Abnormal thermal expansion coefficients in (Nd1−xDyx)2Zr2O7pyrochlore: The effect of low-lying optical phonons

Zesheng Yang, Yi Li, Wei Pan, Chunlei WanJournal of Advanced Ceramics 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Chemical doping is a standard strategy to tune the thermal expansion coefficient (TEC) of ceramics in engineering applications. However, resultant TEC values typically follow Vegard’s law, as doping generally does not modify the fundamental nature of chemical bonding or its anharmonicity. In this study, we report abnormal TEC behavior in (Nd$_{1-x}$Dy$_x$)$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$ ceramics, where TEC values remarkably exceed predictions from Vegard’s law and even surpass the values of the constituent end-members, Nd$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$ and Dy$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$. Beyond a reduction in lattice energy associated with increasing Dy content ($x$), we attribute this increase to high concentrations of Dy dopants within the pyrochlore (P) region. This doping softens low-lying optical phonon modes, inducing a strongly avoided crossing with acoustic phonon branches and enhancing lattice anharmonicity. These findings suggest a novel pathway to transcend the limitations of Vegard’s law, offering new opportunities for developing thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) with minimized thermal mismatch and extended service life.

Introduction

In high-temperature engineering environments, such as gas-turbine engines, metallic components are protected by ceramic Thermal Barrier Coatings (TBCs). A critical failure mechanism in these systems is "thermal mismatch," occurring because metallic substrates expand significantly more than ceramic coatings during heating. This discrepancy generates substantial internal stress, leading to cracking and eventual delamination of the coating.

To mitigate this, researchers aim to increase the Thermal Expansion Coefficient (TEC) of ceramic materials. Traditionally, this is achieved through chemical doping. However, most solid solutions follow Vegard’s Law, which predicts that the physical properties of a mixture will be a linear average of its constituents. Consequently, the TEC of a doped ceramic is usually bounded by the values of its parent compounds. This research explores a method to break this linear restriction, achieving "abnormally" high TEC values in the (Nd$_{1-x}$Dy$_x$)$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$ system.

Methodology

The study utilized a dual approach combining experimental synthesis with advanced computational modeling.

Synthesis and Characterization

A series of (Nd$_{1-x}$Dy$_x$)$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$ ceramics ($x = 0$ to $1.0$ in increments of $0.1$) were synthesized using standard solid-state reaction methods. The crystal structures were analyzed via X-ray Diffraction (XRD) with Rietveld refinement. Raman spectroscopy was employed to monitor the structural transition from an ordered pyrochlore (P) phase to a disordered defect-fluorite (F) phase as the Dy concentration increased.

Property Measurement

Thermal expansion was measured up to 1400°C using a thermomechanical analyzer (TMA). Thermal conductivity was determined through laser flash analysis.

Theoretical Calculations

First-principles calculations were performed using Density Functional Theory (DFT) and the PHONOPY package. The researchers calculated phonon dispersion relations and the Grüneisen parameter, which serves as a quantitative measure of lattice anharmonicity—the degree to which atomic vibrations deviate from simple harmonic motion.

Results and Discussion

Breaking Vegard’s Law

The experimental results revealed a significant deviation from Vegard’s Law. The composition with $x=0.5$ (NdDyZr$_2$O$_7$) exhibited a TEC of $11.36 \times 10^{-6}$ K$^{-1}$ at 1400°C. This value is approximately 10% higher than the linear prediction and exceeds the TECs of both pure Nd$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$ and pure Dy$_2$Zr$_2$O$_7$.

The Mechanism of Abnormal Expansion

The researchers identified two primary drivers for this behavior:

  1. Lattice Energy Reduction: Increasing the molar fraction of Dy "softens" the crystal lattice, reducing the overall lattice energy.
  2. Phonon-Driven Anharmonicity: Heavy Dysprosium (Dy) atoms act as "rattlers" within the pyrochlore lattice. Due to their mass and relatively weak bonding, they generate low-frequency optical phonon modes. In the $x=0.5$ composition, these low-lying optical branches interact with acoustic phonon branches. Instead of crossing, they exhibit "avoided crossing," which distorts the phonon dispersion and significantly increases the Grüneisen parameter. This enhanced anharmonicity leads to greater asymmetric atomic vibrations, resulting in higher thermal expansion.

Structural Sensitivity

This abnormal expansion is highly sensitive to the crystal structure. The effect is prominent only while the material maintains an ordered pyrochlore structure. When Dy concentration exceeds $x = 0.6$, the material transitions to a disordered fluorite structure. In this disordered state, the specific localized environment required for the "rattling" effect disappears, and the TEC values return to levels predicted by Vegard’s Law.

Thermal Conductivity

In addition to the high TEC, the $x=0.5$ sample demonstrated significantly lower thermal conductivity compared to the pure end-members. This combination of high expansion (matching the metal substrate) and low conductivity (providing better insulation) makes these mixed pyrochlores ideal candidates for next-generation TBCs.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that strategic chemical doping can induce specific phonon interactions that transcend conventional property limits. By leveraging the "avoided crossing" of phonon branches, researchers can engineer ceramics with thermal expansion coefficients that exceed those of their constituent parts. While future work must address the long-term phase stability of these materials under operational conditions, this discovery provides a robust framework for designing high-performance coatings and ceramic/metal composites with minimized thermal mismatch.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chemical doping is a normal strategy to tune thermal expansion coefficient (TEC) of ceramics in engineering applications, but the resultant TEC values usually follow Vegard’s law, as doping does not modify the nature of chemical bonding in ceramics and its anharmonicity. In this paper, we report abnormal TEC behavior in (Nd<sub>1−<i>x</i></sub>Dy<sub><i>x</i></sub>)<sub>2</sub>Zr<sub>2</sub>O<sub>7</sub> ceramics, where the TEC values remarkably exceed the values predicted by Vegard’s law and even exceed the values obtained for two constituents Nd<sub>2</sub>Zr<sub>2</sub>O<sub>7</sub> and Dy<sub>2</sub>Zr<sub>2</sub>O<sub>7</sub>. In addition to a reduction in lattice energy with an increasing molar fraction of Dy (<i>x</i>) value, we attribute the additional increase in the TEC to the high concentration of Dy dopants in a pyrochlore (P) region, which can soften low-lying optical phonon modes and induce strongly avoided crossing with acoustic phonon branches and enhanced anharmonicity. We believe that this finding can provide a new route to break through the restriction imposed by the conventional Vegard’s law on the TEC values and bring new opportunities for thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) or ceramic/metal composites towards realizing minimized thermal mismatch and prolonged service life during thermal cycling.
BibTeX
@article{yang2023abnormal,
  author = {Zesheng Yang and Yi Li and Wei Pan and Chunlei Wan},
  title = {{Abnormal thermal expansion coefficients in (Nd<sub>1−<i>x</i></sub>Dy<sub><i>x</i></sub>)<sub>2</sub>Zr<sub>2</sub>O<sub>7</sub>pyrochlore: The effect of low-lying optical phonons}},
  journal = {Journal of Advanced Ceramics},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.26599/jac.2023.9220734},
}
Figure