Abnormal X : autosome ratio, but normal X chromosome inactivation in human triploid cultures

Stanley M. Gartler, Kartik Varadarajan, Ping Luo, Thomas H. Norwood, Theresa K. Canfield, R. Scott HansenBMC 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates X chromosome inactivation (XCI) in human triploid cells, which have an abnormal X:autosome ratio. The researchers found that despite this imbalance, the fundamental mechanisms of XCI appear to function normally, suggesting that the "counting" mechanism for XCI might be more flexible than previously thought. This work sheds light on the robustness of XCI and its potential role in the inviability of triploid conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In mammals, females have two X chromosomes, while males have one. To ensure equal expression of X-linked genes, one of the two X chromosomes in female cells is inactivated (XCI). This process is thought to be governed by a "counting" mechanism that ensures one active X chromosome (Xa) per diploid set of autosomes. Triploid individuals have three sets of chromosomes (e.g., XXX or XXY), meaning they cannot achieve this ideal X:autosome ratio. This raises questions about how XCI functions in such conditions and whether the abnormal ratio leads to developmental abnormalities or inviability. Previous studies in mice suggested a consistent XCI pattern in triploids, but human triploid data was less clear, with some suggesting unstable XCI patterns. This paper aims to clarify the XCI patterns in human triploids and assess the normality of the underlying XCI mechanisms.

Methods

The researchers utilized several key techniques to study XCI in human triploid fibroblast cultures:

  • XIST RNA FISH (Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization): This technique visualizes the XIST RNA "cloud" that forms around an inactive X chromosome (Xi). By counting these bodies, the researchers could determine the number of inactive X chromosomes in individual cells.
  • X chromosome enumeration using FISH: A probe targeting the centromeric region of the X chromosome was used to count the total number of X chromosomes in cells. This helped confirm the ploidy and assess for X chromosome loss.
  • Cell culture and clonal analysis: Triploid cells were cultured, and individual clones were isolated and analyzed. This allowed the researchers to assess the stability of XCI patterns and identify potential selective advantages of certain cell types.
  • DNA methylation analysis: The methylation status of the G6PD gene promoter, a known marker of XCI, was analyzed. This involved bisulfite conversion of DNA followed by PCR amplification, cloning, and sequencing to determine methylation patterns on individual DNA strands. This method assesses the epigenetic state of the inactive X.
  • Quantitative XIST RNA signal analysis: Epifluorescence imaging was used to quantify the intensity of XIST RNA signals, comparing them between normal and triploid cells to assess if XIST expression levels were affected by the abnormal X:autosome ratio.

Datasets

The study used fibroblast cultures from six human XXX triploid individuals. These included cultures derived from embryonic fetal specimens and from newborns. Control cultures from normal female, normal male, and a trisomy X individual were also used for comparison. No new benchmark datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Robustness of XCI: The most striking finding is that despite the abnormal X:autosome ratio in triploids, the core machinery of XCI appears to function normally. This suggests that the "counting" mechanism might be more adaptable than a strict ratio-dependent system.
  • Selective advantage of XaXaXi cells: In cultures, there was a clear tendency for cells with a single inactive X (XaXaXi) to outgrow cells with two inactive X's (XaXiXi). This suggests a growth advantage for cells with fewer inactive X chromosomes, potentially contributing to the observed XCI patterns in later passages.
  • XIST RNA and DNA methylation are normal: The intensity and morphology of XIST RNA signals, as well as the DNA methylation patterns at the G6PD locus, were comparable to those in normal female cells. This indicates that the epigenetic marking and silencing of the inactive X chromosome are preserved.
  • Potential role in triploid inviability: While XCI mechanisms seem normal, the inability to achieve the ideal X:autosome ratio might still contribute to the inviability of triploid conditions, though the paper notes that tetraploids, which can achieve the ratio, are also inviable, suggesting a more complex picture.

Key Results

  • Human XXX triploid fibroblast cultures showed a mosaic pattern of XCI, with cells having either one inactive X (XaXaXi) or two inactive X's (XaXiXi).
  • Over time in culture, there was a significant decrease in the proportion of cells with two inactive X's and a corresponding increase in cells with one inactive X.
  • Clonal analyses revealed that XaXaXi clones were much more numerous and grew better than XaXiXi clones, indicating a selective growth advantage for cells with fewer inactive X chromosomes.
  • XIST RNA FISH signals and G6PD promoter methylation patterns were consistent with normal XCI in both single- and double-inactive X cells in triploids.
  • Quantitative analysis showed that XIST RNA levels on inactive X chromosomes were comparable to those in normal female cells, even in triploids with two inactive X's.
  • X chromosome loss was observed in triploid cells, but it did not fully explain the shift towards single-inactive X cells.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their sampling of methylation patterns might not be exhaustive enough to provide definitive statistical significance. They also note that the inviability of triploids is complex and may not solely be due to the inability to achieve the X:autosome ratio, as tetraploids also face inviability.

Future work could involve:

  • Studies of expressed polymorphic markers: Using triallelic markers in clonal triploid cultures could provide further insights into the stability and patterns of XCI.
  • Investigating Xa up-regulation: The paper highlights the importance of transcriptional up-regulation of the active X chromosome (Xa) for dosage compensation. Further research is needed to understand the mechanisms of Xa up-regulation in mammals and whether it is affected by ploidy.
  • Distinguishing XCI models: The observed selective advantage of XaXaXi cells in human triploids could help differentiate between models of XCI, particularly the "episome" model versus the "autosomal-dependent" model. If XaXaXi cells arise from segregation errors or Xi reactivation, it would support certain models over others.

Summary updated

Abstract

The initial X inactivation pattern in human triploids, therefore, is likely to resemble the pattern that predominates in murine triploids, i.e., a single Xa, with the remaining X's inactive. Furthermore, our studies of XIST RNA accumulation and promoter methylation suggest that the basic features of XCI are normal in triploids despite the abnormal X:autosome ratio.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gartler2006abnormal,
  author = {Stanley M. Gartler and Kartik Varadarajan and Ping Luo and Thomas H. Norwood and Theresa K. Canfield and R. Scott Hansen},
  title = {{Abnormal X : autosome ratio, but normal X chromosome inactivation in human triploid cultures}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1186/1471-2156-7-41},
}
Figure