TL;DR
This study compares the accuracy of two computer-assisted dental implant placement methods: static CAD/CAM-manufactured drilling guides and intraoral real-time dynamic navigation. While both methods offer clinically acceptable results, static guides showed slightly better accuracy in implant base and tip positioning, whereas dynamic navigation was more precise in angulation.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Placing dental implants with high precision is crucial for successful oral rehabilitation, balancing functionality and aesthetics. While 3D planning and computer-aided surgery (CAS) have become standard, accurately transferring the planned implant position from the digital model to the patient remains a challenge. This paper investigates the accuracy of two leading CAS approaches: static drilling guides (produced via CAD/CAM) and intraoral real-time dynamic navigation systems. The goal is to determine which method offers superior accuracy in implant placement, particularly in challenging anatomical situations like interdental gaps and free-end situations.
Methods
The study employed an in vitro setup using 12 partially edentulous lower jaw models. A total of 60 implants were placed, with 30 using static pilot drilling guides and 30 using a dynamic navigation system (DENACAM®).
- Static Drilling Guides: These guides were designed using CAD software and manufactured via 3D printing (PolyJet technology). They were designed to fit precisely over the teeth and guide the pilot drill.
- Dynamic Navigation System (DENACAM®): This system involves a camera mounted on the surgical handpiece that tracks an intraoral marker. It provides real-time visualization of the drill tip's position and angulation relative to the planned implant trajectory on a monitor.
- Implantation Procedure: Implants were placed by two surgeons on dental simulation units that mimic clinical limitations like mouth opening. The time taken for each procedure was recorded.
- Accuracy Assessment: Post-operative cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) was used to evaluate the accuracy of implant placement. This involved measuring deviations in spatial position (apico-coronal, mesio-distal, oro-vestibular) at both the implant base and tip, as well as angular deviation.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study used 12 anatomical plastic models for in vitro simulation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Trade-offs in Accuracy: The study highlights that neither system is universally superior. Static guides excel in precise spatial positioning of the implant base and tip, while dynamic navigation offers better control over the implant's angulation. This suggests that the choice of system might depend on the specific clinical priority (e.g., avoiding adjacent structures vs. achieving a precise angulation for prosthetic reasons).
- Marker Proximity Matters for Navigation: For the dynamic navigation system, accuracy in angulation was significantly affected by the distance of the drill from the intraoral marker. This implies that careful marker placement and consideration of the surgical field relative to the marker are crucial for optimal performance.
- Time Investment: Dynamic navigation required significantly more time per implant placement compared to static guides, which is an important factor for clinical efficiency.
- In Vitro vs. In Vivo: The authors acknowledge that in vitro studies, while controlled, cannot fully replicate the complexities of the oral environment (e.g., bleeding, saliva, patient movement). This means real-world clinical accuracy might differ.
Key Results
- Angulation: Dynamic navigation achieved a median angular inaccuracy of 3°, while static guides had 4.6°. This difference was statistically significant (p=0.0016).
- Horizontal Deviation: Static guides showed better median horizontal deviation at the implant base (0.34 mm) and tip (0.59 mm) compared to dynamic navigation (0.52 mm at base, 0.75 mm at tip).
- Vertical Deviation: Dynamic navigation showed higher vertical deviations at the implant base (0.445 mm) and tip (0.43 mm) compared to static guides (0.275 mm at base, 0.23 mm at tip).
- Time: Dynamic navigation took an average of 4.66 minutes per implant, while static guides took 3.18 minutes.
- Free-end vs. Interdental Gaps: Static guides were significantly more accurate in terms of spatial precision (base and tip) in free-end situations, while dynamic navigation was more accurate in angulation in interdental gaps.
Limitations and Future Work
- In Vitro Limitations: The study was conducted in vitro, which does not account for real-world clinical factors like patient movement, bleeding, saliva, and anatomical variations. The authors explicitly state that conclusions from in vitro data need careful review for clinical application.
- CBCT Resolution: The accuracy of the CBCT used for evaluation might have posed a limitation, potentially masking very small deviations.
- Marker Distance Impact: The study noted that for dynamic navigation, accuracy decreased with increasing distance from the marker, suggesting this as a factor to consider in future planning.
The authors emphasize the need for further clinical studies to provide an evidence-based recommendation for the use of intraoral real-time navigation systems in vivo. They suggest that future research should focus on establishing specific recommendations for clinical use scenarios, particularly considering the cost-benefit ratio and the potential advantages of navigation systems in challenging surgical areas or for less experienced clinicians.
Summary updated