TL;DR
This study investigated whether very low birth weight (VLBW) adults born preterm have altered abdominal adipose tissue and liver fat compared to their term-born siblings. The findings suggest that previously reported differences in fat accumulation might be explained by shared genetic or environmental factors within families, as no significant differences were found in fat volumes or liver fat content. However, VLBW adults showed less unsaturation in subcutaneous adipose tissue, hinting at potential differences in its metabolic activity.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Preterm birth, especially at very low birth weight (VLBW, < 1500g), is linked to an increased risk of cardiovascular and metabolic issues later in life. Some research suggests that this increased risk might be due to higher levels of visceral (abdominal) and ectopic (e.g., liver) fat. However, previous studies have yielded heterogeneous results, possibly due to methodological differences or the use of unrelated controls, which don't account for shared familial factors. This paper aims to clarify whether these observed differences in fat distribution and composition persist into adulthood in VLBW individuals, using a unique sibling-control design to better isolate the effects of prematurity from shared genetic and environmental influences.
Methods
The researchers employed a combination of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) techniques. T1-weighted MRI was used to quantify the volumes of total, subcutaneous, and visceral abdominal adipose tissue. MRS was utilized to assess the hepatic triglyceride content (a marker of liver fat accumulation) and the degree of unsaturation in subcutaneous abdominal adipose tissue and bone marrow. Unsaturation, indicated by the presence of double bonds in fatty acid chains, is thought to reflect metabolic activity and energy storage. The study used paired t-tests and linear mixed models to compare the VLBW group with their term-born siblings, adjusting for various potential confounders like age, sex, maternal factors, and the participants' own BMI.
Datasets
The study utilized data from 78 adults born preterm at VLBW and 72 of their term-born, same-sex siblings. These participants were recruited from existing cohorts and the Finnish Medical Birth Register. The data collection occurred between June 2014 and June 2017. No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Sibling Control Power: The use of same-sex siblings as controls is a significant methodological strength. It helps to control for a substantial portion of genetic and shared environmental factors that could otherwise confound the results, providing a clearer picture of the specific impact of VLBW.
- Fat Volume Similarity: The most striking finding is the lack of significant differences in abdominal adipose tissue volumes (total, subcutaneous, and visceral) between VLBW adults and their siblings. This challenges some previous findings that suggested increased adiposity in VLBW individuals.
- Metabolic Activity Hint: While fat volumes were similar, the reduced unsaturation in subcutaneous adipose tissue of VLBW adults is a key insight. This suggests that while the amount of fat might be similar, its composition or metabolic activity could be different, potentially impacting energy storage and utilization.
- Liver Fat Equivalence: Similar hepatic triglyceride content between groups further supports the idea that VLBW itself, independent of shared familial factors, may not lead to increased liver fat accumulation in adulthood.
Key Results
- After adjusting for age, sex, and maternal/perinatal factors, there were no statistically significant differences in:
- Total abdominal adipose tissue volume (mean difference: 1.05%, 95% CI -13.7%, 18.4%)
- Subcutaneous adipose tissue volume (mean difference: -0.48%, 95% CI -14.8%, 16.3%)
- Visceral adipose tissue volume (mean difference: 7.96%, 95% CI -10.4%, 30.1%)
- Hepatic triglyceride content (mean difference: 12.05%, 95% CI -20.16%, 57.26%)
- A statistically significant finding was a lower degree of unsaturation in subcutaneous abdominal adipose tissue in VLBW adults (mean difference: -4.74%, 95% CI -9.19%, -0.08%).
- No significant difference was observed in bone marrow unsaturation (mean difference: 1.68%, 95% CI -1.86%, 5.35%).
Limitations and Future Work
- Sibling Overlap: The study acknowledges that the sibling design might lead to an "overexpression of sibpairs who feel close to each other," potentially leading them to share more lifestyle characteristics than a random sibling pair.
- Age Difference: A maximum age difference of 10 years between siblings means that environmental conditions could have changed significantly during that time.
- Dietary/Nutritional Factors: The study did not explore the impact of dietary and nutritional factors on abdominal adipose tissue.
- dSAT vs. SSAT: The measurement of subcutaneous adipose tissue unsaturation from dSAT (deep subcutaneous adipose tissue) might not fully represent SSAT (superficial subcutaneous adipose tissue), and their unsaturation could differ.
- Future Work: The authors suggest further studies to investigate how adipose tissue unsaturation, metabolic outcomes, fat composition, and energy expenditure are linked. They also propose that adipose tissue biopsy verification could provide clarity. Exploring the role of dietary and nutritional factors is also recommended.
Summary updated