Achieving diverse and monoallelic olfactory receptor selection through dual-objective optimization design

Xiao‐Jun Tian, Hang Zhang, Jens Sannerud, Jianhua XingProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel three-layer regulatory model for olfactory receptor (OR) gene expression in mammals. It explains how a single neuron can express only one OR allele (monoallelic expression) while the entire olfactory system maximizes the diversity of expressed ORs, a seemingly contradictory dual objective. The model reveals an elegant, evolutionarily optimized system that combines zonal segregation, epigenetic regulation, and enhancer competition.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The mammalian olfactory system faces a fascinating challenge: each olfactory sensory neuron (OSN) must express only one type of olfactory receptor (OR) out of thousands of possibilities to ensure precise odor detection. However, at the organism level, it's crucial to express a wide variety of ORs to detect a broad range of smells. This dual requirement of monoallelic expression within a single neuron and maximal diversity across the population has been a long-standing puzzle. Existing models primarily focused on achieving monoallelic expression and failed to explain experimental observations, particularly regarding the reduced diversity seen in certain genetic knockouts.

Methods

The authors developed a comprehensive computational model that integrates existing experimental data on OR expression. This model is built upon physical interactions and employs a three-layer regulatory mechanism:

  1. Zonal Segregation: The olfactory epithelium is divided into zones, each expressing a subset of OR alleles, effectively reducing the number of competing alleles per neuron.
  2. Epigenetic Barrier Crossing: This is the core of the model. It involves a dynamic epigenetic regulation process where histone marks (H3K9me3 for repression, H3K4me3 for activation) on OR genes are modified. A key element is the bifunctional enzyme LSD1, which can remove both repressive and active marks, facilitating a "barrier-crossing" dynamic. This process is coupled with a negative feedback loop involving Adcy3, which helps stabilize the chosen OR allele.
  3. Enhancer Competition: In cases where multiple alleles become epigenetically active, a limited pool of enhancers competes to bind to and activate these alleles. This competition acts as a backup mechanism to ensure only one allele is ultimately transcribed.

The model uses stochastic Gillespie simulations and deterministic rate equations to capture the complex dynamics of these processes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual-Objective Optimization: The olfactory system is framed as a multi-objective optimization problem, elegantly balancing the need for single-cell specificity with organism-level diversity.
  • Bifunctional LSD1 as a Key Regulator: The enzyme LSD1's ability to remove both repressive and active histone marks is crucial for the "barrier-crossing" dynamics, enabling a switch to an active state and then stabilizing it.
  • Enhancer Competition as a "Safeguard": This mechanism acts as a crucial backup, ensuring monoallelic expression even when the epigenetic machinery falters, without severely compromising overall diversity.
  • "Tug-of-War" in Epigenetic Regulation: The process is likened to a "tug-of-war" between adding and removing histone marks, analogous to ultrasensitive cycles in signal transduction.
  • Evolutionary Design: The model suggests that the observed regulatory mechanisms are not arbitrary but represent an optimally designed system shaped by evolution.

Key Results

  • The model successfully recapitulates monoallelic OR expression and explains how the olfactory system maintains OR diversity.
  • It predicts that reducing LSD1 concentration impedes OR activation, a finding confirmed experimentally.
  • The model predicts that inhibiting H3K9 methyltransferases (G9a/GLP) leads to multiple allele activation and reduced OR diversity, also experimentally validated.
  • It explains why certain genes show upregulated expression in G9a/GLP knockout mice, attributing it to stronger enhancer interactions.
  • The model predicts multiple mechanisms for OR transcription switching, including pseudogene activation and enhancer-mediated switching.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Sensitivity: While the model is robust, the exact values of parameters like enhancer binding affinities and concentrations can be difficult to determine experimentally and may influence specific outcomes.
  • Simplifications: The model makes some simplifying assumptions, such as treating enhancers equally and assuming no free enhancers initially.
  • Experimental Validation: The authors suggest several experiments to further test their predictions, including:
  • Introducing or removing OR alleles in a zone to study the effect on activation ratios.
  • Using CRISPR-Cas9 to fluorescently label specific genes and study switching frequencies in normal mice.
  • Investigating the epigenetic patterns of silent OR alleles in G9a/GLP knockout mice.
  • Introducing enhancers ectopically into G9a KO mice to see if OR diversity is rescued.
  • Monitoring histone modification states of individual alleles over time to confirm epigenetic switching mechanisms.

Summary updated

Abstract

Multiple-objective optimization is common in biological systems. In the mammalian olfactory system, each sensory neuron stochastically expresses only one out of up to thousands of olfactory receptor (OR) gene alleles; at the organism level, the types of expressed ORs need to be maximized. Existing models focus only on monoallele activation, and cannot explain recent observations in mutants, especially the reduced global diversity of expressed ORs in G9a/GLP knockouts. In this work we integrated existing information on OR expression, and constructed a comprehensive model that has all its components based on physical interactions. Analyzing the model reveals an evolutionarily optimized three-layer regulation mechanism, which includes zonal segregation, epigenetic barrier crossing coupled to a negative feedback loop that mechanistically differs from previous theoretical proposals, and a previously unidentified enhancer competition step. This model not only recapitulates monoallelic OR expression, but also elucidates how the olfactory system maximizes and maintains the diversity of OR expression, and has multiple predictions validated by existing experimental results. Through making an analogy to a physical system with thermally activated barrier crossing and comparative reverse engineering analyses, the study reveals that the olfactory receptor selection system is optimally designed, and particularly underscores cooperativity and synergy as a general design principle for multiobjective optimization in biology.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tian2016achieving,
  author = {Xiao‐Jun Tian and Hang Zhang and Jens Sannerud and Jianhua Xing},
  title = {{Achieving diverse and monoallelic olfactory receptor selection through dual-objective optimization design}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1601722113},
}

Loading related content...

Figure