Acknowledgment of Ad Hoc Reviewers

Chaona Chen, Shuquan Chen, Katie Hoemann, Kevin King, Jessica P. Lougheed, Molly Mather, David Matsumoto, Kirsten Mckone, Anna Pecchinenda, Antje Rauers, Sara Waters, Tim Wildschut, Helene Aakvaag, Marlene Abadie, Elinor Abado, M.h. Adams, Elizabeth Addington, James Adelman, Idan Aderka, Saz Ahmed, Daniel Albohn, Adam Anderson, Brian Anderson, Jackie Andrade, Ulrich Ansorge, Oriana R. Aragón, Kimberly R. Hall, Pablo Arias, Ashwini Ashokkumar, Anthony B. Atkinson, Hillel Craig, Steven T. Bailey, Emily Balcetis, Nicholas L. Balderston, Conrad Baldner, Jonathan C. Banks, Yoav Bar‐Anan, Sarah Barber, Kim Barchard, Eran Bar‐Kalifa, Meaghan Barlow, Abigail L. Barthel, Andrew P. Bayliss, James C. Beck, Raul Berrios, Sara Berzenski, Patrick Beymer, Maik Bieleke, Yochanan Bigman, Gijs Bijlstra, Luiz Biondi, Jessica Birg, Caroline Blais, Lian Bloch, Giuseppe Boccignone, Paul Bogdan, Suzanna Bono, Sara Borgomareni, Ty Boyer, Margaret M. Bradley, Eboni Bradley, Charles J. Brainerd, Seger M. Breugelmans, Miriam Brinberg, Annette Brose, Nick Brosowsky, Melissa A. Brotman, Mitch Brown, Casey Brown, Tony W. Buchanan, Eva Buechel, Emily Butler, Claus‐Christian Carbon, Cheryl Carmichael, Luis Carretié, Fausto Caruana, Lahnna I. Catalino, James Cavanagh, Annalise Caviasco, A. M. Chadwick, Valerie Chang, Yen-Ping Chang, Susan Turk, Charles Srinwanti, H Chaudhury, Robert Chavez, Jennifer S. Cheavens, Elizabeth Chervonsky, Kimberly S. Chiew, Brian Chin, Alice Chirico, Sinhae Cho, Yoonseok Choi, Vivian M. Ciaramitaro, David Clewett, Rebecca J. Cobb, John Coffey, Clara Colombatto, Nathan Consedine, Anne ConwayEmotion 2022 · DOI

Abstract: The editorial team of Emotion gratefully acknowledges the many individuals who provided the peer-review labor necessary to maintain the journal's standards between September 2021 and September 2022. This formal acknowledgment addresses the "recognition gap" in academia by providing a public record of service for hundreds of scholars.

The Essential Role of Peer Review

In the academic ecosystem, peer review is the primary mechanism for ensuring research quality and integrity. However, this work is typically unpaid, time-consuming, and—crucially—anonymous. This lack of visibility can make it difficult for researchers, especially those in early-career stages, to receive professional credit for their service.

By publishing this acknowledgment, the American Psychological Association (APA) transforms "service" into a citable contribution. It acknowledges that the journal’s ability to publish high-quality research on emotional processes is entirely dependent on the voluntary time and expertise of the broader scientific community.

Methodology of Recognition

While not an experimental study, the document reflects a systematic editorial method for tracking and rewarding service over a 12-month window. The journal established a specific threshold for "Principal Ad Hoc Reviewers": individuals who completed four or more reviews for Emotion within the year.

The list of Principal Ad Hoc Reviewers who completed four or more reviews in the 2021-2022 cycle.

Additionally, the list identifies "coreviewers" (marked with an asterisk). This practice acknowledges the collaborative nature of reviewing, where senior faculty often mentor graduate students or postdocs through the review process, ensuring the next generation of scholars is trained in critical evaluation.

The Scale of Contribution

The sheer volume of names—spanning multiple pages—illustrates the massive human infrastructure required to run a single high-impact journal. The list includes names from institutions worldwide, reflecting the global nature of modern psychological research and the diversity of the affective science community.

A portion of the extensive list of ad hoc reviewers who contributed to the journal's peer-review process.

Key Insights

  • The "Super-Reviewer" Phenomenon: A small subset of the community carries a disproportionate share of the load. Reviewing four or more papers a year for a single journal represents a significant commitment of professional time.
  • Formalizing Invisible Labor: By providing this public record, the journal allows reviewers to include this service in tenure and promotion dossiers, helping to bridge the gap between anonymous labor and professional advancement.

Conclusion

As journals move toward more robust ways of recognizing reviewers—such as integration with ORCID or "Reviewer of the Year" awards—this acknowledgment remains a vital step. While it does not capture the specific quality or timeliness of reviews, it provides a necessary foundation for valuing the labor that sustains scientific publishing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The editorial team of Emotion gratefully acknowledges the many individuals who
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2022acknowledgment,
  author = {Chaona Chen and Shuquan Chen and Katie Hoemann and Kevin King and Jessica P. Lougheed and Molly Mather and David Matsumoto and Kirsten Mckone and Anna Pecchinenda and Antje Rauers and Sara Waters and Tim Wildschut and Helene Aakvaag and Marlene Abadie and Elinor Abado and M.H. Adams and Elizabeth Addington and James Adelman and Idan Aderka and Saz Ahmed and Daniel Albohn and Adam Anderson and Brian Anderson and Jackie Andrade and Ulrich Ansorge and Oriana R. Aragón and Kimberly R. Hall and Pablo Arias and Ashwini Ashokkumar and Anthony B. Atkinson and Hillel Craig and Steven T. Bailey and Emily Balcetis and Nicholas L. Balderston and Conrad Baldner and Jonathan C. Banks and Yoav Bar‐Anan and Sarah Barber and Kim Barchard and Eran Bar‐Kalifa and Meaghan Barlow and Abigail L. Barthel and Andrew P. Bayliss and James C. Beck and Raul Berrios and Sara Berzenski and Patrick Beymer and Maik Bieleke and Yochanan Bigman and Gijs Bijlstra and Luiz Biondi and Jessica Birg and Caroline Blais and Lian Bloch and Giuseppe Boccignone and Paul Bogdan and Suzanna Bono and Sara Borgomareni and Ty Boyer and Margaret M. Bradley and Eboni Bradley and Charles J. Brainerd and Seger M. Breugelmans and Miriam Brinberg and Annette Brose and Nick Brosowsky and Melissa A. Brotman and Mitch Brown and Casey Brown and Tony W. Buchanan and Eva Buechel and Emily Butler and Claus‐Christian Carbon and Cheryl Carmichael and Luis Carretié and Fausto Caruana and Lahnna I. Catalino and James Cavanagh and Annalise Caviasco and A. M. Chadwick and Valerie Chang and Yen-Ping Chang and Susan Turk and Charles Srinwanti and H Chaudhury and Robert Chavez and Jennifer S. Cheavens and Elizabeth Chervonsky and Kimberly S. Chiew and Brian Chin and Alice Chirico and Sinhae Cho and Yoonseok Choi and Vivian M. Ciaramitaro and David Clewett and Rebecca J. Cobb and John Coffey and Clara Colombatto and Nathan Consedine and Anne Conway},
  title = {{Acknowledgment of Ad Hoc Reviewers}},
  booktitle = {Emotion},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1037/emo0001195},
}
Figure