A Whole-Brain Topographic Ontology

Michael J. Arcaro, Margaret S. LivingstoneAnnual 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This review challenges the idea that specialized brain regions for processing specific categories (like faces or objects) are hardwired from birth. Instead, it proposes that a fundamental, innate "map-based topography" across the entire cortex provides a general architecture that is then shaped by experience to create these specialized domains. This framework offers a unified explanation for how the brain develops its complex functional organization.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, neuroscience has observed that different areas of the brain, particularly in the ventral visual pathway, are specialized for processing distinct categories of information (e.g., faces, places, objects). A central debate has been whether these specializations are innate (genetically predetermined) or learned through experience. While some evidence suggests innate predispositions (like infants looking at faces), other findings point to the necessity of experience (e.g., face domains developing after exposure). This paper aims to reconcile these seemingly contradictory findings and propose a unifying theory for the development of these specialized brain regions, not just in vision but across the entire cortex.

Methods

This paper is a review and theoretical synthesis, not an experimental study. The authors draw upon a vast body of existing research, including:

  • Neuroimaging studies (fMRI, PET): To map brain activity and identify specialized regions in humans and non-human primates.
  • Electrophysiological recordings: To study the activity of individual neurons.
  • Behavioral studies: To observe preferences and learning in infants, children, and animals.
  • Computational modeling: To test hypotheses about how experience shapes neural circuits.
  • Controlled rearing experiments: Manipulating early sensory experience in animals to assess its necessity for domain development.

The novelty lies in the proposed "activity-acting-on-maps" framework, which integrates topographic maps and experience-driven plasticity.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper synthesizes findings from numerous published studies, rather than presenting new experimental data or datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Innate Topography as the Foundation: The most fundamental innate organization of the cortex is not specialized domains, but rather "map-based topographies." These are orderly representations of sensory space (like retinotopy in vision) that are present from birth.
  • Experience Sculpts the Maps: These innate topographic maps provide a general architecture. Experience then acts on this architecture, refining and shaping it to create the specialized category-selective domains we observe in adults.
  • "Activity-Acting-on-Maps" Framework: This model proposes that intrinsic topographic organization (maps) provides the scaffolding, and activity-driven plasticity (experience) sculpts these maps into functional specializations.
  • Unified Explanation: This framework is proposed to apply not only to the visual cortex but to the development of specializations across the entire brain, including areas involved in language and other cognitive functions.
  • Cross-Modal Congruency: The consistent alignment of maps across different sensory modalities (vision, audition, touch) supports the idea of an underlying, shared topographic organization.

Key Results

  • Face Domain Development: Face-selective regions are not present at birth in monkeys and require visual experience to develop. However, infants show early looking preferences for faces, suggesting a predisposition.
  • Experience is Necessary and Sufficient: Controlled rearing experiments show that visual experience is necessary for face domain formation, and computational models suggest it can be sufficient for their emergence.
  • Text Domains as an Example: The development of specialized text processing regions in literate humans highlights the role of experience, as these domains are absent in illiterate individuals and emerge only after learning to read.
  • Intrinsic Maps Precede Specialization: Retinotopic maps, which represent visual space, are present from birth and precede the emergence of category-selective domains, suggesting they provide the underlying structure.
  • Species-Specific Variations Explained: Differences in the anatomical location of category domains across species (e.g., humans vs. macaques) can be explained by evolutionary adaptations in the underlying topographic maps.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Domain Formation: The authors acknowledge that domain formation for complex visual features is unlikely to be reducible to a single mechanism, involving combinatorial computations at each stage of the visual hierarchy.
  • Generalizability to Higher Cognition: While the authors propose their framework extends to higher cognitive functions like language, this remains a speculative extension requiring further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should focus on uncovering the developmental trajectory of these specialized circuits and exploring how the "activity-acting-on-maps" framework applies to other brain regions and cognitive functions. They also highlight the need to understand how intrinsic architectures constrain where specializations develop, even if experience is the primary driver of their content.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is a common view that the intricate array of specialized domains in the ventral visual pathway is innately prespecified. What this review postulates is that it is not. We explore the origins of domain specificity, hypothesizing that the adult brain emerges from an interplay between a domain-general map-based architecture, shaped by intrinsic mechanisms, and experience. We argue that the most fundamental innate organization of cortex in general, and not just the visual pathway, is a map-based topography that governs how the environment maps onto the brain, how brain areas interconnect, and ultimately, how the brain processes information.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{arcaro2024whole,
  author = {Michael J. Arcaro and Margaret S. Livingstone},
  title = {{A Whole-Brain Topographic Ontology}},
  booktitle = {Annual},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1146/annurev-neuro-082823-073701},
}
Figure