Academic landscape of hydropower: citation-analysis-based method and its application

Hajime Sasaki, Zhidong Liu, Ichiro SakataInternational Journal of Energy Technology and Policy 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper maps the academic landscape of hydropower research using citation network analysis to identify key research clusters and emerging trends. It reveals six main research areas and highlights the growing importance of small hydropower, the Mekong Basin, and pumped-storage systems, offering valuable insights for policymakers and researchers alike.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Hydropower is a critical renewable energy source with significant growth potential, yet the vast and rapidly expanding body of academic literature makes it challenging for researchers and policymakers to grasp the field's overall structure and identify emerging trends. This lack of a clear academic map hinders informed decision-making and strategic investment in hydropower research and development. The paper aims to address this by providing a comprehensive overview of the hydropower research landscape.

Methods

The study employs a citation network analysis approach. First, they collected 7,521 academic papers related to hydropower from the Web of Science using a specific search query. This raw data was then used to construct a non-weighted, non-directed citation network where each paper is a node and citations are links. To manage the complexity, they focused on the largest connected component of this network. A topological clustering method (specifically, Newman's algorithm) was used to divide the network into distinct clusters, each representing a thematic area of research. Finally, they visualized the network using a force-directed layout algorithm and extracted topic keywords from the most cited papers within each cluster to characterize them. Time series analysis of publication dates within clusters and sub-clusters was also used to identify trends.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is a collection of 7,521 academic papers related to hydropower, sourced from the Web of Science (specifically, the Science Citation Index (SCI) and Social Science Citation Index (SSCI)) up to September 29, 2013. No new datasets were created; the study relies on existing published literature.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydropower research is a mature but dynamic field: While hydropower has a long history, the sharp increase in publications since the 1990s, coinciding with the rise of sustainable development discourse, indicates a renewed and growing academic interest.
  • Six core research clusters emerge: The analysis reveals six principal thematic areas: renewable energy, optimization of system operation, environmental impact, fish management, water governance, and hybrid solutions.
  • Emerging trends are clearly identifiable: The study pinpoints "small hydropower," "Mekong Basin hydropower," and "pumped-storage" as rapidly developing and increasingly important sub-fields, evidenced by recent publication trends.
  • Industry and academia are closely linked: A comparison of hydroelectricity generation data with academic publication trends shows a strong correlation, suggesting that practical development and research are closely intertwined.
  • The importance of context-specific research: The analysis highlights the significance of regional studies, such as "hydropower in Turkey" and "Mekong Basin hydropower," indicating that localized challenges and opportunities drive specific research directions.

Key Results

The study identified 50 distinct clusters within the hydropower research landscape, with the top six clusters accounting for approximately 80% of the total papers. These top six clusters are:

  1. Renewable energy (656 papers): This is the largest cluster, with sub-clusters focusing on small hydropower, hydropower in Turkey, and the impact of climate change.
  2. Optimization of system operation (580 papers): This cluster deals with methods and algorithms for improving the efficiency and scheduling of hydropower generation.
  3. Environmental impact (564 papers): This cluster addresses issues like greenhouse gas emissions, impacts on aquatic fauna, and mercury in reservoirs.
  4. Fish management (376 papers): Research here focuses on topics such as fish passage survival and the migration of eels and salmon.
  5. Water governance (252 papers): This cluster includes research on the Mekong Basin hydropower and river regulations.
  6. Hybrid solution (171 papers): This cluster explores the integration of hydropower with other renewable sources like wind and solar, particularly through pumped-storage systems.

The analysis also revealed that sub-clusters like "hydropower in Turkey" (#1-2), "fish passage survival" (#4-1), and "migration of salmon" (#4-3) are "highly concentrated," indicating a dominant contribution from a few countries (primarily the USA). Conversely, sub-clusters like "small hydropower" (#1-1) and "scheduling" (#2-2) are "unconcentrated," suggesting a more competitive research environment.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Query limitations: The search query might have excluded some relevant papers or included unrelated ones, potentially affecting the completeness of the analysis.
  • Focus on cited papers: The naming of clusters was based on the top 20 most cited papers, potentially overlooking emerging technologies or novel ideas from less-cited works.
  • Time lag: There's an inherent time lag between research completion, publication, and recognition, meaning the "current status" might not be entirely up-to-date.
  • Bibliographic analysis limitations: While useful for understanding research trends, bibliographic analysis may not fully capture the commercialization potential or practical application of emerging technologies.

Future work could involve refining search queries, exploring less-cited papers for novel insights, and incorporating more recent data to account for the time lag. The authors also emphasize the need for policymakers, especially in developing countries, to actively seek and utilize the latest academic knowledge to inform their decisions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hydropower has superior storage capacity and speedy response to meet sudden fluctuations in electricity demand. According to a recent estimate by International Energy Agency (IEA), its generation capacity could double by 2050. Nevertheless, no great picture of academic knowledge exists in relation to hydropower. This study was undertaken to reveal the academic landscape in this field by analysing the citation network of papers published in academic journals. We collected 7,521 target papers from the Web of Science using a specific search query. Using a topological-based method, all the papers were categorised into clusters according to their own characteristic topics. Results show the existence of six principal research clusters: renewable energy, optimisation of system operation, environmental impact, fish management, water governance and hybrid solutions. Combining the analysis results, clusters were found related to 'small hydropower', 'Mekong Basin hydropower' and 'pumped-storage' are developing, as indicated by the recent increasing trend. Even in developing countries, policymakers should make policy with full access to that knowledge. Governments must prepare environments in which policymakers can access the latest knowledge and information related to their own countries.
BibTeX
@article{sasaki2016academic,
  author = {Hajime Sasaki and Zhidong Liu and Ichiro Sakata},
  title = {{Academic landscape of hydropower: citation-analysis-based method and its application}},
  journal = {International Journal of Energy Technology and Policy},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1504/ijetp.2016.074493},
}
Figure