Acoustic Source Localization in CFRP Composite Plate Based on Wave Velocity-Direction Function Fitting

Yu Zhang, Yu Feng, Xiaobo Rui, Lixin Xu, Lei Qi, Zi Yang, Cong Hu, Peng Liu, Haijiang Zhang2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel acoustic source localization method for Carbon Fiber-Reinforced Polymer (CFRP) composite plates. By fitting a wave velocity-direction function and constructing a theoretical time-difference matrix, the method achieves accurate impact localization with a simple system and minimal data, demonstrating an average error of just 1.44 cm.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Composite materials, like CFRP, are increasingly used in critical applications due to their high strength-to-weight ratio. However, they are susceptible to damage from impacts, which can compromise structural integrity. Accurately locating these impact points is crucial for safety and maintenance. Existing acoustic source localization methods often struggle with the anisotropic nature of composite materials, leading to complex systems, low accuracy, or impractical assumptions. This paper aims to overcome these limitations by developing a more robust and practical localization technique specifically for CFRP plates.

Methods

The proposed method involves four key steps:

  1. Wave Velocity-Direction Function Establishment: The anisotropic nature of CFRP means that the speed of acoustic waves (Lamb waves) varies with direction. This relationship is modeled by fitting a function to experimentally measured wave velocities at different angles.
  2. Theoretical Time Difference Matrix Establishment: The composite plate is divided into a grid. For each grid point, a theoretical time difference matrix is constructed. This matrix represents the expected time differences of acoustic signals arriving at different sensors if the impact originated from that grid point. This calculation relies on the established wave velocity-direction function.
  3. Actual Time Difference Vector Obtained: When an impact occurs, acoustic emission sensors detect the signal. The arrival times at each sensor are measured, and the actual time difference vector between sensor pairs is calculated.
  4. Impact Source Localization: The actual time difference vector is compared with the theoretical time difference matrix. The grid point that yields the minimum error between the theoretical and actual time differences is identified as the impact source location.

The authors employed both finite element simulations and a lead-break experiment (to simulate impact without damaging the specimen) to validate their approach.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention training datasets. However, it utilizes:

  • Finite Element Simulation Data: A simulated CFRP plate model was used to generate acoustic signal propagation data and verify the wave velocity-direction function.
  • Experimental Data: A lead-break experiment was conducted on a CFRP plate. This experiment generated acoustic signals from controlled impact points, which were used to validate the localization algorithm. The paper presents data from 49 impact points, each tested twice and averaged.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Anisotropy is Key: The paper highlights that the anisotropic nature of CFRP is not just a challenge but a crucial factor to be modeled. The wave velocity-direction function captures this anisotropy, which is essential for accurate localization.
  • Wave Velocity-Direction Function as a Foundation: Instead of relying on a single, averaged wave speed, the method leverages a directional wave speed model. This allows for more precise calculation of signal propagation times across the plate.
  • Grid-Based Theoretical Matrix: The concept of creating a comprehensive theoretical time-difference matrix for a meshed plate is a core innovation. This allows for a direct comparison with measured data without needing complex iterative algorithms for every localization.
  • Lead-Break Experiment for Validation: Using a lead-break experiment is a clever way to simulate impact events repeatedly and precisely without causing irreversible damage to the composite material, enabling robust experimental validation.

Key Results

  • High Accuracy: The proposed method achieved an average localization error of 1.44 cm across 49 experimental points.
  • Low Maximum Error: The maximum localization error was 3.35 cm.
  • Simple System: The localization system is described as simple, requiring a relatively small number of sensors (four in the experimental setup) and minimal data.
  • Good Stability: The results demonstrate good stability and accuracy in localizing impact sources.
  • Comparison with Existing Methods: Table 4 shows that the proposed method offers a competitive normalization error (1.440 x 10⁻⁵ mm⁻¹) with a significantly lower number of sensors compared to other advanced techniques.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Symmetric Peaks in Error Matrix: The authors note that the error indexing process can sometimes exhibit symmetric peaks and valleys. This is attributed to the symmetry in sensor arrangement and the wave speed-angle relationship in the composite plate. This phenomenon leads to similar difference values at two grid points, potentially complicating precise localization in some cases.
  • Generalizability: While validated for CFRP plates, the direct applicability to other composite materials or different plate geometries might require re-calibration of the wave velocity-direction function.
  • Future Work: The paper implicitly suggests that further refinement of the error analysis and potentially exploring different sensor configurations could further improve accuracy and mitigate the symmetric peak issue. Investigating the method's performance under varying environmental conditions or with different types of impact damage could also be valuable future research directions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2023acoustic,
  author = {Yu Zhang and Yu Feng and Xiaobo Rui and Lixin Xu and Lei Qi and Zi Yang and Cong Hu and Peng Liu and Haijiang Zhang},
  title = {{Acoustic Source Localization in CFRP Composite Plate Based on Wave Velocity-Direction Function Fitting}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23063052},
}
Figure