Abstract Meaning Representation for Multi-Document Summarization

Kexin Liao, Logan Lebanoff, Fei LiuCOLING 2018

TL;DR

This paper explores using Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) as a novel way to represent content for multi-document summarization. By converting source documents into AMR graphs, merging them, and then generating summary sentences, the authors demonstrate a promising, data-driven approach that outperforms existing abstractive methods on benchmark datasets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Generating concise and accurate summaries from multiple documents (multi-document summarization) is a challenging but valuable task. While extractive methods (selecting existing sentences) are common, abstractive methods (generating new sentences) offer more flexibility and can produce more human-like summaries. However, abstractive approaches, especially for multiple documents, have been less explored due to the difficulty in representing and manipulating the core meaning across various sources. Traditional methods often rely on heuristic representations like parse trees or phrase lists, which can be hard to work with systematically. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating AMR, a linguistically grounded semantic representation, as a principled way to capture and condense meaning from multiple documents for abstractive summarization.

Methods

The proposed framework consists of three main components:

  1. Source Sentence Selection: This component identifies sets of similar sentences from the source documents that cover different aspects of the topic. They use spectral clustering to group sentences and then select the most representative ones from each cluster.
  2. Content Planning: This is the core innovation. Source sentences are first parsed into Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) graphs. These individual graphs are then merged into a single "source graph." A structured prediction framework, using integer linear programming and a structured ramp loss, is employed to extract a "summary graph" from this source graph, representing the salient content. This process is designed to be data-driven and domain-independent.
  3. Surface Realization: The extracted summary graph is converted into the PENMAN format, a standard representation for AMR. An existing AMR-to-text generator (JAMR) is then used to convert this PENMAN representation into a natural language summary sentence.

The framework is designed to allow individual components to be optimized independently, reducing the need for large, end-to-end training datasets.

Datasets

The experiments were conducted on standard multi-document summarization datasets from DUC (Document Understanding Conferences) and TAC (Text Analysis Conferences), specifically DUC-03, DUC-04, TAC-09, TAC-10, and TAC-11. These datasets typically consist of clusters of news articles and multiple human-written reference summaries. The authors also mention using human reference summaries to create training instances for the content planning component by parsing them into AMR graphs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • AMR as a Unified Semantic Representation: The paper strongly advocates for AMR as a powerful, language-neutral semantic representation that can effectively capture and condense meaning from multiple sources, overcoming the limitations of syntactic or phrase-based representations.
  • Structured Prediction for Content Selection: Using structured prediction (specifically, integer linear programming) to extract a summary graph from a larger source graph is a key technical contribution. This allows for a principled way to identify and select the most important semantic units.
  • Component-wise Optimization: The modular design, allowing independent optimization of sentence selection, content planning, and surface realization, is a significant practical advantage, reducing data requirements.
  • Abstractiveness vs. Extractive Tendencies: The results highlight a trade-off. While their AMR-based approach achieves higher abstractiveness (fewer n-grams from source documents) compared to pointer-generator networks, it also shows competitive or superior performance in terms of ROUGE scores, suggesting a good balance.

Key Results

  • The proposed AMR summarization framework ("AMRSumm-VSM" and "AMRSumm-Clst") outperforms other abstractive systems on benchmark datasets (DUC-04 and TAC-11) in terms of ROUGE-1 and ROUGE-SU4 F-scores.
  • "AMRSumm-VSM" also achieved the highest ROUGE-2 F-scores among abstractive methods.
  • The "Concept Coverage" strategy for source sentence selection showed strong performance in preserving salient summary concepts (40.3% of goldstandard concepts).
  • Oracle decoding (an upper bound) significantly boosted performance, indicating the potential for further improvements in the decoding process.
  • The AMR-based summaries were found to be more abstractive than those produced by pointer-generator networks, with fewer n-grams directly copied from the source documents.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parser Performance: The quality of the AMR parser used (JAMR or CAMR) significantly impacts summarization performance. There's a noticeable gap between current parser performance and the best achievable, suggesting that improvements in AMR parsing would directly benefit summarization.
  • Simplified AMR Representation: The authors suggest that a simplified AMR representation might be beneficial for summarization. Collapsing complex "semantic content units" into "mega-nodes" could potentially improve robustness and efficiency.
  • Future AMR Parsers: They propose that future AMR parsers could consider working on reduced AMR graphs, tailored for summarization tasks.
  • Balancing Abstractiveness and Copying: The paper notes the need for future abstractive systems to carefully balance copying words from the source with generating novel words/phrases to produce human-like abstracts.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liao2018abstract,
  author = {Kexin Liao and Logan Lebanoff and Fei Liu},
  title = {{Abstract Meaning Representation for Multi-Document Summarization}},
  booktitle = {International Conference on Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure