A Wide-Range and Calibration-Free Spectrometer Which Combines Wavelength Modulation and Direct Absorption Spectroscopy with Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy

Zhen Wang, Yanjun Du, Yanjun Ding, Zhimin Peng2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel spectrometer that combines two established techniques, Wavelength Modulation-Direct Absorption Spectroscopy (WM-DAS) and Continuous Wave Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy (CW-CRDS), to achieve a wide-range, calibration-free measurement of gas concentrations. This hybrid approach overcomes the limitations of each individual method, offering high precision across a vast dynamic range and enabling faster measurements.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Measuring gas concentrations accurately and efficiently is crucial in various fields, from environmental monitoring to industrial process control. However, existing spectroscopic techniques often face a trade-off between measurement range and precision. Direct Absorption Spectroscopy (DAS) is simple and effective for high concentrations but struggles with trace gases. Conversely, Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy (CRDS) excels at detecting weak absorption signals from trace gases but can be challenged by high concentrations due to signal saturation and reduced ringdown times. This paper addresses the need for a single instrument capable of accurately measuring gas concentrations across a broad dynamic range, from trace levels to high concentrations, without requiring frequent recalibration.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the synergistic combination of two techniques:

  • Wavelength Modulation-Direct Absorption Spectroscopy (WM-DAS): This method uses a tunable diode laser whose wavelength is modulated sinusoidally. By analyzing the transmitted light's intensity using Fast Fourier Transform (FFT), WM-DAS can effectively filter out noise and recover absorption spectra with high accuracy, even for weak absorption signals. The paper highlights their group's recent advancements in WM-DAS, achieving a root mean square error (RMSE) of spectral fitting around $3 \times 10^{-5}$ and a detection limit of approximately $3 \times 10^{-9} \text{ cm}^{-1}$ with a long optical path.
  • Continuous Wave Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy (CW-CRDS): CW-CRDS utilizes a high-finesse optical cavity to enhance the effective path length for light absorption. By measuring the decay time of light within the cavity (ringdown time, $\tau$), the absorption coefficient can be determined. This technique is known for its high sensitivity and precision, particularly for trace gas detection.

The key to their combined approach is a calibration-free baseline ringdown time ($\tau_0$) calculation. Instead of needing to measure the empty cavity ringdown time separately (which is sensitive to environmental factors and requires purging), they leverage the overlapping measurement range of WM-DAS and CW-CRDS. Specifically, they use the peak absorbance measured by WM-DAS and the ringdown time measured by CW-CRDS at the absorption line center to derive $\tau_0$. This eliminates the need for real-time calibration of $\tau_0$, significantly improving the measurement speed and simplifying the system.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using a gas mixture of CO and N2 at various concentrations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergy for Wide Range: Combining WM-DAS and CW-CRDS creates a powerful hybrid system that leverages the strengths of each. WM-DAS handles higher concentrations and provides accurate absorbance data, while CW-CRDS excels at low concentrations and provides precise ringdown time measurements.
  • Calibration-Free Operation: The novel method for calculating the baseline ringdown time ($\tau_0$) from the peak absorbance (WM-DAS) and the ringdown time with gas absorption (CW-CRDS) is a significant advancement. This eliminates a critical calibration step, making the system more practical for real-world applications.
  • Improved Measurement Speed: By fixing the laser wavelength at the absorption line center and using the derived $\tau_0$, the system can determine gas concentration by measuring only the ringdown time, drastically reducing the time required for each measurement.
  • Enhanced Precision at High Concentrations: While CW-CRDS struggles with high concentrations, the WM-DAS component of the hybrid system provides accurate absorbance data, which is then used to improve the overall measurement accuracy.

Key Results

  • Wide Dynamic Range: The spectrometer demonstrated a wide measurement range for CO, extending over five orders of magnitude, from 4 ppm to 1.09%.
  • High Precision: The measurement accuracy for different concentration ranges was reported as:
  • 5-10 ppm for 3650 ppm to 1.09%
    • 0.5-5 ppm for 101 ppm to 3650 ppm
    • ~0.5 ppm for 4 ppm to 101 ppm
  • Fast Measurement Speed: The measurement speed can be as fast as 10 ms.
  • Low Detection Limit: The detection limit for CO was found to be 35 ppb within 25 s.
  • Accurate $\tau_0$ Calculation: The relative error between the calculated and measured baseline ringdown time ($\tau_0$) was less than $4 \times 10^{-4}$.
  • Allan Deviation: At 101 ppm, CW-CRDS achieved a detection limit of 35 ppb in 25 s, while WM-DAS achieved 161 ppb.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Environmental Drifts: The paper acknowledges that drifts in temperature, pressure, and cavity length can affect WM-DAS measurements, while laser wavelength drift, temperature, and pressure can impact CW-CRDS. These factors can lead to unstable deviations in measurements over longer periods.
  • Mirror Contamination: For real-time industrial measurements, slow attenuation of $\tau_0$ due to mirror surface pollution is a potential issue.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further improvements in precision and SNR could lead to even wider ranges and faster measurements, enhancing the system's usability as an industrial gas sensor. The ability to obtain $\tau_0$ via linear fitting of $(c\tau)^{-1}$ and $\kappa$ is highlighted as beneficial for developing simple, fast, and calibration-free gas sensors.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{wang2020wide,
  author = {Zhen Wang and Yanjun Du and Yanjun Ding and Zhimin Peng},
  title = {{A Wide-Range and Calibration-Free Spectrometer Which Combines Wavelength Modulation and Direct Absorption Spectroscopy with Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/s20030585},
}
Figure