Abstract Electronic assessments and corrections (EAC) of academic work offer a sustainable alternative to traditional typed-and-printed paper submissions (TPPS). This study evaluates the economic and environmental benefits of adopting EAC and its impact on student well-being. Data collected from 188 final-year students at a Nigerian university revealed a low average happiness index (3.58), significantly influenced by the financial and psychological strain of paper-based project corrections. Transitioning to electronic methods could reduce assessment costs by over 90% and save approximately 20 pulp trees per session for a single cohort, highlighting a clear path toward both student welfare and forest conservation.
Introduction
In many Nigerian tertiary institutions, the "typed-and-printed paper submission" (TPPS) remains the standard for assignments, seminars, and final-year projects. This practice imposes a significant financial burden on students, contributes to environmental degradation through massive paper consumption, and negatively impacts student well-being due to the repetitive nature of printing and re-printing drafts for correction. This paper explores the intersection of assessment methods, forest conservation, and student happiness.
Methods
The study was conducted at the Faculty of Agriculture, University of Port Harcourt, Nigeria, involving 188 final-year (500L) students across six departments. Data was gathered via a structured Google Form questionnaire. Student happiness was quantified using the Cantril Ladder scale (a 10-point self-anchoring scale), while economic and environmental impacts were modeled based on paper consumption (80g A4 reams) and established pulp-to-tree conversion factors.
Results and Discussion
Current Assessment Landscape
The prevalence of paper-based assessments varies by task and department. While some progress has been made in electronic presentations, traditional paper remains dominant for term papers, reports, and critical project corrections.
The Happiness Index
The faculty-wide average happiness index was recorded at 3.58, categorized as "low happiness." However, departmental variations were significant. Students in Forestry and Wildlife Management (FWM) reported the highest happiness (4.79), likely due to their department's early adoption of electronic pre- and post-field project presentations.
Regression analysis identified "Project Corrections" as a primary "happiness killer" (p = 0.009). The iterative process of printing 50+ page documents for multiple rounds of manual correction creates substantial psychological and financial stress. Interestingly, demographic factors such as age, gender, and stipend levels were not significant predictors of happiness, suggesting that the process of assessment is a more critical factor for student well-being.
Economic and Environmental Impact
The financial disparity between assessment methods is stark. The estimated cost for TPPS was ₦6,761,354 ($4,829.52) per session, compared to only ₦370,970.8 ($264.97) for electronic submissions—an 18-fold reduction. Environmentally, the 188 students consumed approximately 326.55 reams of paper (163,000 sheets), equivalent to 741.28 kg of dried pulp or 20.4 pulp trees. Scaled to an entire university population, the environmental footprint of paper-based assessment is staggering.
Conclusion
The study demonstrates that phasing out typed-and-printed paper submissions in favor of absolute electronic assessments is a dual-purpose strategy. It significantly enhances student happiness by removing financial and psychological stressors while contributing to vital forest conservation and economic efficiency. Educational institutions should prioritize the implementation of EAC policies to align with global sustainability goals and improve the student experience.
Summary updated