TL;DR
This paper presents a dual-strategy approach to quiet bioinspired flapping-wing micro aerial vehicles (FWMAVs) by optimizing wing geometry. By using a nonlinear structural model to optimize carbon-fiber venation patterns and adding bioinspired trailing-edge fringes, the researchers achieved up to a 7.8 dB reduction in impulsive "reversal clicks" and a 4 dB reduction in broadband "swoosh" noise without sacrificing lift.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
While flapping-wing robots are often touted for their potential for quiet, unobtrusive flight, the reality is disappointing: engineered wings are typically 15–30 dB louder than the animals they mimic. This "acoustic gap" limits their use in sensitive environments like wildlife observation or indoor monitoring.
The authors identify two primary noise sources in membrane wings:
- The Reversal Click: An impulsive sound caused by the wing membrane "snapping through" between curvatures at the end of each stroke.
- The Aerodynamic Swoosh: Broadband noise generated by vortical flow shed at the trailing edge.
Previous research focused on performance (lift/thrust) rather than acoustics. This paper aims to fill that gap by treating wing venation (the stiffening ribs) and edge geometry as design variables for noise mitigation.
Methods
The researchers developed a comprehensive wing design framework that combines computational optimization with a novel manufacturing process.
1. Venation Optimization
To tackle the reversal click, the team modeled the wing as a von Kármán plate—a thin-sheet model that accounts for large out-of-plane deflections. Crucially, they identified that the click is a dynamic, inertia-driven event rather than a static buckling one. They implemented an iterative optimization loop (see Figure 3) using Bayesian optimization and a Gaussian process to find the quietest rib layout. The objective function was a "loading-rate surrogate"—essentially the high-passed rate of change of force the wing exerts on the air.

2. Bioinspired Fringes
For the broadband swoosh, they looked to hummingbird feathers. They compared standard "cut" serrations (which remove wing area) against additive fringes—triangular teeth added beyond the mean trailing edge. This approach aims to disrupt vortex shedding without losing lifting surface.
3. Integrated Manufacturing
To ensure precision, the team moved away from gluing individual carbon rods. Instead, they used a CNC waterjet to cut single-piece wing frames (including the optimized venation) from cured carbon-fiber sheets, which were then bonded to a foam membrane.
Datasets
While this paper does not use a traditional large-scale dataset, it relies on:
- Computational Evaluations: 180 unique wing designs were simulated during the Bayesian optimization process to map the design space.
- Experimental Benchmarking: A custom flapping-mechanism test rig (Figure 2) was used to collect acoustic and lift data for a baseline wing (B0), two venation variants (M1, M1-adverse), and six edge-treatment variations (F0-F4 and a subtractive serration).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Orientation Over Thickness: The optimization revealed that the angle of the venation ribs is far more critical for noise reduction than their thickness.
- Diagonal Ribs are Key: The most effective designs placed ribs at a diagonal (roughly 48°) near the wing root. This is because the wing undergoes significant shear/twist during stroke reversal; a diagonal rib crosses these principal directions of twist, stiffening the membrane against the snap-through.
- Additive vs. Subtractive: While cut serrations are common in airfoil research, additive fringes are superior for FWMAVs. They provide comparable noise reduction to cut serrations but generate significantly more lift (approx. 25% more) by maintaining the full membrane area.
- Mass as a Self-Penalty: In the optimization, adding too much carbon fiber actually increased noise because the extra mass increased the inertial load at stroke reversal. The "quietest" wing was not the stiffest one, but the one with the best stiffness-to-mass distribution.
Key Results
The researchers successfully manufactured and tested several wing designs (Figure 4) to validate their models.
- Venation: The optimized M1 design reduced the reversal click by 7.8 dB at the 90° microphone position compared to the baseline (Figure 5). Even a minor 5° change in rib angle (M1-adverse) almost entirely removed this benefit, highlighting the sensitivity of the design.
- Fringes: The best fringe design (F2, short and coarse) reduced broadband noise by 4.1 dB (Figure 6).
- Lift Performance: The optimized venation wing (M1) actually produced slightly more lift than the baseline (0.112 N vs 0.102 N).

Limitations and Future Work
The primary limitation noted was the mechanical noise floor. Above 1 kHz, the noise from the flapping mechanism's drive system dominated the acoustic signature, masking potential further improvements from the wing design.
Future research directions include:
- Developing a quieter flapping mechanism to explore high-frequency noise reduction.
- Testing a "combined" wing that features both optimized venation and additive fringes.
- Investigating how these passive geometric changes perform across different flapping frequencies and amplitudes.
Summary updated