TL;DR
This paper bridges the gap between two formalisms for modeling biological regulatory networks (BRNs): Process Hitting (PH) and Thomas' models. They introduce a method to infer the structure (Interaction Graph) and parameters of Thomas' models from a PH model, enabling more abstract and incomplete knowledge to be translated into a concrete, executable model. This is crucial for understanding complex biological systems where complete information is rarely available.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Biological regulatory networks (BRNs) are complex systems where genes and proteins interact to control cellular functions. Understanding these networks is key to deciphering biological processes and developing new therapies. However, modeling BRNs is challenging due to the sheer number of components and the often incomplete knowledge we have about their interactions.
Two popular modeling approaches exist:
- Thomas' models: These provide a discrete, qualitative representation of BRNs, capturing the different expression levels of components and their interactions. However, specifying the exact parameters for these models can be difficult, especially for large networks.
- Process Hitting (PH): This is a more recent, abstract formalism that allows modeling concurrent systems with partial knowledge. It's particularly useful for handling large networks and situations where interactions are not fully understood.
The problem is that while PH models are good for abstract representation and handling incomplete information, they are not directly executable for simulating dynamics. Thomas' models, on the other hand, are executable but require precise parameterization, which is often hard to obtain. This paper aims to bridge this gap by showing how to translate the abstract information captured in a PH model into a concrete, executable Thomas' model.
Methods
The authors propose a two-step method to infer a Thomas' model from a Process Hitting (PH) model:
- Interaction Graph (IG) Inference:
- They first infer the Interaction Graph (IG), which defines the structure of the BRN (which components influence which others and whether the influence is positive or negative).
- This is done by analyzing the "focal processes" within the PH model. Focal processes represent states that are reached after a sequence of actions and are crucial for understanding the underlying dynamics.
- They define "local influence switches" by comparing the focal processes of a component under different conditions (e.g., when a regulator is at level $b_i$ versus $b_{i+1}$). Positive or negative influence switches are identified based on these comparisons.
- An unsigned edge is inferred if both positive and negative influence switches are observed.
- Parametrization Inference:
- Once the IG is established, they infer the discrete parameters for the Thomas' model. These parameters define the "focal level intervals" for each component, dictating how it evolves based on its regulators.
- This inference also relies on analyzing focal processes in the PH model, but this time considering specific configurations of regulators.
- A key challenge is that some parameters might remain undetermined due to conflicting influences or oscillations in the PH model. To address this, they employ abductive reasoning and Answer Set Programming (ASP) to find all admissible parametrizations that are consistent with the inferred IG and the original PH dynamics. This means finding a set of parameters that, when combined with the IG, produce a BRN behavior that is a subset of the original PH's behavior.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses toy examples and refers to existing models from the literature for illustration and validation.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Bridging Abstraction and Concreteness: The core insight is that an abstract PH model, even with incomplete knowledge, contains enough information to infer a concrete, executable Thomas' model. This is a significant step towards making complex biological models more tractable.
- Focal Processes as the Key: The concept of "focal processes" in PH is identified as the crucial element for inferring both the structure (IG) and dynamics (parameters) of Thomas' models.
- Abduction for Parameter Completion: The use of abductive reasoning and ASP to find admissible parametrizations is a powerful technique for handling indeterminacy. It allows for the generation of a family of valid models when a unique one cannot be determined, which is realistic for biological systems.
- Cooperative Sorts for Refinement: The paper highlights how "cooperative sorts" in PH can help resolve ambiguities and lead to more precise parameter inference, as demonstrated in the metazoan segmentation example.
Key Results
- The paper successfully demonstrates the inference of Interaction Graphs and parameters for Thomas' models from PH models using toy examples and a metazoan segmentation example.
- They show that their method can handle BRNs with up to 40 components, indicating scalability.
- The implementation of their method as a tool named
ph2thomasis mentioned, which can perform IG and parameter inference in less than a second for large models. - The abductive reasoning approach allows for the enumeration of multiple compatible Thomas' models when parameters are not fully determined, providing a family of plausible biological network behaviors.
Limitations and Future Work
- Unsigned Edges: The paper acknowledges that their current method struggles with "unsigned edges" in the inferred IG, which represent influences where the sign (positive/negative) is not clearly determined. Future work aims to explore new semantics to tackle these influences.
- Indeterministic Evolutions/Oscillations: The method can face challenges when the PH model leads to indeterministic evolutions or oscillations, making parameter inference impossible. The authors suggest that removing undesired actions or using cooperative sorts can help mitigate this.
- Completeness of PH Models: The accuracy of the inferred Thomas' model is dependent on the completeness and correctness of the initial PH model. If the PH model lacks crucial actions or information, the inferred model might not fully capture the biological reality.
- Future Work: The authors plan to explore new semantics for BRNs to handle influences currently represented by unsigned edges. They also aim to further refine the understanding of the relationship between PH and Thomas' models.
Summary updated