Acoustic Features Associated with Sustained Vowel and Continuous Speech Productions by Chinese Children with Functional Articulation Disorders

Wang Zhang, Xiangquan Gui, Tianqi Wang, Manwa Ng, Feng Yang, Lan Wang, Nan YanInterspeech 2018

TL;DR

This study investigates acoustic features in the speech of Chinese children with Functional Articulation Disorder (FAD) to identify objective markers for diagnosis and evaluation. By analyzing sustained vowels and continuous speech, researchers found that specific acoustic patterns in FAD children, such as reduced articulatory movement and altered voice onset times, can differentiate them from typically developing children, offering a more objective approach to understanding and addressing FAD.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Functional Articulation Disorder (FAD) is a common speech disorder in preschoolers that can negatively impact communication and long-term psychological development. While FAD is prevalent, current diagnostic and evaluative methods often rely on subjective perceptual assessments by speech therapists. This approach can be inconsistent and may not be ideal for large-scale studies or objective tracking of progress. The paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring objective acoustic features in the speech of Chinese children with FAD, moving beyond purely perceptual analysis to provide quantifiable insights into their speech production difficulties. This is particularly important given that FAD can affect up to 10% of preschool children, and early identification and intervention are crucial for improving outcomes.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of established acoustic analysis techniques. For sustained vowel production, they focused on analyzing the first two formant frequencies (F1 and F2) to calculate several key acoustic features:

  • Formant Centralization Ratio (FCR3): Measures the overall movement of the tongue in both vertical and horizontal directions.
  • F1 Range Ratio (F1RR): Specifically quantifies the vertical movement of the tongue.
  • F2 Range Ratio (F2RR): Quantifies the horizontal movement of the tongue.
  • Triangular Vowel Space Area (TVSA): A measure of the overall range of vowel articulation, calculated from the F1 and F2 values of the corner vowels /a/, /i/, and /u/.

For continuous speech, they analyzed Voice Onset Time (VOT), which is the time interval between the release of a stop consonant and the onset of vocal fold vibration. This is a crucial parameter for distinguishing between voiced and voiceless stop consonants. The analysis was conducted using the Praat software, and speech samples were recorded with a high-quality microphone at a 44100 Hz sampling rate.

Datasets

The study utilized speech samples from two groups of participants:

  • FAD Group: 67 children diagnosed with FAD, recruited from Shenzhen Children's Hospital.
  • Control Group: 30 typically developing children, recruited from local kindergartens.

All participants were native Mandarin speakers and aged between 3 and 6 years old. The study also included a prerecorded set of Mandarin phrases containing various stop consonants, produced by a native Mandarin speaker, which served as a reference for continuous speech analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gender Matters in FAD Acoustics: The study highlights that acoustic patterns can differ significantly between boys and girls with FAD, suggesting that gender-specific analyses are crucial for accurate assessment.
  • Articulatory Undershooting: FAD children, particularly girls, exhibit reduced articulatory movement, especially in the vertical dimension of tongue movement, leading to less distinct vowel sounds.
  • VOT as a Diagnostic Tool: Alterations in Voice Onset Time (VOT) for both unaspirated and aspirated stop consonants in FAD children suggest difficulties in controlling the release of oral occlusion and coordinating respiratory and articulatory systems.
  • Objective Measures for Subjective Issues: The research demonstrates that acoustic features can provide objective, quantifiable data to complement subjective perceptual evaluations of FAD, potentially leading to more consistent and reliable diagnoses.

Key Results

  • FCR3 and F1RR: FAD girls showed significantly lower F1RR (indicating reduced vertical tongue movement) and higher FCR3 (indicating altered overall tongue movement) compared to controls. FAD boys also showed a trend towards lower F1RR and higher FCR3, though not statistically significant.
  • TVSA: No significant difference was found in Triangular Vowel Space Area (TVSA) between FAD and control groups for either boys or girls, suggesting that while individual formant ranges might be affected, the overall vowel space area might be less sensitive to FAD in this cohort.
  • VOT: FAD boys exhibited significantly longer VOTs for unaspirated stop consonants (/b/, /d/, /g/) and shorter VOTs for aspirated stop consonants (/p/, /t/, /k/) compared to controls. FAD girls also showed significantly longer VOTs for unaspirated stops. These differences suggest a reduced categorical distinction between voiced and unvoiced stops in FAD children.
  • Vowel Distortions: The study noted that /u/ was more frequently misarticulated by boys with FAD, while girls tended to have more distortions in /i/.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Interspeaker Variability: The authors acknowledge that interspeaker variability might have masked some differences, particularly in boys, and suggest that using logarithmically scaled TVSA in future studies could help mitigate this.
  • Limited Scope of Vowel Distortions: While specific vowel distortions were noted, the study focused on acoustic features rather than a comprehensive phonetic analysis of all possible distortions.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that the identified acoustic features can be used to differentiate pathological from healthy speech and could be integrated into objective assessments for FAD, particularly for evaluating the effectiveness of clinical interventions. Further research could explore the application of these metrics in longitudinal studies to track speech development and treatment outcomes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018acoustic,
  author = {Wang Zhang and Xiangquan Gui and Tianqi Wang and Manwa Ng and Feng Yang and Lan Wang and Nan Yan},
  title = {{Acoustic Features Associated with Sustained Vowel and Continuous Speech Productions by Chinese Children with Functional Articulation Disorders}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure