Accelerated and Inexact Forward-Backward Algorithms

Silvia Villa, Saverio Salzo, Luca Baldassarre, Alessandro VerriSIAM J. Optim 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces and analyzes accelerated forward-backward splitting algorithms that can handle inexact computations of the proximity operator. The key contribution is proving that a $1/k^2$ convergence rate can still be achieved even when the proximity operator is computed with a controlled level of error, which is crucial for practical applications where exact computation is often infeasible.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many optimization problems in signal processing, machine learning, and image recovery can be formulated as minimizing the sum of a convex differentiable function and a convex non-differentiable function. Forward-backward splitting (FBS) methods are popular for these problems, especially when accelerated. However, a critical bottleneck arises when the "proximity operator" (a core component of FBS) cannot be computed exactly. This is common in real-world scenarios, leading to algorithms with nested loops (one for the main optimization, one for the proximity operator). While inexactness has been studied for basic proximal point algorithms, its impact on accelerated FBS methods, particularly regarding convergence rates, remained an open question. This paper addresses this gap by providing a theoretical framework and analysis for accelerated FBS with inexact proximity operator computations.

Methods

The paper's core technical contribution lies in its use of Nesterov's estimate sequences to analyze the convergence of accelerated forward-backward algorithms under inexact proximity operator computations.

  • Estimate Sequences: This is a powerful machinery developed by Nesterov for analyzing accelerated methods. The authors adapt this framework to handle the errors introduced by inexact proximity operator calculations.
  • Inexact Proximal Point Definition: They introduce a specific notion of "$\epsilon$-precision" for approximating the proximity operator, based on the concept of $\epsilon$-subdifferentials. This definition is crucial for their theoretical analysis and is shown to be applicable to various scenarios.
  • Algorithm Formulation (aiFOBOS): They propose a general accelerated and inexact forward-backward splitting algorithm (aiFOBOS) that incorporates these inexact computations.
  • Convergence Analysis: The main theoretical result establishes that if the errors in the proximity operator computation decay sufficiently fast (specifically, $\epsilon_k = O(1/k^q)$ with $q > 3/2$), the algorithm achieves the optimal $1/k^2$ convergence rate for the objective function values.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and uses synthetic examples for numerical experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Controlled Inexactness is Key: The most significant insight is that controlled inexactness in the proximity operator computation doesn't necessarily destroy the fast convergence rates of accelerated methods. The type and decay rate of the errors are critical.
  • Bridging Theory and Practice: The paper provides a theoretical justification for using inexact proximity operators in accelerated FBS, which is essential for practical implementations where exact computations are often intractable or computationally prohibitive.
  • Flexibility of Estimate Sequences: The authors demonstrate the power and flexibility of Nesterov's estimate sequences by adapting them to analyze inexact algorithms, showing their broad applicability beyond exact settings.
  • Practical Implications for Signal Recovery: The analysis is directly relevant to problems like image denoising and deblurring, where total variation regularization (a common non-differentiable term) leads to proximity operators that are often computed inexactly.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Convergence Rate: The paper proves that the proposed accelerated and inexact forward-backward splitting algorithm (aiFOBOS) achieves a $1/k^2$ convergence rate for the objective function values, provided the approximation errors $\epsilon_k$ in the proximity operator computation satisfy $\epsilon_k = O(1/k^q)$ with $q > 3/2$.
  • Error Tolerance: For merely achieving convergence (not necessarily the optimal rate), a weaker condition on errors ($\epsilon_k = O(1/k^q)$ with $q > 1/2$) is sufficient.
  • Empirical Validation: Numerical experiments on problems like Fused Lasso and Total Variation deblurring demonstrate that the empirical convergence rates are generally better than the theoretical lower bounds. They also show that accuracy rates below $q=1/2$ can lead to slower convergence or non-convergence, aligning with the theory.
  • Backtracking Procedure: A backtracking stepsize rule is proposed to handle situations where the Lipschitz constant of the gradient is unknown, making the algorithm more practical.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Admissible Approximations: The primary theoretical result relies on a specific notion of "admissible" approximations of the proximity operator. The paper acknowledges that other types of approximations (e.g., those that fall outside the domain of the function $g$) might not satisfy the theoretical guarantees, although empirical results suggest convergence can still occur.
  • Computational Complexity: While the paper focuses on convergence rates in terms of iterations, the actual computational cost per iteration depends on the method used to compute the inexact proximity operator. This aspect is not deeply explored.
  • Comparison with Other Inexact Methods: The paper mentions that other notions of inexactness exist and have been studied. A more comprehensive comparison of their proposed method with these alternatives could be valuable.
  • Generalization to Non-convex Problems: The current analysis is for convex optimization problems. Extending these results to non-convex settings would be a significant future direction.
  • More Sophisticated Error Analysis: The paper suggests that further work is needed to understand the convergence behavior with non-admissible approximations and to explore the impact of different inexactness criteria.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{villa2013accelerated,
  author = {Silvia Villa and Saverio Salzo and Luca Baldassarre and Alessandro Verri},
  title = {{Accelerated and Inexact Forward-Backward Algorithms}},
  journal = {SIAM J. Optim.},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1137/110844805},
}
Figure