Acceptability of App-Based Contact Tracing for COVID-19: Cross-Country Survey Study

Samuel Altmann, Luke Milsom, Hannah Zillessen, Raffaele Blasone, Frederic Gerdon, Ruben Bach, Frauke Kreuter, Daniele Nosenzo, Séverine Toussaert, Johannes AbelerJMIR mHealth and uHealth 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract

Background: The COVID-19 pandemic is the greatest public health crisis of the last 100 years. Countries have responded with various levels of lockdown to save lives and stop health systems from being overwhelmed. At the same time, lockdowns entail large socioeconomic costs. One exit strategy under consideration is a mobile phone app that traces the close contacts of those infected with COVID-19. Recent research has demonstrated the theoretical effectiveness of this solution in different disease settings. However, concerns have been raised about such apps because of the potential privacy implications. This could limit the acceptability of app-based contact tracing in the general population. As the effectiveness of this approach increases strongly with app uptake, it is crucial to understand public support for this intervention. Objective: The objective of this study is to investigate the user acceptability of a contact-tracing app in five countries hit by the pandemic. Methods: We conducted a largescale, multicountry study (N=5995) to measure public support for the digital contact tracing of COVID-19 infections. We ran anonymous online surveys in France, Germany, Italy, the United Kingdom, and the United States. We measured intentions to use a contact-tracing app across different installation regimes (voluntary installation vs automatic installation by mobile phone providers) and studied how these intentions vary across individuals and countries. Results: We found strong support for the app under both regimes, in all countries, across all subgroups of the population, and irrespective of regional-level COVID-19 mortality rates. We investigated the main factors that may hinder or facilitate uptake and found that concerns about cybersecurity and privacy, together with a lack of trust in the government, are the main barriers to adoption. Conclusions: Epidemiological evidence shows that app-based contact tracing can suppress the spread of COVID-19 if a high enough proportion of the population uses the app and that it can still reduce the number of infections if uptake is moderate. Our findings show that the willingness to install the app is very high. The available evidence suggests that app-based contact tracing may be a viable approach to control the diffusion of COVID-19. JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2020;8(8):e19857 doi:10.2196/19857

Introduction

For app-based contact tracing to suppress a pandemic, epidemiological models suggest a "critical mass" of adoption is required—often cited as 60% or more of the population. While the technical hurdles of Bluetooth-based proximity sensing were being solved in early 2020, the human hurdle remained unknown: Would people actually install a government-backed tracking app? This study investigates the "acceptability gap," exploring not just if people would use the app, but why they might refuse, how they feel about automatic installation (opt-out) versus voluntary (opt-in), and whether local disease severity influences their decision.

Methods

The researchers conducted a large-scale, cross-country survey in March and April 2020 across France, Germany, Italy, the UK, and the US. A key methodological feature was the use of comprehension filtering. Unlike many surveys that accept all responses, this study required participants to pass three comprehension checks about how the app works. This filtered out nearly 40% of initial respondents, ensuring the final data came from informed participants.

Participant flow and exclusion criteria, highlighting the impact of comprehension checks.

The survey used experimental blocks to test different implementation regimes (opt-in vs. opt-out) and merged survey responses with real-time COVID-19 infection and death rates to assess the impact of living in a "hotspot."

Results

Across all five countries, roughly 70% of respondents said they would "definitely" or "probably" install the app, and over 90% stated they would comply with a self-isolation request if notified of exposure.

Sample demographics and country-level epidemiological data.

Key insights from the analysis include:

  • Trust as Infrastructure: Trust in government was the single strongest predictor of app acceptance. Likelihood of installation plummeted among those who lacked trust in their national government.
  • The Opt-Out Backfire: While automatic enrollment often increases participation in other contexts, the authors found a potential "reactance" effect here. In some regions, people were less likely to keep an automatically installed app than they were to voluntarily download one.
  • Privacy vs. Utility: While surveillance concerns were cited, the most influential factor was perceived benefit. The reason "I would not benefit" had a larger negative impact on installation probability than general privacy concerns.
  • Hotspot Effect: Living in a severely affected area (e.g., New York or Northern Italy) increased the probability of "definitely" installing the app by about 10 percentage points.

Discussion and Conclusion

While stated intent is high, the study highlights that success hinges on trust and the specific "choice architecture" used during rollout. The "comprehension dividend" suggests that public education is vital, as understanding the app is a prerequisite for support. Limitations include potential hypothetical bias and the digital divide inherent in online surveys. However, the available evidence suggests that app-based contact tracing is a viable approach to control the diffusion of COVID-19 if uptake is high enough.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: The COVID-19 pandemic is the greatest public health crisis of the last 100 years. Countries have responded with various levels of lockdown to save lives and stop health systems from being overwhelmed. At the same time, lockdowns entail large socioeconomic costs. One exit strategy under consideration is a mobile phone app that traces the close contacts of those infected with COVID-19. Recent research has demonstrated the theoretical effectiveness of this solution in different disease settings. However, concerns have been raised about such apps because of the potential privacy implications. This could limit the acceptability of app-based contact tracing in the general population. As the effectiveness of this approach increases strongly with app uptake, it is crucial to understand public support for this intervention.Objective: The objective of this study is to investigate the user acceptability of a contact-tracing app in five countries hit by the pandemic.Methods: We conducted a largescale, multicountry study (N=5995) to measure public support for the digital contact tracing of COVID-19 infections. We ran anonymous online surveys in France, Germany, Italy, the United Kingdom, and the United States. We measured intentions to use a contact-tracing app across different installation regimes (voluntary installation vs automatic installation by mobile phone providers) and studied how these intentions vary across individuals and countries.Results: We found strong support for the app under both regimes, in all countries, across all subgroups of the population, and irrespective of regional-level COVID-19 mortality rates. We investigated the main factors that may hinder or facilitate uptake and found that concerns about cybersecurity and privacy, together with a lack of trust in the government, are the main barriers to adoption.Conclusions: Epidemiological evidence shows that app-based contact tracing can suppress the spread of COVID-19 if a high enough proportion of the population uses the app and that it can still reduce the number of infections if uptake is moderate. Our findings show that the willingness to install the app is very high. The available evidence suggests that app-based contact tracing may be a viable approach to control the diffusion of COVID-19.JMIR Mhealth Uhealth 2020;8(8):e19857doi:10.2196/19857
BibTeX
@inproceedings{altmann2020acceptability,
  author = {Samuel Altmann and Luke Milsom and Hannah Zillessen and Raffaele Blasone and Frederic Gerdon and Ruben Bach and Frauke Kreuter and Daniele Nosenzo and Séverine Toussaert and Johannes Abeler},
  title = {{Acceptability of App-Based Contact Tracing for COVID-19: Cross-Country Survey Study}},
  booktitle = {JMIR mHealth and uHealth},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=v9ClN8PNpO},
}
Figure