Abrupt Decline in Primary Productivity Coincident with the End-Ordovician Mass Extinction: Cadmium Isotopic Evidence from South Chin

He Zhao, Thomas J. Algeo, Zhong‐Qiang Chen, Simon W. Poulton, Yongsheng Liu, Zhaochu Hu, Xiangdong Wang, Lei ZhangGoldschmidt 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Although the end-Ordovician mass extinction caused the disappearance of >80% of contemporaneous marine species, many aspects of this biocrisis remain poorly understood. This study utilizes cadmium isotope signatures to reveal a massive collapse in marine primary productivity, providing direct evidence that the "biological pump"—the process by which marine life moves carbon and nutrients through the ocean—effectively crashed alongside the disappearance of marine species.

Introduction

The end-Ordovician mass extinction, occurring approximately 444 million years ago, stands as one of the "Big Five" extinction events in Earth's history. While the fossil record provides a clear account of taxonomic loss, the functional health of the marine ecosystem during this crisis has remained a subject of debate. Specifically, the status of primary productivity—the rate at which photosynthetic organisms like phytoplankton produce organic compounds—has been difficult to quantify. Understanding whether the extinction was accompanied by a collapse of the food web's foundation is crucial for modeling how biosphere-wide crises unfold.

Methodology

To reconstruct ancient biological activity, researchers utilized cadmium (Cd) isotopes ($\delta^{114/110}\text{Cd}$) as a proxy for nutrient utilization.

The Logic of the Cd Proxy

Marine phytoplankton preferentially take up lighter isotopes of cadmium ($^{110}\text{Cd}$) during photosynthesis. When primary productivity is high, the surface seawater becomes enriched in the heavier isotope ($^{114}\text{Cd}$), which is then recorded in the carbonate rocks forming at that time. Conversely, a drop in $\delta^{114/110}\text{Cd}$ values indicates reduced biological uptake.

Study Site and Validation

The researchers analyzed carbonate samples from the Wangjiawan section in South China. This site is a Global Boundary Stratotype Section and Point (GSSP), representing the "gold standard" geological record for the Ordovician-Silurian boundary. To ensure the reliability of the Cd signal, the findings were cross-referenced with other nutrient proxies, specifically Zinc (Zn) and Phosphorus (P) enrichments.

Key Results

The isotopic record from the Wangjiawan GSSP reveals a dramatic trajectory of marine productivity across the extinction interval:

  1. Katian Stage: $\delta^{114/110}\text{Cd}$ values decreased from $+1.13\text{‰}$ to $+0.25\text{‰}$.
  2. Early Hirnantian: A brief spike to $+0.59\text{‰}$ occurred, suggesting a temporary surge in productivity at the onset of the Hirnantian glacial period.
  3. Late Hirnantian (The Extinction): Values plummeted to a minimum of $-0.17\text{‰}$. This negative value indicates a massive reduction in nutrient uptake, signaling a stalled biological pump coincident with the peak of the extinction.
  4. Early Silurian: A recovery to $+0.64\text{‰}$ marks the return of a functioning marine ecosystem and the restoration of the biological pump.

Discussion: Linking Diversity to Function

This study demonstrates that the end-Ordovician event was not just a loss of species diversity but a fundamental breakdown of the ocean's biogeochemical cycling. The correlation between the crash in Cd isotopes and the enrichment of Zn and P in the sediments suggests that unused nutrients accumulated in the water column because phytoplankton were no longer consuming them.

The "Aha" moment of this research is the evidence that the biological pump didn't just slow down—it effectively reached a "cliff-edge" drop. This suggests that the extinction of 80% of marine species was inextricably linked to a total collapse of the ocean's energy production system.

Limitations and Future Work

While the Wangjiawan section is a globally significant GSSP, geological records can be influenced by local environmental factors such as regional upwelling or basin restriction. To confirm that this productivity crash was a synchronous global phenomenon, future research must test the Cd-isotope proxy across other Ordovician-Silurian boundary sections worldwide. Additionally, further investigation is needed to identify the specific triggers—such as rapid cooling or changes in ocean oxygenation—that caused productivity to peak and then fail so abruptly during the Hirnantian.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although the end-Ordovician mass extinction caused the disappearance of >80% of contemporaneous marine species, many aspects of this biocrisis remain poorly understood.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2020abrupt,
  author = {He Zhao and Thomas J. Algeo and Zhong‐Qiang Chen and Simon W. Poulton and Yongsheng Liu and Zhaochu Hu and Xiangdong Wang and Lei Zhang},
  title = {{Abrupt Decline in Primary Productivity Coincident with the End-Ordovician Mass Extinction: Cadmium Isotopic Evidence from South Chin}},
  booktitle = {Goldschmidt},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.46427/gold2020.3162},
}
Figure