Acetylcholinesterase/paraoxonase genotype and expression predict anxiety scores in Health, Risk Factors, Exercise Training, and Genetics study

Ella H. Sklan, Alexander Lowenthal, Mira Korner, Ya’acov Ritov, Daniel M. Landers, Tuomo Rankinen, Claude Bouchard, Arthur S. Leon, Treva Rice, D. C. Rao, Jack H. Wilmore, James S. Skinner, Hermona SoreqProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a significant link between genetic variations and enzyme activity related to acetylcholine regulation and anxiety scores in healthy individuals. It suggests that quantifying these biochemical markers could offer a novel way to predict and potentially manage anxiety.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anxiety is a pervasive mental health issue with complex origins, involving a tangled web of genetic, environmental, and experiential factors. While psychological assessments are the current standard for measuring anxiety, identifying consistent biological markers has been challenging. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating whether specific genetic polymorphisms and the resulting activity levels of key enzymes involved in acetylcholine (ACh) signaling and detoxification can predict both trait (long-term susceptibility) and state (situational) anxiety in healthy individuals.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multi-faceted approach:

  • Serum Analyses: They measured the activity levels of three crucial enzymes: acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and butyrylcholinesterase (BChE), which break down ACh, and paraoxonase 1 (PON1), which detoxifies environmental toxins that can affect AChE.
  • Genotyping: They analyzed specific single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the genes encoding AChE, BChE, and PON1. These genetic variations are known to influence enzyme activity and are located on chromosome 7q21-22 for ACHE-PON1.
  • Statistical Analysis: A range of statistical methods were employed, including:
  • Hardy-Weinberg equilibrium and linkage disequilibrium (LD) analysis to assess genetic patterns.
  • Likelihood ratio tests and Monte Carlo simulations to determine the significance of differences between genotype groups and anxiety scores.
  • Student's t-tests for comparing enzyme activities.
  • Expectation maximization algorithms to estimate haplotype frequencies.
  • Multiple regression analysis and classification trees to build predictive models for anxiety based on demographic factors, enzyme activities, and genotypes.

Datasets

The study used data from 461 healthy individuals participating in the Health, Risk Factors, Exercise Training, and Genetics (HERITAGE) Family Study. This cohort comprised individuals of African-American and Caucasian origin.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biochemical Markers for Anxiety: The study provides compelling evidence that serum levels of AChE and PON1, along with specific genetic variations in their genes, are significantly associated with anxiety scores. This opens the door for objective, biochemical assessments of anxiety.
  • Inverse Relationship: A key finding is the inverse and reciprocal relationship between AChE and PON1 activities and anxiety measures. Higher AChE activity was linked to higher anxiety, while higher PON1 activity appeared to be protective against anxiety.
  • Trait vs. State Anxiety Distinction: The study highlights that trait anxiety (long-term susceptibility) is more strongly linked to AChE activity and its genetic underpinnings, while state anxiety (situational) shows a more complex interplay with both AChE and PON1.
  • Gene-Environment Interaction: The findings suggest that inherited genetic predispositions (genotype) interact with acquired factors (enzyme activity, potentially influenced by environment and lifestyle) to shape an individual's anxiety profile.
  • PON1 as a Protective Factor: PON1's role in detoxifying harmful compounds and protecting against oxidative stress appears to confer a protective effect against anxiety, particularly state anxiety.

Key Results

  • Serum Enzyme Activities: Serum AChE and BChE activities were higher in females and increased with age and body mass index (BMI). PON1 activity was higher in African Americans and declined with age.
  • Anxiety Correlations: Trait anxiety scores decreased with age. Serum AChE activity showed an inverse correlation with trait anxiety (R² = 0.93), suggesting it's a predictor. PON1 activity showed an inverse association with state anxiety (R² = 0.89).
  • Genotype Associations: Specific polymorphisms in the ACHE-PON1 locus were found to be significant predictors of trait anxiety, with some ethnic origin-dependent effects. For instance, heterozygosity for the ACHE P446 polymorphism and homozygosity for the PON1 192 variant were more common in high trait-anxiety groups.
  • Predictive Models: Combined biochemical and genetic data, along with demographic factors, could predict anxiety scores. A predictive tree model demonstrated how combinations of genotype, age, gender, and enzyme activities could estimate an individual's probability of belonging to the top 20% state-anxiety group.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Self-Reported Measures: The study relies on self-reported anxiety scores (STAI), which, while standard, can be subject to individual interpretation and bias. The authors suggest that future work should include diagnostic interviews for confirmation.
  • Replication Needed: The findings, particularly the biochemical associations, should be confirmed in independent samples and clinically diagnosed anxious populations to solidify their clinical value.
  • Ethnic Differences: While the study found some ethnic origin-dependent effects for ACHE-PON1 polymorphisms, further investigation into these differences is warranted.
  • Causality: While the study establishes strong associations, definitively proving causality requires further experimental manipulation.
  • Broader Implications: The authors suggest that the role of cholinergic regulation and the ACHE-PON1 locus could extend to understanding human anxiety disorders more broadly. They also propose that serum AChE levels might predict inflammatory responses, linking anxiety to broader health outcomes.

Summary updated

Abstract

Anxiety involves complex, incompletely understood interactions of genomic, environmental, and experience-derived factors, and is currently being measured by psychological criteria. Here, we report previously nonperceived interrelationships between expression variations and nucleotide polymorphisms of the chromosome 7q21-22 acetylcholinesterase-paraoxonase 1 (ACHE-PON1) locus with the trait- and state-anxiety measures of 461 healthy subjects from the Health, Risk Factors, Exercise Training, and Genetics Family Study. The AChE protein controls the termination of the stress-enhanced acetylcholine signaling, whereas the PON protein displays peroxidase-like activity, thus protecting blood proteins from oxidative stress damages. Serum AChE and PON enzyme activities were both found to be affected by demographic parameters, and showed inverse, reciprocal associations with anxiety measures. Moreover, the transient scores of state anxiety and the susceptibility score of trait anxiety both appeared to be linked to enzyme activities. This finding supported the notion of corresponding gene expression relationships. Parallel polymorphisms in the ACHE and PON1 genes displayed apparent associations with both trait- and state-anxiety scores. Our findings indicate that a significant source of anxiety feelings involves inherited and acquired parameters of acetylcholine regulation that can be readily quantified, which can help explaining part of the human variance for state and trait anxiety.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sklan2004acetylcholinesterase,
  author = {Ella H. Sklan and Alexander Lowenthal and Mira Korner and Ya’acov Ritov and Daniel M. Landers and Tuomo Rankinen and Claude Bouchard and Arthur S. Leon and Treva Rice and D. C. Rao and Jack H. Wilmore and James S. Skinner and Hermona Soreq},
  title = {{Acetylcholinesterase/paraoxonase genotype and expression predict anxiety scores in Health, Risk Factors, Exercise Training, and Genetics study}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.0307659101},
}
Figure