Acoustic and Perceptual Characteristics of Mandarin Speech in Homosexual and Heterosexual Male Speakers

Puyang Geng, Wentao Gu, Hiroya FujisakiInterspeech 2018

TL;DR

This study investigates acoustic and perceptual differences in Mandarin speech between homosexual and heterosexual males. It reveals that Mandarin homosexual males exhibit distinct vocal characteristics, often in opposition to those found in Western studies, suggesting a cultural influence on how sexual orientation is expressed and perceived through voice.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the question of whether sexual orientation influences speech characteristics in Mandarin-speaking males, and how these characteristics are perceived. While previous research has explored this in English, Cantonese, and Spanish, no such study existed for Mandarin. This is significant because language and culture can shape vocal expression, and understanding these nuances is crucial for a comprehensive view of how voice conveys identity. The authors aim to identify specific acoustic cues that differentiate homosexual and heterosexual male Mandarin speakers and to determine if these cues are perceived by listeners.

Methods

The study employed two main methods: acoustic analysis and a perceptual experiment.

  • Acoustic Analysis: Researchers analyzed recordings of monosyllabic Mandarin words spoken by 24 male participants (12 homosexual, 12 heterosexual). They focused on:
  • Fundamental Frequency (F0): Examining F0 contours, mean, maximum, minimum, and range across four Mandarin tones. Growth curve analysis was used to model F0 changes over time.
  • Vowel Formants (F1 and F2): Analyzing the first two formants of three key vowels to understand vowel space and articulation.
  • Consonant Durations: Measuring the length of aspiration/frication for several consonants.
  • Spectral Properties of /s/: Analyzing the center of gravity and skewness of the fricative /s/.
  • Perceptual Experiment: Thirty participants (15 male, 15 female) listened to recordings of monosyllabic words from both groups and rated the speakers' "gayness" on a 5-point scale. The study then correlated these perceptual scores with the acoustic parameters.

Datasets

The study utilized two datasets:

  • Acoustic Dataset: Recordings of 64 monosyllabic Mandarin words (including nine consonants, three vowels, and four tones) spoken by 24 male participants (12 homosexual, 12 heterosexual). For analysis, specific subsets of these words were selected based on the features being investigated (e.g., 32 words for F0 and formants, 41 words for consonant durations).
  • Perceptual Dataset: A subset of 18 monosyllabic Mandarin words, chosen for their potential to reveal significant acoustic differences, were used for the perceptual experiment. These words were presented to 30 participants (15 male, 15 female).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cultural Opposition: A striking finding is that Mandarin homosexual males often exhibit acoustic characteristics that are the opposite of what has been observed in Western studies (e.g., American English). This suggests that cultural context and social acceptance significantly influence how vocal cues of sexual orientation are expressed and potentially suppressed.
  • Feminine Voice Stereotype: While Western studies suggest homosexual males may adopt more "feminine" vocal traits (e.g., higher pitch, larger vowel space), Mandarin homosexual males in this study showed lower F0 and a smaller vowel space. This is hypothesized to be a strategy to avoid perceived feminine traits due to lower social acceptance of homosexuality in China.
  • Universal Cue: Despite cultural differences in other acoustic features, the lengthened duration of fricatives (like /s/) was observed in Mandarin homosexual males, mirroring findings in American English and Cantonese. This suggests it might be a more universal acoustic cue for perceived male homosexuality.
  • Perceptual Salience: The perceptual experiment indicated that listeners could indeed distinguish between the speech of homosexual and heterosexual male Mandarin speakers. The study suggests that while F0 and vowel formants might be manipulated to mask sexual orientation, the duration of fricatives could be a more robust and less consciously controlled cue.

Key Results

  • Acoustic Differences:
    • Homosexual males had significantly lower mean F0, lower F0 max, and narrower F0 range compared to heterosexual males.
  • The acoustic vowel space (tVSA) was significantly smaller for homosexual males, with a notably lower F1 for the vowel /a/.
  • All six measured consonants (/s/, /s/, /ph/, /tsh/, /tsh/, /tch/) were significantly longer in duration for homosexual males.
  • No significant differences were found in the center of gravity or skewness of /s/, contradicting findings in American English studies.
  • Perceptual Findings:
    • Perceptual scores of "gayness" were significantly different between the two groups, indicating that listeners could differentiate the speakers.
  • Acoustic parameters showed correlations with perceptual scores. Notably, lower F1 of vowels, lower F0 max, narrower F0 range, and longer fricative duration were negatively correlated with higher "gayness" scores.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study acknowledges that the sample sizes for both acoustic (24 participants) and perceptual (30 participants) experiments are relatively small.
  • Controlled Speech: The speech data was collected from reading text materials, which might not fully represent spontaneous conversational speech.
  • Cultural Nuances: While the study proposes cultural explanations for the observed differences, further research is needed to explore these social psychological factors in more depth.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further testing on larger speech corpora is needed to confirm the findings, particularly regarding the interaction effects observed in vowel durations. They also emphasize the need for more research to solidify the role of fricative duration as a key perceptual cue for sexual orientation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{geng2018acoustic,
  author = {Puyang Geng and Wentao Gu and Hiroya Fujisaki},
  title = {{Acoustic and Perceptual Characteristics of Mandarin Speech in Homosexual and Heterosexual Male Speakers}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure