Abrupt changes in algal biomass of thousands of US lakes are related to climate and are more likely in low-disturbance watersheds

Patricia A. Soranno, Patrick J. Hanly, Katherine E. Webster, Tyler Wagner, Andrew McDonald, Arnab Shuvo, Erin M. Schliep, Kaitlin L. Reinl, Ian M. McCullough, Pang‐Ning Tan, Noah R. Lottig, Kendra Spence CheruvelilProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Climate change is expected to increase algal blooms in lakes, but the direct causal link and potential for ecosystem-wide "regime shifts" have been hard to prove. This study analyzed 34 years of data from over 24,000 US lakes and found that climate directly influences algal biomass in about a third of them. Interestingly, these climate-driven changes are often abrupt but temporary, and regime shifts are rare, with the strongest climate signals appearing in lakes with low human disturbance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Predicting how ecosystems will respond to climate change is a major scientific challenge. For lakes, a key concern is the intensification of algal blooms, which can lead to eutrophication, oxygen depletion, and loss of biodiversity. While rising temperatures and altered precipitation patterns are suspected drivers, directly attributing changes in algal biomass (measured as chlorophyll-a, or CHL) to climate has been difficult. This is due to several factors: natural climate variability can mask long-term trends, lakes are influenced by a complex web of local factors (like nutrient inputs from land use), and the non-linear dynamics required for "regime shifts" (sudden, large-scale ecosystem transformations) are hard to detect and prove. This paper aims to disentangle these complexities by quantifying the causal relationship between climate and lake algal biomass across a vast number of lakes and assessing the potential for regime shifts.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze their extensive dataset:

  • Time Series Modeling (Process): They first assessed the predictability of each lake's CHL time series. For predictable series, they used empirical dynamic modeling to distinguish between linear-stochastic (predictable but not state-dependent) and nonlinear (state-dependent, potentially leading to regime shifts) dynamics. Causality was then inferred using either vector autoregressive models (for linear-stochastic series, akin to Granger causality) or convergence cross-mapping (for nonlinear series). This allowed them to identify lakes where CHL was "climate-causal."
  • Temporal Pattern Analysis (Pattern): They clustered the CHL time series based on their interannual patterns using agglomerative hierarchical clustering. These clusters were further refined into nine "ecological temporal classes" based on indicators like abrupt changes (breakpoints and anomalies) and monotonic trends.
  • Integration: The core of their approach was to integrate these "process" (climate causality) and "pattern" (temporal class) analyses. They examined how the proportion of climate-causal lakes varied across different ecological temporal classes and, crucially, how these relationships were influenced by various environmental context variables (lake characteristics, watershed features, hydrology, and climate). This allowed them to build a framework for understanding where and why climate effects are most pronounced.

Datasets

  • Lake Chlorophyll-a (CHL) Data: The study utilized a dataset of validated, satellite-derived annual median CHL concentrations for 24,452 lakes across the conterminous United States. This data spanned 34 years (1985-2018) and was sourced from the LAGOS-US LANDSAT module.
  • Climate Data: Sixteen climate metrics were used, including temperature, precipitation, drought indices, and the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO), aggregated across four time periods (water year, spring, summer, and preceding winter).
  • Environmental Context Data: A comprehensive suite of data from the LAGOS-US Research Platform was used to characterize lakes and their watersheds. This included lake morphometry, watershed soils, hydrology, land use/cover, and climate normals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Climate Causality is Not Universal: The finding that climate directly influences algal biomass in only about a third of lakes is significant. It highlights that while climate is a factor, it's not the sole or even dominant driver in many aquatic systems.
  • Abrupt but Temporary Changes Dominate: The prevalence of abrupt but temporary shifts (71% of climate-causal lakes) over persistent changes or true regime shifts is a crucial nuance. This suggests that many lakes are resilient to short-term climate fluctuations, rather than undergoing fundamental, long-term transformations.
  • Human Disturbance Masks Climate Signals: The inverse relationship between human disturbance (especially agriculture) and climate causality is a powerful insight. High nutrient loads from human activities can overwhelm or mask the more subtle effects of climate change, making it harder to detect climate-driven algal blooms in heavily impacted lakes.
  • Low-Disturbance Lakes are Climate Sentinels: Lakes with minimal human disturbance, cooler summer temperatures, and extreme environmental conditions (like high elevation) are more likely to show clear climate-driven responses. These lakes act as sensitive indicators of climate change.
  • Regime Shifts Remain Rare (at this scale/timeframe): The low percentage of lakes showing potential for regime shifts (13%) and even fewer exhibiting persistent increases (4%) suggests that, at least over the 34-year study period and at this continental scale, true regime shifts driven solely by climate are not the norm.

Key Results

  • 34% of lakes showed climate-causal relationships with algal biomass.
  • Of these climate-causal lakes, 71% exhibited abrupt but mostly temporary shifts.
  • Only 13% had the potential for regime shifts.
  • 4.5% of all climate-causal time series were nonlinear, a key characteristic for regime shift potential.
  • Climate causality was most likely in lakes with minimal human disturbance and cooler summer temperatures.
  • Climate causality was least likely in lakes with high human disturbance, where it may be masked.
  • 54.2% of lake CHL time series were unpredictable, meaning they could not be modeled with the current data and methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unpredictability: A significant limitation is that over half of the lake CHL time series were unpredictable, preventing the analysis of climate effects. The authors suggest that longer time series data and continued climate change may improve the ability to detect effects in these lakes.
  • Statistical Power: The authors acknowledge that using a P < 0.05 threshold for statistical significance across multiple analytical steps might increase the potential for Type I errors (false positives). They opted for this to maximize their power to detect effects, given the relatively short time series.
  • Generalizability: While the study covers a vast number of lakes across the US, the framework developed could be applied to other ecosystem types and regions worldwide. Future work could explore how these patterns hold up in different geographical and ecological contexts.
  • Future Climate Scenarios: The current study focuses on historical climate data. Extending this framework to predict future algal biomass responses under various climate change scenarios would be a valuable next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Climate change is predicted to intensify lake algal blooms globally and result in regime shifts. However, observed increases in algal biomass do not consistently correlate with air temperature or precipitation, and evidence is lacking for a causal effect of climate or the nonlinear dynamics needed to demonstrate regime shifts. We modeled the causal effects of climate on annual lake chlorophyll (a measure of algal biomass) over 34 y for 24,452 lakes across broad ecoclimatic zones of the United States and evaluated the potential for regime shifts. We found that algal biomass was causally related to climate in 34% of lakes. In these cases, 71% exhibited abrupt but mostly temporary shifts as opposed to persistent changes, 13% had the potential for regime shifts. Climate was causally related to algal biomass in lakes experiencing all levels of human disturbance, but with different likelihood. Climate causality was most likely to be observed in lakes with minimal human disturbance and cooler summer temperatures that have increased over the 34 y studied. Climate causality was variable in lakes with low to moderate human disturbance, and least likely in lakes with high human disturbance, which may mask climate causality. Our results explain some of the previously observed heterogeneous climate responses of lake algal biomass globally and they can be used to predict future climate effects on lakes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{soranno2025abrupt,
  author = {Patricia A. Soranno and Patrick J. Hanly and Katherine E. Webster and Tyler Wagner and Andrew McDonald and Arnab Shuvo and Erin M. Schliep and Kaitlin L. Reinl and Ian M. McCullough and Pang‐Ning Tan and Noah R. Lottig and Kendra Spence Cheruvelil},
  title = {{Abrupt changes in algal biomass of thousands of US lakes are related to climate and are more likely in low-disturbance watersheds}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.2416172122},
}
Figure