Acceptance Rates of Invertible Neural Networks on Electron Spectra from Near-Critical Laser-Plasmas: A Comparison

Thomas Miethlinger, Nico Hoffmann, Thomas KlugePPAM 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper benchmarks Invertible Neural Networks (INNs) against traditional statistical methods for inferring plasma dynamics from electron spectra in near-critical laser-plasmas. INNs demonstrate a significant improvement in acceptance rates (up to 10x) and speed-up for this challenging inverse problem, paving the way for more efficient analysis of complex plasma experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the dynamics of ultra-intense laser-plasma interactions is crucial for applications in medicine, materials science, and laboratory astrophysics. However, directly observing these phenomena, especially in near- and overcritical plasmas, is extremely difficult. Experimentally accessible quantities (observables) only indirectly reveal information about the underlying plasma dynamics, and this information is often incomplete. This leads to a highly ambiguous "inverse problem": multiple plasma states can produce the same observable. To accurately infer plasma dynamics and experimental parameters, we need methods that can capture the full probability distribution of possible solutions, accounting for the information lost in the forward process.

Methods

The authors compare Invertible Neural Networks (INNs) with standard statistical methods like Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) and Hill-Climbing (HC) for solving this inverse problem.

  • Invertible Neural Networks (INNs): These networks are designed to efficiently model both forward (parameter to observable) and inverse (observable to parameter) processes. They achieve this by learning a mapping from the observable space to a latent space, allowing for the probabilistic reconstruction of the input parameters. The paper utilizes the Glow architecture, a type of INN composed of affine coupling blocks (ACBs).
  • Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC): This is a rejection-sampling scheme where parameters are sampled, passed through a forward model, and accepted if the resulting observable is close to the target. The paper explores variations using random sampling, quasi-random (Halton sequence) sampling, and an informed prior for one parameter.
  • Hill-Climbing (HC): This is a local search algorithm that incrementally improves a candidate solution. The paper uses a "first-choice" variant where the search restarts from a random location to find uncorrelated samples.
  • Forward Model: A hyperparameter-optimized Multilayer Perceptron (MLP) is used as the forward model to predict electron spectra from input parameters.
  • Data Transformation: Raw electron spectra are transformed non-linearly and then compressed using Principal Component Regression (PCR) to reduce dimensionality before being used as targets for the ML models.

Datasets

The study uses synthetic datasets generated from 5000 Particle-in-Cell (PIC) simulations performed with the Smilei code. The simulations cover a parameter space of five variables: normalized vector potential ($a_0$), laser pulse width ($\tau$), electron density ($n_0$), target thickness ($D$), and pre-plasma scale length ($l$). The generated electron spectra are binned into 200 energy bins between 0 and 40 MeV. The data is split into 80% for training and 20% for testing.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • INNs excel at capturing the full posterior: Unlike methods that might only find a single "best" solution, INNs are designed to provide the complete conditional probability distribution of parameters given an observation, which is crucial for handling the inherent ambiguity of inverse problems.
  • Quasi-random numbers are key for INNs: The performance of INNs significantly benefits from using quasi-random sequences (like Halton) for sampling parameters compared to purely random sampling, especially for achieving higher acceptance rates.
  • Trade-offs between methods and acceptance thresholds: The "best" method depends heavily on the chosen acceptance threshold ($\epsilon$). For larger thresholds, INNs generally outperform ABC and HC. However, for very small thresholds, iterative methods like HC can achieve higher acceptance rates.
  • Composite algorithms offer a promising path: Recognizing the complementary strengths of INNs and HC, the authors propose a hybrid approach that combines both to achieve both high accuracy and efficiency, particularly for challenging scenarios with small acceptance thresholds.

Key Results

  • Acceptance Rate Improvement: INNs achieve acceptance rates up to a factor of 10 higher than naive ABC (random sampling) and significantly outperform informed ABC (using a modified prior).
  • Speed-up: The increased acceptance rate of INNs directly translates to a similar speed-up in finding accepted solutions.
  • Comparison with HC: For very small acceptance thresholds ($\epsilon < 3 \cdot 10^{-3}$), Hill-Climbing methods show superior acceptance rates compared to INNs.
  • Runtime Efficiency: INNs demonstrate competitive runtimes, especially for larger acceptance thresholds, and do not introduce significant overhead compared to their acceptance rate improvements.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Cost of INNs: While INNs offer speed-ups, training them can still be computationally intensive, and their performance for very small acceptance thresholds is surpassed by iterative methods.
  • Hyperparameter Sensitivity: The performance of both INNs and other ML models is sensitive to hyperparameter choices, requiring careful optimization.
  • Proposed Composite Algorithm: The paper proposes a composite algorithm combining INNs and Hill-Climbing to leverage the strengths of both, aiming for high accuracy and efficiency across a range of acceptance thresholds. This hybrid approach is presented as a promising direction for future work.

Summary updated

Abstract

While the interaction of ultra-intense ultra-short laser pulses with near- and overcritical plasmas cannot be directly observed, experimentally accessible quantities (observables) often only indirectly give information about the underlying plasma dynamics. Furthermore, the information provided by observables is incomplete, making the inverse problem highly ambiguous. Therefore, in order to infer plasma dynamics as well as experimental parameter, the full distribution over parameters given an observation needs to considered, requiring that models are flexible and account for the information lost in the forward process. Invertible Neural Networks (INNs) have been designed to efficiently model both the forward and inverse process, providing the full conditional posterior given a specific measurement. In this work, we benchmark INNs and standard statistical methods on synthetic electron spectra. First, we provide experimental results with respect to the acceptance rate, where our results show increases in acceptance rates up to a factor of 10. Additionally, we show that this increased acceptance rate also results in an increased speed-up for INNs to the same extent. Lastly, we propose a composite algorithm that utilizes INNs and promises low runtimes while preserving high accuracy.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{miethlinger2022acceptance,
  author = {Thomas Miethlinger and Nico Hoffmann and Thomas Kluge},
  title = {{Acceptance Rates of Invertible Neural Networks on Electron Spectra from Near-Critical Laser-Plasmas: A Comparison}},
  booktitle = {PPAM},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=WS3qzAVP2me},
}
Figure