Abstinent Heroin Addicts Tend to Take Risks: ERP and Source Localization

Qinglin Zhao, Hongqian Li, Bin Hu, Haiyan Wu, Quanying LiuFrontiers in Neuroscience 2017 · DOI

Abstract

Abnormal decision-making is a hallmark of drug addiction, often characterized by a preference for immediate rewards at the expense of long-term interests. This study investigates the neurocognitive basis of these deficits in abstinent heroin addicts (AHAs) using event-related potential (ERP) analysis and source localization. Twenty AHAs and twenty healthy controls (HCs) performed a two-choice gambling task. Results revealed that AHAs exhibit a significant risk-prone bias and disrupted neural activity during both reward anticipation and outcome evaluation. Specifically, the right-hemisphere dominance of stimulus-preceding negativity (SPN) was lost in AHAs, and source localization identified abnormalities in the insula and anterior cingulate cortex (ACC). These findings suggest that even during abstinence, heroin addicts struggle with adaptive decision-making due to impaired reward processing systems.

The Challenge of Decision-Making in Addiction

Drug addiction is frequently described as a chronic relapsing disorder where an "impulsive" neural system overrides a "reflective" one. This imbalance leads to a "myopia for the future," where individuals prioritize immediate gratification over long-term stability. While this behavior is well-documented in active users, the specific neurocognitive mechanisms that persist during abstinence remain less clear. Understanding whether these deficits stem from flawed reward anticipation or impaired outcome evaluation is crucial for developing targeted withdrawal and relapse-prevention treatments.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers compared 20 AHAs (average abstinence: 9 months) with 20 age-, education-, and gender-matched healthy controls. Participants engaged in a simple two-choice gambling task where they chose between a low-risk/low-reward option ("9") and a high-risk/high-reward option ("99").

The experimental paradigm: participants chose between '9' and '99', followed by an anticipation period and the final outcome.

To analyze the underlying brain activity, the study employed:

  • Event-Related Potentials (ERPs): Measuring components like SPN (anticipation), FRN (early outcome evaluation), and P300 (late-stage processing of magnitude and valence).
  • eLORETA (Source Localization): A technique used to estimate the specific brain structures, such as the insula and ACC, responsible for the electrical signals recorded at the scalp.

Key Insights: A Broken Neural Compass

Behavioral Risk-Seeking

The behavioral data confirmed a strong bias: AHAs chose the high-risk "99" option significantly more often than controls (71.25% vs. 56.01%). More importantly, AHAs failed to shift to a safer strategy even after repeated losses, indicating a fundamental deficit in adaptive decision-making—the brain isn't learning from its mistakes.

Disrupted Anticipation

In healthy individuals, the right hemisphere—particularly the right insula—typically dominates during the anticipation of a reward. This "gut feeling" helps weigh potential risks. In AHAs, this right-hemisphere preponderance was completely disrupted, suggesting that the interoceptive awareness needed to weigh risks is fundamentally altered.

Source localization of the SPN component reveals reduced activity in the right insula and ACC during the anticipation phase for AHAs.

Evaluation and the "Oops" Signal

During the outcome phase, AHAs showed a higher amplitude in Feedback-Related Negativity (FRN), the brain's early error-detection signal. However, source localization revealed decreased activity in the Anterior Cingulate Cortex (ACC). This suggests that while the addict's brain detects a negative outcome, the reflective system responsible for adjusting behavior is too weak to implement a change in strategy.

Conclusion and Clinical Implications

The study demonstrates that abstinent heroin addicts possess a persistent "myopia for the future" driven by a dysfunctional neural anticipation system in the right insula and a weakened reflective process in the ACC. These individuals are effectively "blind" to the threat of loss, continuing to seek high-risk rewards despite negative consequences. These findings highlight the need for therapeutic interventions that specifically target these neural circuits to improve decision-making and reduce the risk of relapse.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abnormal decision making is a behavioral characteristic of drug addiction. Indeed, drug addicts prefer immediate rewards at the expense of future interests. Assessing the neurocognitive basis of decision-making related to drug dependence, combining event-related potential (ERP) analysis and source localization techniques, may provide new insights into understanding decision-making deficits in drug addicts and further guide withdrawal treatment. In this study, EEG was performed in 20 abstinent heroin addicts (AHAs) and 20 age-, education- and gender-matched healthy controls (HCs) while they participated in a simple two-choice gambling task (99 vs. 9). Our behavioral results showed that AHAs tend to select higher-risk choices compared with HCs (i.e., more "99" choices than "9"). ERP results showed that right hemisphere preponderance of stimulus-preceding negativity was disrupted in AHAs, but not in HCs. Feedback-related negativity of difference wave was higher in AHAs than HCs, with the P300 amplitude associated with risk magnitude and valence. Using source localization that allows identification of abnormal brain activity in consequential cognitive stages, including the reward expectation and outcome evaluation stages, we found abnormalities in both behavioral and neural responses on gambling in AHAs. Taken together, our findings suggest AHAs have risk-prone tendency and dysfunction in adaptive decision making, since they continue to choose risky options even after accruing considerable negative scores, and fail to shift to a safer strategy to avoid risk. Such abnormal decision-making bias to risk and immediate reward seeking may be accompanied by abnormal reward expectation and evaluation in AHAs, which explains their high risk-seeking and impulsivity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2017abstinent,
  author = {Qinglin Zhao and Hongqian Li and Bin Hu and Haiyan Wu and Quanying Liu},
  title = {{Abstinent Heroin Addicts Tend to Take Risks: ERP and Source Localization}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neuroscience},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3389/fnins.2017.00681},
}
Figure