TL;DR
This study investigated how accurately parents in Australia report their children's height and weight for use in eHealth interventions. While parents were reasonably accurate overall, especially for weight, the calculated Body Mass Index (BMI) showed poor concordance with objective measurements. This suggests that while parent-reported data can be a useful starting point for eHealth programs, adjustments may be needed for precise BMI calculations.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Electronic health (eHealth) interventions, particularly those delivered via web-based platforms, are increasingly used for health and lifestyle programs, including those targeting childhood obesity. A common challenge in these remote interventions is the reliance on self-reported data, especially when objective measurements are not feasible. For childhood obesity interventions, parent-reported height and weight are often used to calculate Body Mass Index (BMI) and determine weight categories. However, the accuracy of these parent-reported measures, particularly in an Australian context and using online reporting methods, has not been extensively studied. Discrepancies between parent-reported and objectively measured data can lead to miscalculations of weight trajectories, incorrect weight classifications, and potentially impact eligibility for research or treatment programs. This paper aims to fill this gap by assessing the accuracy of parent-reported child height and weight, and the resulting BMI, compared to objective measurements.
Methods
This study employed a secondary analysis of data collected during a 12-week pilot randomized controlled trial focused on a web-based family lifestyle intervention for childhood obesity. Parents were asked to report their child's height and weight via an online survey before their child's measurements were objectively taken by trained research assistants at two time points: baseline and week 12.
The researchers used several statistical methods to assess agreement:
- Lin concordance correlation coefficient (CCC): This was the primary measure to assess the agreement between parent-reported and researcher-measured data for height, weight, and calculated BMI. The CCC ranges from 0 (poor agreement) to ±1 (perfect agreement), with specific ranges defined for moderate, substantial, and almost perfect agreement.
- Cohen kappa coefficient: This was used to assess interrater agreement for the child's weight category, which was derived from both parent-reported and researcher-measured data.
- Multivariable linear regression models: These were used to explore whether factors like parent age, child age, sex, weight status, or participation in the intervention influenced the accuracy of reporting.
Datasets
The study utilized data from a pilot randomized controlled trial involving families with children aged 4 to 11 years in New South Wales, Australia.
- Baseline Data: Collected from 42 families.
- Week 12 Data: Collected from 35 families (83% retention rate).
The study did not introduce new benchmarks or datasets; it analyzed existing data from a prior trial.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Parental Underreporting is Common: Across the board, parents tended to underreport their child's height and weight. This aligns with findings from previous studies in other countries.
- Weight Reporting is More Accurate Than Height: Parents were generally more accurate in reporting their child's weight (substantial agreement) than their height (moderate agreement). This might be because weight is measured more frequently at home with scales, whereas height measurement requires more specific positioning.
- BMI Calculation is Sensitive to Reporting Errors: Despite reasonable accuracy in height and weight reporting individually, the calculated BMI showed poor concordance. This highlights how small errors in height and weight can be amplified when calculating BMI, especially for children at the extremes of the weight spectrum.
- Intervention Impact on Weight Reporting: While height reporting accuracy remained moderate, parents in the intervention group showed improved accuracy in reporting their child's weight after the 12-week program. This suggests that eHealth interventions might increase parental attentiveness to their child's weight.
- Age Matters: Both parent age and child age were found to be significantly associated with reporting accuracy. Older parents tended to underreport height more, while older children's weight was also more likely to be underreported.
Key Results
- Height Agreement: Moderate agreement (pc=.94) at baseline and week 12.
- Weight Agreement: Substantial agreement (pc=.96) at baseline and week 12.
- BMI Agreement: Poor agreement (pc=.63) at baseline and moderate agreement (pc=.86) at week 12.
- Underreporting: Parents underreported height by an average of 0.9 cm at baseline and 0.2 cm at week 12. They underreported weight by 0.5 kg at baseline and 1.6 kg at week 12.
- Weight Category Accuracy: The weight category calculated from parent-reported data agreed with objectively measured data for 74% of children at baseline and 70% at week 12.
- Parental Age and Height Accuracy: A 1-year increase in parent age was associated with a 0.29 cm underreporting of child height (P=.01).
- Child Age and Weight Accuracy: A 1-year increase in child age was associated with a 1.2 kg underreporting of child weight (P=.04).
Limitations and Future Work
- Small Sample Size: The authors acknowledge that the small sample size limited their ability to develop and model calibration equations to improve the validity of parent-reported data.
- Generalizability: The study sample comprised children with a BMI above the midpoint of the healthy weight category (≥21.5 kg/m²). Therefore, the results may not be generalizable to children with lower BMIs or to other populations and ethnicities.
- Lack of Specific Instructions: Parents were not given specific instructions on how to measure height and weight (e.g., time of day, use of specific tools). Future studies should explore whether providing clear guidance improves accuracy.
- Potential for Measurement Bias: The study did not collect information on whether parents estimated or measured the data, or where measurements were taken (home, school, clinic), which could influence accuracy.
The authors suggest that future research should:
- Use larger sample sizes and repeated measures over time in eHealth contexts.
- Model calibration equations to adjust parent-reported data for improved accuracy.
- Collect information on whether parents estimated or measured the anthropometric data.
- Provide specific guidance to parents on how to measure height and weight.
Summary updated