Abundant Polymorphism in a System with Multiple Hydrogen-Bonding Opportunities: Oxalyl Dihydrazide

Shinbyoung Ahn, Fang Guo, Benson M. Kariuki, Kenneth D. HarrisJournal of the American Chemical Society 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that oxalyl dihydrazide (ODH), previously thought to have only one crystal form, actually exhibits at least five distinct polymorphs. This discovery highlights how subtle variations in molecular conformation, specifically the orientation of NH₂ groups, can lead to a rich landscape of hydrogen-bonding arrangements and diverse crystal structures for a seemingly simple molecule.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The phenomenon of polymorphism, where a compound can crystallize into multiple distinct solid-state structures, is of significant interest in fields ranging from pharmaceuticals to materials science. Understanding and controlling polymorphism is crucial because different crystal forms can have vastly different physical properties (solubility, melting point, stability, etc.). While computational methods are advancing, predicting the full polymorphic potential of a molecule remains a major challenge, and experimentally discovering a large number of polymorphs for a single compound is relatively rare. The problem this paper addresses is the limited understanding of the polymorphic behavior of oxalyl dihydrazide (ODH), a molecule with multiple hydrogen-bonding sites. Previously, only one crystal structure was known, leaving open the question of whether ODH could exhibit more complex polymorphic behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed a systematic approach to explore the polymorphic landscape of ODH. The core techniques involved:

  • Crystallization Experiments: A wide array of crystallization conditions were tested, varying solvents (e.g., water, DMSO, dioxane, methanol, DMF), co-solutes (e.g., cyanuric acid, trithiocyanuric acid, urea), and temperatures. This is a standard but exhaustive method for discovering new polymorphs.
  • Powder X-ray Diffraction (PXRD): Used as a primary screening tool to identify different crystalline phases obtained from the various crystallization experiments. This technique provides a unique fingerprint for each crystal structure.
  • Single-Crystal X-ray Diffraction (SCXRD): Once new crystalline phases were identified by PXRD, SCXRD was used to determine the precise three-dimensional atomic arrangement of each polymorph. This is the gold standard for crystal structure determination.
  • Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC): Employed to investigate the thermal behavior of the polymorphs, including melting points and solid-state transformations at elevated temperatures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on experimental synthesis and characterization of new polymorphs of oxalyl dihydrazide.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hidden Polymorphic Diversity: The most striking insight is the discovery of four new polymorphs (β, γ, δ, and ε) of ODH, bringing the total to at least five. This dramatically expands our understanding of ODH's solid-state behavior beyond the previously known single form (α).
  • Conformational Flexibility Drives Polymorphism: The paper strongly suggests that the molecule's ability to adopt different orientations of its NH₂ groups (via rotation around the NH-NH₂ bond) is the key driver for its extensive polymorphism. Even though the core N-N-C-C-N-N backbone remains in a trans-trans-trans conformation, these subtle NH₂ rotations create distinct hydrogen-bonding opportunities.
  • Hydrogen-Bonding Networks Dictate Structure: The different orientations of the NH₂ hydrogen atoms lead to a variety of hydrogen-bonding arrangements (e.g., sheets, ribbons, grids) and connectivity patterns, explaining the formation of distinct crystal structures.
  • "Elusive" Polymorphs: The β polymorph is highlighted as an "elusive" form, initially obtained but difficult to reproduce, underscoring the sensitivity of crystallization processes and the challenges in fully characterizing all polymorphic forms.
  • Thermal Behavior and Transformations: The study reveals that some polymorphs undergo solid-state transformations to other ODH polymorphs (specifically to the γ form) upon heating, rather than directly melting. This adds another layer of complexity to their stability and interconversion.

Key Results

  • Five Polymorphs Identified: The paper reports the structural characterization of five polymorphs of oxalyl dihydrazide (ODH): α, β, γ, δ, and ε.
  • Structural Similarities and Differences: All polymorphs share the same trans-trans-trans conformation of the molecular backbone. The primary differences lie in the orientation of the NH₂ hydrogen atoms, leading to variations in torsion angles (detailed in Table 3).
  • Diverse Hydrogen-Bonding Architectures: The polymorphs exhibit distinct hydrogen-bonding arrangements, including two-dimensional sheets (α), one-dimensional ribbons (β, γ, δ, ε), and even a "grid-like" pattern (ε).
  • Thermal Transformations: DSC data indicate that upon heating, the α, δ, and ε polymorphs transform into the γ polymorph before undergoing a solid-state reaction at higher temperatures. The γ polymorph itself does not show any thermal events before this reaction.
  • Density Differences: The α polymorph exhibits the highest calculated density among the characterized forms, suggesting it might be the thermodynamically most stable form at low temperatures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Incomplete Polymorph Discovery: The authors acknowledge that it would not be surprising if even more polymorphs of ODH are discovered in the future, as their search was primarily limited to conventional solution crystallization.
  • Reproducibility Challenges: The β polymorph was found to be particularly difficult to reproduce, highlighting the inherent challenges in controlling crystallization processes.
  • "Elusive" Polymorphs: The difficulty in obtaining and characterizing certain polymorphs (like β) remains a limitation.
  • Solid-State Reaction Mechanism: While the paper notes a solid-state reaction occurring at higher temperatures (forming DOHH and hydrazine), detailed kinetic and mechanistic investigations of this reaction are ongoing and will be reported in future work.
  • Conformational Polymorphism: The paper speculates about the possibility of conformational polymorphs (e.g., with cis conformations of the C-N bond), which were not observed in this study but were suggested by earlier spectroscopic evidence. Further investigation into these forms is implied.
  • Exploring Other Crystallization Strategies: The authors mention that a wide range of other strategies beyond conventional solution crystallization could be explored to generate further polymorphic forms.

Summary updated

Abstract

To date, only one crystal structure has been reported in the literature for oxalyl dihydrazide [H(2)N.NH.CO.CO.NH.NH(2)]. In the present paper, we report the discovery of four new polymorphs of oxalyl dihydrazide, obtained by crystallization from solution under different conditions, including the use of different crystallization solvents. All polymorphs have the trans-trans-trans conformation of the N-N-C-C-N-N backbone, but the positions of the hydrogen atoms of the NH(2) groups relative to this backbone differ between the different polymorphs through variation of the torsion angle around each NH-NH(2) bond. The different polymorphs display a range of different hydrogen-bonding arrangements, constructed from different types of hydrogen-bonded array. The existence of several different potential hydrogen-bond donor and hydrogen-bond acceptor groups in the oxalyl dihydrazide molecule, together with the fact that the N-H bonds of the NH(2) groups adopt different orientations with respect to the molecular plane, leads to several possible geometric permutations for hydrogen-bonding arrangements in the solid state. It would not be surprising if even more polymorphs of oxalyl dihydrazide are discovered in the future.
BibTeX
@article{ahn2006abundant,
  author = {Shinbyoung Ahn and Fang Guo and Benson M. Kariuki and Kenneth D. Harris},
  title = {{Abundant Polymorphism in a System with Multiple Hydrogen-Bonding Opportunities: Oxalyl Dihydrazide}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1021/ja0573155},
}
Figure