ACDC-Tracing: Towards Anonymous Citizen-Driven Contact Tracing

Kristof Roomp, Nuria OliverarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract

Digital contact tracing (DCT) solutions for COVID-19 faced significant hurdles regarding privacy, technical accuracy, and the requirement for high population adoption. This paper introduces Anonymous Citizen-Driven Contact Tracing (ACDC-Tracing), a human-centric, voucher-based system designed to bypass these limitations. By leveraging human memory and anonymous testing vouchers, ACDC-Tracing enables private, scalable intervention without the need for mass surveillance or high-end smartphone penetration.

Introduction

While digital contact tracing apps were initially viewed as a primary tool for pandemic management, their real-world efficacy was hampered by several factors. First, the "critical mass" problem requires approximately 60% adoption to be effective, a threshold rarely met due to varying smartphone penetration and digital literacy. Second, privacy concerns regarding location and proximity data led to public distrust. Third, technical limitations of GPS and Bluetooth in dense urban environments often resulted in high false-positive rates. ACDC-Tracing addresses these issues by removing the reliance on automated sensors and personal data.

Proposed Method: The ACDC-Tracing Protocol

The ACDC-Tracing system utilizes a "viral" distribution model for testing vouchers, mimicking the spread of the virus itself through social networks. The protocol consists of a four-step cycle:

  1. Diagnosis and Issuance: Upon a positive test result, an individual (the index patient) receives a set of anonymous alpha-numeric "testing vouchers." These vouchers are not linked to the patient's identity.
  2. Peer Distribution: The patient shares these vouchers with a limited number of close contacts (e.g., up to 6, based on $R_0$ estimates) whom they believe may have been exposed.
  3. Booking and Testing: Recipients use a voucher to book a test via a secure portal. The system tracks voucher usage counts but does not record the identity of the user.
  4. Confirmation and Loop Closure: The recipient receives a confirmation code for their appointment. If they test positive, they receive their own set of vouchers, continuing the tracing chain.
The four-step cycle of the ACDC-Tracing protocol.

Empirical Foundation

The feasibility of a human-driven approach is supported by data from the Covid19ImpactSurvey. Analysis indicates that over 70% of individuals who tested positive could identify their likely source of infection. This high rate of self-identification suggests that human intelligence can effectively target high-risk contacts that automated sensors might miss or misidentify due to physical barriers (e.g., thin walls).

Key Insights

  • Decentralized Privacy: The protocol achieves full anonymity. No identity, location, or proximity data is stored centrally; the only metric tracked is the aggregate usage of anonymous vouchers.
  • Immediate Utility: Unlike DCT apps, ACDC-Tracing does not require a critical mass of users to provide value. It can be deployed effectively at a local or neighborhood level.
  • Inclusivity: The system is compatible with low-tech environments, as vouchers can be distributed via SMS, email, or physical media, ensuring coverage for populations without smartphones.

Discussion and Limitations

While ACDC-Tracing offers a robust alternative to automated tracing, it relies on human reliability and memory. The integrity of the chain depends on the willingness of individuals to share vouchers. Furthermore, the system's success is contingent upon the availability of rapid, accessible testing infrastructure. Future work should explore incentive structures to encourage voucher usage among asymptomatic individuals and investigate hybrid models where automated apps generate anonymous vouchers to bridge the gap between digital detection and clinical action.

Conclusion

ACDC-Tracing presents a privacy-preserving, citizen-driven framework for contact tracing. By shifting the focus from automated surveillance to empowered human intervention, it offers a scalable and inclusive tool for pandemic management that respects individual privacy and overcomes the technical barriers of traditional digital tracing.

Summary updated

Abstract

As we enter the control phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, many efforts have been dedicated to developing smartphone-based contact tracing apps in order to automatically identify people that a person with COVID-19 might have infected. These applications while potentially useful, present significant adoption, societal, technical and privacy challenges. We propose ACDC-Tracing, a simpler, anonymous, voucher-based contact tracing solution that relies on peoples' knowledge of their own close contacts. People who test positive are given an anonymous voucher which they can share with a limited number of people whom they think they might be infected. The recipients can use this voucher to book a COVID-19 test and can receive their test results without ever revealing their identity. People receiving positive result are given vouchers to further backtrack the path of infection. This is a fully anonymous solution which does not require any sharing of location data, Bluetooth, or having an app installed on people's mobile device. Moreover, ACDC-Tracing can be tested for effectiveness at a small scale without requiring adoption by the entire population, which would enable acquiring fast evidence about its efficacy and scalability. Finally, it is compatible with and complementary to alternative approaches to contact tracing.
BibTeX
@misc{roomp2020acdc,
  author = {Kristof Roomp and Nuria Oliver},
  title = {{ACDC-Tracing: Towards Anonymous Citizen-Driven Contact Tracing}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2004.07463},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.07463},
}
Figure