Abnormal Exercise Electrocardiography With Normal Stress Echocardiography Is Associated With Subclinical Coronary Atherosclerosis

Jessica Duran, Peter Shrader, Chuan Hong, François Haddad, Everton J. Santana, Nicholas Cauwenberghs, Tatiana Kuznetsova, Michael Salerno, Gerald S. Bloomfield, Lynne Koweek, Adrian F. Hernandez, Kenneth W. Mahaffey, Svati H. Shah, Pamela S. Douglas, Melissa A. Daubert, on behalf of the Project Baseline Health Study GroupCirculation 2025 · DOI

Abstract: URL: https://www.clinicaltrials.gov; Unique identifier: NCT03154346.

Introduction

In cardiovascular medicine, the exercise stress test is a fundamental diagnostic tool that integrates two primary data streams: electrical activity (ECG) and mechanical wall motion (Echocardiography). A frequent clinical challenge arises when these signals are discordant—specifically, when the ECG indicates ischemia but the stress echocardiogram appears normal (+ECG/−Echo). Historically, clinicians often dismissed these abnormal ECG findings as "false positives" because echocardiography is considered a more specific imaging modality. However, emerging data suggests these patients may face an elevated risk of adverse cardiovascular events. This study investigates whether this electrical-mechanical discordance serves as a marker for subclinical coronary artery disease (CAD) that has not yet progressed to obstructive levels.

Methods

Researchers analyzed data from the Project Baseline Health Study (PBHS), a high-tech observational cohort designed to map human health at a granular level. The study focused on 1,630 asymptomatic participants who underwent both an exercise stress echocardiogram and a Coronary Artery Calcium (CAC) scan via CT.

Study population flowchart and group stratification

Participants were stratified into three distinct groups based on their stress test results:

  1. Concordant Negative (−ECG/−Echo): Normal ECG and normal Echo (n=1,503).
  2. Discordant (+ECG/−Echo): Abnormal ECG but normal Echo (n=105).
  3. Positive (+Echo): Abnormal Echo (n=22).

Multivariable regression models were employed to determine if discordant results predicted the burden of coronary plaque, adjusting for traditional risk factors such as age, sex, smoking status, and cholesterol levels.

Key Results

The study found that discordant results are not mere false positives but are strongly associated with a higher burden of subclinical atherosclerosis.

  • Increased Plaque Burden: The mean CAC score for the discordant (+ECG/−Echo) group was 198, significantly higher than the 53 observed in the concordant negative group ($P < 0.001$).
  • Severe Disease Risk: After adjusting for age and other risk factors, individuals in the discordant group were 4.5 times more likely to have a CAC score ≥400, a threshold indicating high risk for future cardiovascular events.
  • Statin Eligibility: Nearly one-third of the discordant group had CAC scores >100. Under current clinical guidelines, this level often warrants statin therapy, yet many of these individuals did not meet the standard 7.5% risk threshold for treatment based on traditional calculators alone.
Distribution of Coronary Artery Calcium (CAC) scores across study groups

Discussion and Insights

The findings suggest that an abnormal exercise ECG provides critical information that should not be ignored, even when the accompanying echocardiogram is normal. This discordance may represent the "ischemic cascade," where electrical changes occur before mechanical failures. The +ECG/−Echo group likely represents an early or non-obstructive stage of disease where the heart is struggling electrically but maintaining mechanical output.

Furthermore, the association between discordant results and plaque burden remained significant even after adjusting for ASCVD risk scores, indicating that the stress test provides incremental diagnostic value beyond traditional risk assessments.

Limitations and Future Work

As an observational study, these results demonstrate an association rather than direct causation. The PBHS cohort is relatively young and healthy, resulting in a low number of clinical events (heart attacks or strokes) during the 4.3-year follow-up, which limits statistical power for long-term outcome prediction. Future research should investigate whether performing CAC scans specifically on patients with discordant stress tests improves clinical outcomes and explore the role of Coronary Microvascular Dysfunction (CMD) in these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

URL: https://www.clinicaltrials.gov; Unique identifier: NCT03154346.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{duran2025abnormal,
  author = {Jessica Duran and Peter Shrader and Chuan Hong and François Haddad and Everton J. Santana and Nicholas Cauwenberghs and Tatiana Kuznetsova and Michael Salerno and Gerald S. Bloomfield and Lynne Koweek and Adrian F. Hernandez and Kenneth W. Mahaffey and Svati H. Shah and Pamela S. Douglas and Melissa A. Daubert and on behalf of the Project Baseline Health Study Group},
  title = {{Abnormal Exercise Electrocardiography With Normal Stress Echocardiography Is Associated With Subclinical Coronary Atherosclerosis}},
  booktitle = {Circulation},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1161/circimaging.124.017380},
}
Figure