Accuracy of Predictive Resting-Metabolic-Rate Equations in Chinese Mainland Adults

Jingjing Xue, Shuo Li, Yong Zhang, Ping HongInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated the accuracy of existing equations for predicting Resting Metabolic Rate (RMR) in Chinese adults and developed new, more accurate equations. The findings highlight that many common RMR prediction equations, including some developed for Asian populations, perform poorly in mainland Chinese adults, underscoring the need for regionally specific models.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately estimating Resting Metabolic Rate (RMR) is crucial for determining daily energy requirements, which is vital for clinical nutrition, weight management, and body composition strategies. However, the gold standard for RMR measurement, indirect calorimetry, is expensive, time-consuming, and not widely accessible. This necessitates the use of predictive equations. The problem is that many existing RMR prediction equations are based on Western populations and may not be accurate for diverse ethnic groups, including Chinese mainland adults. Previous research has shown discrepancies when applying these equations to different populations, leading to potential over- or underestimations of energy needs. This study aims to address this by evaluating existing equations and developing new ones specifically for Chinese mainland adults, considering their unique physiological and anthropometric characteristics.

Methods

The researchers recruited 315 healthy Chinese adults from various regions of mainland China. Participants underwent anthropometric measurements (height, weight, body composition) and RMR measurement using indirect calorimetry. They then compared the measured RMR with RMR predicted by several existing equations:

  • Internationally used equations: Harris-Benedict and Schofield.
  • Chinese-specific equations: Liu, Yang, and Singapore equations.
  • Fat-Free Mass (FFM) modeling equations: Cunningham and Wang.

The study then developed two new predictive equations for Chinese mainland adults using multiple stepwise regression analysis, based on anthropometric data. To ensure internal validity, the sample was split into a development group (75%) and a validation group (25%). Statistical analyses included paired t-tests to compare predicted and measured RMR, Pearson correlation coefficients to assess relationships, and Bland-Altman plots to evaluate agreement and identify bias. Individual-level accuracy was defined as the percentage of predictions within ±10% of the measured RMR.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 315 healthy Chinese mainland adults, aged 18-67 years, with a BMI range of 16.7–38.2 kg/m². This dataset was collected specifically for this research and was split into a development (n=236) and validation (n=79) subsample. The paper does not refer to any pre-existing public datasets for training or evaluation but rather uses the collected data to evaluate existing equations and develop new ones.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • One-size-fits-all RMR equations are problematic: The study strongly suggests that RMR prediction equations developed for one population group (e.g., Westerners, or even specific Asian subgroups) are not reliably accurate for the broader Chinese mainland adult population.
  • Chinese-specific equations aren't universally applicable: Even equations developed from Chinese populations (Liu, Yang, Singapore) showed significant underestimation in this mainland Chinese cohort, suggesting that regional variations within China and differences in study populations (e.g., inclusion/exclusion criteria, geographical origin) matter.
  • FFM-based equations also fall short: Two FFM-based equations, while theoretically sound, also underestimated RMR in this cohort, potentially due to differences in body composition, metabolic activity of organs, or lifestyle factors in the Chinese mainland population.
  • Schofield remains a decent, but not ideal, option: Among the pre-existing equations, Schofield's equation performed the best for the overall Chinese mainland adult group, but still had limitations.
  • New, tailored equations are superior: The newly developed equations in this study demonstrated significantly better accuracy and agreement with measured RMR compared to all pre-existing equations, highlighting the benefit of developing models specific to the target population.

Key Results

  • The mean measured RMR for the total sample was 1651 ± 339 kcal/day.
  • Except for the Schofield equation, all other pre-existing equations (Harris-Benedict, Liu, Yang, Singapore, Cunningham, Wang) significantly underestimated RMR in the Chinese mainland adult group (p < 0.01).
  • The Harris-Benedict equation overestimated RMR in females but underestimated it in males.
  • The Schofield equation was the most suitable among pre-existing equations, showing a 59.1% accuracy rate (within ±10% of measured RMR) at the individual level.
  • The two newly developed equations (Present 1 and Present 2) showed no significant differences between predicted and measured RMR for males and females.
  • Present 1 achieved the highest prediction accuracy at the individual level (70%), while Present 2 showed the smallest mean differences and bias at the group level.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample representativeness: While the study included participants from different regions of mainland China, the authors acknowledge that the sample may not fully represent the entire diverse Chinese mainland population. Future validation with larger, more diverse independent samples is recommended.
  • Age and BMI limits: The newly developed equations were intended to be applicable without strict age and BMI limits. However, the study's age range was 18-67 years and BMI range was 16.7–38.2 kg/m². Further testing on populations outside these ranges would be beneficial.
  • Validation: The authors explicitly state that the newly developed equations need to be validated by a larger independent sample with different physiological and anthropometric characteristics.
  • Comparison with other FFM models: While two FFM models were tested, the paper notes that FFM modeling equations are not popularly used and have not been developed in mainland China, suggesting potential for further exploration in this area.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate measurement of the resting metabolic rate (RMR) is necessary when we make energy requirements and nutrition suggestions in clinical. However, indirect calorimetry is not always available. The objectives of this study were to make a comparison between RMR measured by indirect calorimetry and RMR predicted by different kinds of equations, and to develop new predictive equations for Chinese mainland adults. In this study, 315 Chinese mainland adults from different provinces all over China were recruited. Subjects underwent half a day of testing, which consisted of anthropometric assessment and RMR measurement. Measured and predicted RMR were compared; new optimal equations for Chinese mainland adults were developed and tested by splitting the subjects into a development and validation group. The measured RMR was in the range of 831-2776 kcal/day (mean 1651 ± 339 kcal/day). Our findings indicated that, except for the Harris-Benedict and Schofield equations, three Chinese equations and two fat-free mass (FFM) modeling equations all significantly underestimated RMR compared to the measured value (all <i>p</i> < 0.01). There were no significant differences between predicted and measured RMR using the new equations for females and males. Of the pre-existing equations, Schofield's is the most suitable for Chinese mainland adults. However, the two new equations developed in this study seem to be more effective for predicting the RMR of Chinese mainland adults, and need to be validated by a larger independent sample with different physiological and anthropometric characteristics.
BibTeX
@article{xue2019accuracy,
  author = {Jingjing Xue and Shuo Li and Yong Zhang and Ping Hong},
  title = {{Accuracy of Predictive Resting-Metabolic-Rate Equations in Chinese Mainland Adults}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph16152747},
}
Figure