fragment.
- Understanding Low Notes: The two lowest notes identified by John Kenny (D#1 and D#2) are difficult to explain solely based on the measured input impedance, suggesting they might function as pedal notes.
- Further Tintignac Insights: The authors suggest that further investigation of the Tintignac carnyx finds could provide more definitive answers about the nature of these ancient instruments, though they caution that the carnyx likely existed in various forms over centuries.
- Reconstruction's Musical Role: The paper highlights that reconstructions, despite their speculative nature, can result in instruments capable of playing a valuable role in contemporary musical culture, as demonstrated by John Kenny's extensive use of the Deskford carnyx.
Summary updated